Customer Reviews

Renegade Wizards: Tracy Hickman Presents the Anvil of Time

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I thoroughly enjoyed Lucien's previous entry into the Dragonlance mythos: The Alien Sea (Dragonlance: Champions, Vol. 2). As such, I was pleasantly surprised when it was announced that Renegade Wizards would be another Lucien book. The plot involves, of course, renegade wizards attempting to break away from the highly structured and rigid ways of the Orders of High Sorcery. The writing and prose were fluid and scenes flowed neatly from one to another. I enjoyed the opportunity to expand upon Par-Salian and Ladonna's background as well as the interwoven segue about Belize's rise to power (connected directly to the Defenders of Magic trilogy). I have noticed that Dragonlance authors have begun to exercise some discipline about telling stories within a framework that recognizes, acknowledges and respects events that occurred in other works. There has been times when I would question the veracity of certain events (in other Dragonlance books) because of the lack of precedence. Lucien has succeeded in neatly tying the various plots of this book to other books in the larger Dragonlance mythos. My only complaint about the book was that it was way too short; the ending seem rushed. Some authors like to unnecessarily pad their stories but Lucien's exposition and plot often left me hungering for more details. I am no writer but I am confident that the author will do well in his first trilogy.

The use of wild sorcery (or Wylding magic as it is called in this book) as the driving force behind the main plot dovetails nicely into the "current" world of Dragonlance. I had to smile a few times at the arguments presented by the various characters about the pros and cons for both wild and High sorcery. This is a most fascinating subject that hasn't been fully explored yet. A few books and authors have touched upon it (Wizards' Conclave (Dragonlance: Age of Mortals) springs to mind) but none so far have really come up with a story or trilogy worthy of the philosophical and metaphysical differences of the two branches of sorcery or the reconciliation and/or battles among sorcerers and wizards/mages. Someone needs to redefine the magic the way Niles redefined the Knighthood in the Rise of Solamnia trilogy.

Finally, it is about high time readers are treated to a main character who happens to be LGBT. Yes, I know I might spoil it for some folks but I just want to heap some worthy praise upon the author for this. Being a gay man, I have seen how marginalized LGBT characters are in the Dragonlance world. "Marginalized"? More like none that I know of or care to remember. I was doubly happy as the author used the concept of sexuality as a trying aspect of the dreaded Test. I don't need knights in rainbow armor or a flaming jester but it was sure nice to know that yes, there are finally some characters (strong ones too I might add) that some LGBT readers might identify with.

PS-This Journeyman character is extremely fascinating. Each author in the Anvil of Time series has written him uniquely and added a LOT of mystique to him. Before this series of book was launched I believe that there was a book written or commissioned expressly to explain the role of the Journeyman. Maybe it's time for THAT story to see the light of day?

Renegade Wizards by Lucien Soulban is the third in a series of stand alone novels under the banner The Anvil of Time. The first book is The Sellsword: Tracy Hickman Presents The Anvil of Time, Vol. One by Cam Banks and the second book is The Survivors: Tracy Hickman Presents the Anvil of Time (Dragonlance) by Dan Willis. The fourth, scheduled to be released in June, 2009, is titled The Forest King: Tracy Hickman Presents the Anvil of Time, Volume Four by Paul B. Thompson. This is Mr. Soulban's second novel in the Dragonlance universe, the first being The Alien Sea (Dragonlance: Champions, Vol. 2). I have been a big fan of these stand alone novels that Wizards of the Coast has been issuing for Dragonlance, Forgotten Realms, and Eberron. It gives the reader a good snapshot at what the world is like, without requiring them to read copious amounts of other novels. It's nice to be able to recommend single novels for people to get a feel of the world, so, I for one, hope they keep this trend up. Here are my thoughts about this novel.

