3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
RENEGADE: The Lives and Tales of Mark E. Smith, December 29, 2009
This review is from: Renegade (Hardcover)
At the very least this book is a must for all Fall fans. For all of the line up changes over the years, the one constant is Mark E. Smith. Over the years I have always read what a jerk he was, w/ no words to the contrary from him. Finally the final word from the man himself. Their place as one of the greatest bands ever already cemented. The book is a heady stream of conciousness filled w/ comical personal attacks. No person, concept, or institution is safe from this caustic wit. For every blast to one (whose fault it always is) that Mark felt crossed him, there are also kind (Mark E. Smith kind) words for those who supported him. For a self avowed socialist, Mr. Smith comes across conservative in many ways, such as marriage, family, and work ethic to name but a few. Mr. Smith is convicted in all of his beliefs, even if they sometimes contradict themselves. He seems to have no regrets. You will not get much insight into any of the Falls material, or Mark E. Smith, the man himself really. What you will get is a thought provoking rant on a myriad of subjects, recommendations on books that I,for one have taken up and found to be right on in their recommendation. Far more laughs than in your average biography, or any other book for that matter. Another man out of his time, a ribald original. I can't recommend this book enough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hilarious, August 7, 2010
As expected this makes an excellent read: Mark E Smith is again on excellent form and recounts his adventures and misadventures in the music business. Of course he ends up criticizing everybody and nobody really comes out unscathed by his criticism. Highly recommended. It is a very entertaining read and irt is extremely funny.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Could of been better, April 16, 2009
Mark E. Smith and The Fall are acutely phenomenal in the world of pop music and that alone would be enough for me to pick up their proper biography.
After countless brilliant interviews and on-spot snippets of wit and anger, we finally get an autobiography of Mark E. Smith himself. Considering MES's graphomaniac ability and his long-forgotten aspiratinos to be a writer, one would expect something stylish and literary, or maybe revolutionary. At least, I was inclined to believe so. Wrong. Instead, MES simply rants about this and that, wisely led by the co-writer Austin Collings, whose job, I assume, was to keep everything in order. The cover picture of a drinking MES doesn't help: was the book being made at some Manchester pub over a moutain of beers?
The book starts with settling account with a recently departed member of The Fall, Ben Pritchard, who had given a tell-it-all interview about MES's attics. It's awfully lame for MES to do so, but I see the point. In July 1977 Elvis Presley's bodyguards published an outrageous book exposing the King's behavioral atrocities. Presley was ill-mad at the publication but never had a chance to oppose it as he was announced dead a few weeks later. Luckily MES didn't die before completing the book.
Throughout the book, MES constantly bemoans about England and "these days" and gloriously paints Bo Didley's America and the old socialist Manchester of the 1970s, which is a striking dissonance when compared to the attitude of Tony Wilson & the Factory crowd.
In the end, I found myself to prefer these short brisk outburts of revelation that MES gave us throughout the years: they were different from each other, increasing contradiction and intrigue; once you put it out in form of a book, it is set and Mark is never set. In this regard, I more enjoyed John Lydon's "Rotten: No Irish, No Blacks, No Dogs", which was simply better delivered. On the other hand, "Renegade" serves its purpose, allowing MES to narrate his own autobiography by himself. Everyone would find what they look for in this book and that truly makes up for the patchy, alcoholic style.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No