Most Helpful Customer Reviews
34 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Never again? The lessons of the Ingram case, July 30, 2004
This review is from: Remembering Satan: A Tragic Case of Recovered Memory (Paperback)
I use the case of Paul Ingram, intelligently reconstructed in Lawrence Wright's _Remembering Satan_, in a university class I teach on the history of magic and witchcraft in early modern Europe. The case helps my students to see how innocent people can be coerced, cajoled, and arm-twisted into confessing to horrendous, even incredible crimes. Paul Ingram's case parallels almost perfectly the witchcraft confessions of the 16th-17th centuries, even though many of those confessions were elicited through torture (though others, particularly those in England and New England, were not). Ingram, a law officer himself, 'knew' the stereotypes - now discredited - of so-called recovered memory and of so-called satanic ritual abuse. A devout born-again Christian, he believed, and was egged on by his pastor and other born-again advisers, that the devil could have possessed him and prevented his being able to remember that he had allegedly committed horrific crimes with other satanists - including murder and rape. These assumptions reflect those of the age of the European witchhunts, when intellectual elites - professors, theologians, popes, princes, and lawyers - defined and then prosecuted alleged diabolical witches, for whose alleged deeds and cults we have not one shred of historical evidence.
Experts - academics, professional counselors, and law-enforcement officials - have proven that no large, organized satanic cults exist in contemporary America. They point out that more murderers claim that God told them to kill than claim that Satan told them to kill. There are no credible cases of satanic ritual abuse along the lines alleged in _Remembering Satan_. The remains of dozens of children and animals that the accusers claimed had been sacrified and buried in a field were searched for by an expert forensic archaeologist - not only did he find no such evidence, but he concluded that the earth had never been disturbed and no burials had taken place. Virtually no reputable psychologist or psychiatrist believes that 'victims' who were subjected to the most vile and ghastly crimes imaginable have somehow 'forgotten' these events; they point out that even survivors of horrible abuse in Nazi death camps do not forget what happened. Rather, they cannot forget; they remember all too well the horrors they witnessed. The book that started the SRA panic of the 1980s-90s, _Michelle Remembers_, has, since the publication of Wright's work, been convincingly discredited by groups ranging from Wiccans to evangelical Christians.
In 2003, years after _Remembering_ appeared, Paul Ingram was finally released from prison. The story that Wright tells does, then, have a denouement. The book is a compelling and chilling reconstruction of a family's nightmare. But anyone reading it should follow up with some research on current thinking on so-called SRA, recovered memory, and on Paul Ingram himself. I recommend Kenneth Lanning's lengthy study, available on the web at http://www.religioustolerance.org/ra_rep03.htm (Lanning was the FBI's expert on alleged SRA, and has come to realize SRA just does not exist - a conclusion that led to his being accused of being a satanist himself!). The same website, religioustolerance.org, has numerous balanced and judicious essays on similar topics, including the Ingram case itself. This kind of research will prevent a reader from falling into the circular reasoning expressed by another reviewer on this website, who argued that the crimes were so horrendous that they must have happened.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A fascinating and frustrating case of alleged satanic abuse, February 11, 1998
This review is from: Remembering Satan: A Tragic Case of Recovered Memory (Paperback)
"Remembering Satan" is an account of one of the more prominent and tragic cases of alleged child abuse and satanic ritual abuse (SRA). Author Lawrence Wright makes it clear that he does not believe the majority of the allegations, and how could he? What started as "mere" allegations of sexual abuse soon developed into allegations of a widespread satanic cult that included many members of the investigating police force, lawyers, judges, and many others. The allegations started when Ericka and Julie Ingram accused their father, Paul Ingram, of molesting them. Paul Ingram was a deputy sheriff and deeply religious man in Olympia, Washington. He soon admitted to the allegations and began naming others as participants in all manner of rapes, orgies, and satanic rituals. The problem with the case, though, was that the allegations kept growing. Soon the alleged participants were talking about photographs, sacrifices of animals and human babies, and much more--none of which could be verified by any physical evidence. Further, the stories were often contradictory or patently false. Wright attempts to combine in a relatively slim volume the successful prosecution of Paul Ingram (who confessed), the destruction of a family and the lives of many others, and the hysteria surrounding the search for satanic cults. He locates these events within the larger context of repressed memories and the television talk-show dominated landscape of 1980s' America. There are problems in this approach as the subject matter seems to be one that cannot be captured in the book's approximately 200 pages, but Wright does an extraordinary job in presenting the material he has chosen to include. For those who have trouble crediting the outlandish claims of those who advocate widespread SRA, this book should be a fascinating read. For those who find themselves on the other side of the fence and believe fully in the validity of repressed memories, "Remembering Satan" will probably seem to be a slap in the face or just another part of the conspiracy. Either way, the Ingram case itself, which is the focus of this book, is a fascinating study in a modern-day witch hunt and the credulity of the investigators--and the accused.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Stranger Than Fiction, July 18, 2000
This review is from: Remembering Satan: A Tragic Case of Recovered Memory (Paperback)
An unbelievable, tragic, "stanger than fiction" account of two daughters' allegations of sexual abuse by their deputy sheriff father. The subsequent interrogations, in which suggestions of satanism were made, resulted in confessions to Satanic Ritual Abuse (SRA). In a trance, Paul Ingram implicated fellow deputies, family members and friends who allegedly participated in atrocious, despicable acts of murder, rape, sexual abuse and dismemberment. Evetually the charges against everyone implicated were dropped except for Paul Ingram. Tragically, this highly suggestible man was persuaded by apparantly honest interrogators to confess to crimes uncorroborated by any other evidence. His guilty plea resulted in a 20 year prison term. Lawrence Wright, a journalist and recent author of his first work of fiction, God's Favorite, presented this provocative and controversial case in what initially read like a bad novel. However, it became personally fascinating and educational as he introduced the psychological concepts of repression, recovered memories, suggestibility, hypnosis, trance and trauma. This case is but one example of the False Memory Syndrome. It by no means dismisses the existence and seriousness of incest and sexual abuse. It does however, call for caution by well-trained and experienced professionals in both the judicial and mental health fields when working with repressed and recovered memories. This book is an excellent starting point for anyone intrigued by human behavior, the complexities of the human mind and the legal/ethical repercussions involving recovered memory phenomena.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
