Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Story of Survival and Faith-Based on a True Story-A+++!, March 24, 2005
This story was based on a true story that happened back in the year 1786. It took place in Austrailia.
Mary Broad was only 18 years of age, when in terrible poverty, she steals a silk hat. For that small crime, she was sentenced to death as it says in the beginning of the book. However, at the last minute she gets a break from hanging, and is instead, sentenced to 7 years of transportation. The fate though, is almost as horrifying as death, in that these prisoners in transportation live in VERY deplorable conditions.
The only thing Mary can do is have courage and be determined to live one day to the next. And that is exactly what she does, and is of lots of help and a friend to her fellow prisoners.
Throughout the story, there is birth of children, escape, and death.
I highly recommend the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Author gets points for sticking to the facts but the lack of emotion pulls down what should have been a highly charged book, June 14, 2008
It was a completely miraculous situation that I found this book because only days before I had been thinking about the man character in it, Mary Broad, who I first read about in the historical biography The Girl From Botany Bay by now fiction writer Carolly Erickson. Then, when bouncing around on Amazon one day I found this novel, "Remember Me" by Lesley Pearse. Naturally I had to read it.
"Remember me" is the tale of Mary Broad, one of the very first convicts to settle in the penal colony of Australia and more importantly-a woman who managed to escape to a Dutch trading colony 3,000 miles away in an open boat with her two small children and eight men.
This novel is very true to the actual facts of Mary's life. She was imprisoned for highway robbery (really she stole a hat but on a street so technically she robbed someone on a highway) and was sentenced to hang only to have her sentence changed like so many others to seven years transportation. But with the war in America over there was no place to put the convicts, meaning Mary spent time on the infamous prison hulks before the great experimental transport of convicts so many thousands of miles to a completely unknown and uncharted Australia.
But this book for all the story it is telling was sensational, full of drama, terror, adventure, romance...this novel is kind of flat. I've never read anything by Lesley Pearse before so I don't know if this is indicative of her typical style but "Remember Me" just came off as kind of emotionless to me in spite of all of the highly emotional content. This could be because I knew all the facts of the story ahead of time and there was no deviation from them in the book so with the lack of emotion it was like reading the biography again only with dialog. I was also disappointed with the lack of detail in the novel but that is probably because after reading Colleen McCullough's Morgan's Run which is about the exact same time period (only it covers the Norfolk Island experiment also) almost anything will seem lacking in detail.
But still, for me fiction is more interesting to read than a biography so while I did like this a little bit more than "The Girl from Botany Bay" (as Mary Broad eventually became known) I can't say the novelized version contained a whole lot more emotion but it was true to the facts.
I have one more book by Lesley Pearse so I hope that this isn't her usual style-or maybe it would be different if I didn't know the whole story in advance. I don't know. But she seems to have a huge following in the UK so I'll hold out hope.
Three stars. If you want any more details on Mary Broad or the transportation story in general check out the books above.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Quick, straight-forward read., November 19, 2010
It's 1786 in England and Mary Broad is guilty of stealing a hat. Instead of being hung, she is transported to a new colony in Australia.
On her journeys, Mary takes care of everyone around her. It didn't take long for me to get annoyed by her "too good to be true" behavior. She was also getting away with being snarky and demanding without punishment. Yes, she is smarter than everyone else. Again and again, it's pointed out by the narrator or even by Mary herself. Mary is smarter than everyone in the ship. Mary is smarter than the marines. Mary is smarter than anyone in the colony. Ugh!!!
The writing is very plain, but gets the story across.
Yes, I wanted to know what was next in the story, but I wasn't excited or looking forward to it. I didn't NEED to find out what happened next. This book didn't get much emotion out of me for some reason. I still enjoyed the storyline though. A fairly quick, straight-forward read for me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|