The plot of this book centers around a plot against the Towers of High sorcery from a rival group of renegade magic users. The rivals are slowly stealing tomes artifacts, and magic users to further their cause. The Towers of High Sorcery are seeking to put a stop to it and further their control over magic use and those who use it. To do this they enlist the help of a mage from each order (white, red, and black). There are also a few sub plots as well such as; different reasons why each character is chosen by their respective order, characters doubting `things' about their lives, political maneuvering, and a little history into a time that is rarely written about. While there are several things in his novel that entertained me, and I was curious about, overall the plot seemed a little uneven to me. There are moments when it is well paced, but there are also moments where the pacing becomes near non-existent. This makes it, at times, difficult to really get into a groove while reading. There are also a couple of elements included in this book that didn't really seem to add to the overall plot line and were merely filler. With that said, being a fan of the Dragonlance world for the past twenty years, there were several things in this novel that were very interesting to me. I just wish it would have had a better balance throughout instead of the spotty nature it has.

The characters in this book could very well be a love them or hate them group. Let me give you an analogy to explain what I mean. In the music industry there are some songs that no one will cover because they are considered sacred. I think that's the case with at least one character in this book. In this book we get to see a much younger version of Par-Salian and Ladonna. At first I was excited about this proposition, but the more I read the more I felt that some things should have been left alone. The mystery behind some characters is part of their appeal. The dialogue, mannerisms, etc of Par-Salian did not mesh with how I remember him acting from the Chronicles. I understand characters develop over time, but it just didn't feel right reading about him like this. Other characters such as Tythonnia, Dumas, Thoma, and Berthal were well written. I actually enjoyed reading about them more than Par-Salian and Ladonna. There are some very strong character development moments for Tythonnia as well. I really did enjoy most of the characters, I just wish those two big name characters were not included in this book.

A couple criticisms about this novel:

1 - As I mentioned above the inclusion of a couple characters really took away some of the mystique for me. Partly because as a reader you know how things are going to turn out in regards to them, but also because there is a uniqueness about those characters that should have been left alone. I am not placing all the blame on Mr. Soulban though, because may very well have been told to use them.

2 - The unevenness of the plot and flow of the novel. While there are times when Mr. Soulban's prose shines, there are also times when it seems to sputter. This stunts the ability to really get the reader engaged in the story.


Some things I liked about this novel:

1 - There are several instances of very thought provoking dialogue and themes. I was not expecting those to be present in this book so it was a nice surprise. They don't come across as heavy-handed or preachy, but more of a thought provoking idea to consider.

2 - I liked the small tidbits of information about characters from past books such as the couple mentions of Justarius. I just wish all those mentions of other characters would have remained tidbits. That is just my opinion though.

Overall I thought this was a good book, but it missed being great for me. There are certainly some good things about this novel, but there are also some things that lessened my enjoyment of it a bit too. For fans of the Dragonlance universe I would rank this book up there are pretty close to a must read, if for no better reason than to learn about a time that Is very rarely talked about. It certainly adds quite a bit of lore to the Dragonlance universe. Aside from DL fans though, I am not sure if this is a good book to start with, just because of all the mentions of things that would be lost on people. I enjoyed Alien Sea by Mr. Soulban, and enjoyed most of this book as well, so I am looking forward to seeing what he writes next. Dragonlance fans, do yourself a favor and go out and pick this one up.

I liked this. I have always loved stories about the conclave of wizards. The addition of a new character was nice while still visiting with old friends and getting to know more about Ladonna and Par Salien's origins. Definitely recommend!

This being the three of four volumes was interesting but once again had some very try spells. The writing was very good however.

First I must say that although I didn't particularly like this book I still think the author's storytelling is above the average for sci-fi writers. The problem is that the author seemed to lose his train of thought in this story and as a consequence the story seem to drift around. The ideal of a conflicted member of the wizards being part of the group chasing the renegades was interesting and should have been more of the heart of the story than the renegade hunters or the rise to power of a minor character that had no impact in the grand scheme of the novel. I agree with another reviewer that the "mysterious" journeyman was in my opinion brilliantly portrayed not only by this author but all so far. I really hope that one of these novels deals in detail with this character.But back to this story I feel that this story could have been expanded with the present level of characters and maybe fill a three book arc with ease. As such I feel that the author had a tough time including all these characters and giving them due representation in this story.

Finally I hope dragonlance gives Mr. Soulban the opportunity to delve into a true story arc in this genre. But for the dedicated readers of Dragonlance I would skip this book since it doesn't really blend in with the entire series and instead of adding to the series it unfortunately detracts from it.

This is a great book. I recieved it quickly and it was in excellent shape.