Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sunday School Teachers - Beware!, March 19, 2010
It is not often that I open a book by a minister and immediately find a description of his euphoric sex-on-the-beach encounter with his wife as a sacred experience. That is when I realized two things about this book:
* 1. Not everyone will like this material.
* 2. I will probably love it.
Randy Elrod presents a thoroughly researched paradigm shift in the way spiritual people approach sex. He is talking to Christians in this book (the brave soul,) but I think it calls to those who have cast away their Christian faith as well.
Sex, Lies and Religion is in its own words, "controversially redemptive" in its purpose. Controversial because not all people can reconcile paragraphs that deal with the very practical i.e. "how to use a vibrator to make erections last longer," with the spiritual concept of intercourse symbolizing intimacy with our passionate Redeemer.
As Elrod delves into how to masturbate without going blind OR becoming a pervert, many a Sunday School Teacher may blush in horror (While students from 12 to 120 may cheer out loud.) When he deals with the lies about fantasy (ergoing the football kind) he offers compassionate clues into the yearnings of humanity.
Whether tackling lies about nudity, gender equality, self-pleasure, sexual fantasy or "yada,yada, yada," he continually offers truth to set the reader free from condemnation. Elrod writes with the pen of an artist, philosopher and poet, painting pictures that glisten with supernatural love, acceptance and eroticism. He scoffs at the religious notion that the body is evil and unspiritual. He embraces the idea that ALL we do can be spiritual and draw us closer to God.
If I have any concerns with this book it would be that it is sometimes so deep and idealistic that its beauty may be lost on the average guy who likes to drink beer and play poker on his non-church days. The song of songs after all, calls not just to poets and philosphers but to all who have ever yearned to give and receive true love. It is in the presence of such overwhelming goodness, that vices and "unholiness" lose their appeal.
I love the book Sex, Lies, and Religion. Not just because it dares to go where no minister has gone before, but because it vibrates (no pun intended) with life that is abundant, love that is undefiled, and redemption that is complete.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What Christians should really think about sex, February 6, 2010
This review is from: Sex, Lies & Religion (Enjoying The Freedom of Unconditional Sexuality) (Kindle Edition)
There are many books out there about sex, even a lot of books about sex oriented toward Christians. There are not many that are about how to have a healthy view of sex as a Christian. Sex, Lies and Religion will be uncomfortable for many to read. It is about sex, the lies that religion and culture tell us about sex and how God has created sex, not just for pleasure and procreation, but as a teaching tool to show us how God wants to be intimate with us and desired by us.
I have two clear teaching points about sex that I can think about. These are not the bird and bees discussions. I had those too, but instead these two discussions were about what to think about sex. When I was in early high school (sophomore?), Charlie Peacock released an album called Love Life. I remember talking with my Mom about the fact that a large Christian bookstore chain would not carry the album because it included the line "they were naked and unashamed" (the song was Kiss Me Like a Woman). Apparently the decisions makers did not get the biblical reference. Or Charlie Peacock's point that we need to have more Christian expressions of positive sexuality, within marriage, to counteract the negative expressions of sexuality outside of marriage. My Mom though that the song was a beautiful expression of sexuality and disagreed with the decision. A second teaching point came as a pastoral intern during seminary, when my supervising pastor has a conversation with me about how uncomfortable some of the music we were singing in church made him. It used language that was too intimate and showed too much desire. He clearly thought there were sexual overtones to the music. I disagreed for pretty much the same reasons. I thought there were some sexual overtones to the music and thought that not only was it appropriate, but it illistrated the type of desire we should have for Christ and the church.
Randy Elrod's book follows in that vein. I think that this book should be discussed. Depending on the small group and their willingness to be open, it might be too intimate to discuss in small groups. But if there are any books that you should read together with your spouse, this is one of them. The book is divided into three sections: Sex, Lies (about sex) and Religion.
The opening section was what might make people most uncomfortable. There was a good discussion on masturbation and another on the purpose of sex. While I agree with most of the Lies section, it is probably organizationally the weakest of the three sections. It deviated from the other two sections and was more scattered. The third section was the most theologically oriented. The best parts were when he was trying to talk about why sex shows us to be intimate with God. I do wish he had relied a bit more on some of the theologians from the Middle Ages. Many of them were writing about similar themes and it would have grounded the teaching a bit more in historical theology.
Overall this was a good contribution to the Christian world I hope it sells well and it can help to counteract some bad teaching on sexuality.
___________
Disclosure: I received this book free as a digital advanced copy (a PDF file that I converted to read on my kindle.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Misses opportunity to share that this sexual freedom is a benefit of marriage, April 24, 2010
First, let me say that there is a lot of good in this book. When I started reading it, I knew that the author was a friend of my pastor, which gave him credibility and trust - neither of which was lost, however I think he missed a big opportunity on which this platform provided.
It wasn't until I got to Chapter 11, that I realized that I don't see this Christian author promoting this sexual freedom for within the boundaries of marriage at all. And that, for me, is a deal-breaker. I feel that this omission compromises the entire message of the book. On page 125, he says "The theological symbolism of sexual union (whether single or married) makes visible the invisible mystery of God." Huh?
He continually uses the words "lovers" and "couples" even when he refers to a Bible verse which specifically says husband and wife (not "couple") - pg. 137: "Sexual union is also liturgy and a sacrament. It is an entrance of a couple into the profound mystery of the Lord (Eph. 5) This is the essential calling of sexual communion and it's liturgy - the sacrament by which the couple becomes "one flesh."
On page 139 he does say "But selfless and dynamic lovemaking - particularly within the context of marriage - is not only a richly satisfying experience, but also one of sacramental ways encountering the mystery we call God (1 John 4:16). It's that word "particularly" that irks me. Again, I don't personally know Randy, but I feel he is saying - I guess it's better if you're married, but if you're not, don't worry, as long as your goal is to get to know God better, have sex with whomever and attain this goal.
There is an obvious amount of research that went into this book and I agree that much of what has been taught (or avoided for that matter) in church about sexuality is meant to make people feel shameful of their God-given sexual longings. Though it is recognized that these desires can become twisted and sinful...the author beautifully writes that "Sometimes the body longs for God in the most paradoxical of ways. Could it be, as one writer puts it, that every knock at the door of a brothel is actually a knock at the heart of God?" pg 21.
In the Lie about Self-Pleasure, which is interesting, and quite, frankly, made me laugh out-loud with this sentence: "Despite these cautions, self-pleasure does offer positive benefits. There is a reason God gave us hands and genitals with a complementary physical proximity." Funny? Yes. An argument that stands up? No. Some friends and I were discussing this and one said you can say the same thing about pulling the trigger on a gun - your finger has complementary physical proximity, right? Also, perhaps the proximity was given for more reasons than just self-pleasure, like, I don't know, washing/bathing? Not entirely disagreeing with that chapter, I'm just sayin'.
I wanted to like this book - but it would take quite a lot for me to recommend it, and when I do, I'd probably want to lend them my book with my notes. Again, there is A LOT of good in this book - from self-serving actions on a multitude of levels, lust, self-control (we tend to trade the ultimate for the immediate, pg. 116 and HALT - Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired, pg 117) and several other topics typically shied away from in many churches.
I would LOVE to hear a what Mark Driscoll has to say about this book :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|