Customer Reviews

Reprise Musical Repertory Theatre (Finian's Rainbow, Kiss Me Kate, South Pacific, Guys and Dolls)

5 star:		(9)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

It's great to have all four of these albums available again -- Bing Crosby, Dean Martin, Sammy Davis Jr., Jo Stafford, Rosemary Clooney, Keely Smith and of course Sinatra, all in one collaboration. While not all of the music is exactly timeless (Debbie Reynolds' performances as Adelaide on 'Guys and Dolls' are excruciating, and the Hi-Lo's, though fun to listen to, sound like, well, 1963...), there are some real treasures here. If you can take the ride from novelty to classic and back again, you will enjoy all four albums.

'Guys and Dolls' may be the best of the four sets, but from the overtures (the orchestra is magnificent) through the reprises each album has its highlights. Sinatra's 'Luck Be a Lady' is definitive, Davis shines on 'Too Darn Hot' and Jo Stafford's performances are all flawless. Keely Smith performs on several tracks, all of which are excellent -- 'Always True to You in My Fashion' is especially fine, with lyrics that she delivers with the right balance of coyness and honesty. Smith's duets with Sinatra are a treat.

Other highlights: the ensemble performances with Crosby, Martin and Sinatra are fun in a wiseguy kind of way. Bing wasn't a kid in 1963, but his voice aged well, and it is rewarding to hear Sinatra work with the guy who inspired him to be a singer.

Shortcomings? While I did not hear the discrepancies between the Martin and Sinatra tracks mentioned in other reviews, the sound quality is just okay. Reprise in the early 1960s could not compare to Columbia or Capitol, so even these stereo recordings suffer from exaggerated channel separation (Sinatra sounds like he's in the next room on one track) and some loss of depth.

But, it is difficult or impossible to remaster quality that wasn't there to begin. If you really love the music, the performers and the era, sometimes you must take what you can get.

About 8 years ago, when a revival of "Guys And Dolls" was sweeping the Great White Way, Reprise re-issued the 4th disc of this set on its own. Since then, the search has been on by music lovers everywhere for the other three volumes devised by Ol' Blue Eyes of some of Broadway's most beloved musicals. Here they are, presented in cd format at long last. Frank commissioned fellow pallies Sammy Davis Jr. and Dean Martin among other label mates to put across their spin on these great musicals, and the results are incredible. Already owning the "Guys And Dolls" disc for many years, I went directly to the "Kiss Me Kate" disc, which, in this reviewer's humble opinion, holds the best of this entire wonderful set. Dean Martin's "Bianca" is nothing short of sensuous, tender, and even more emotion-filled than how the immortal Cole Porter ever dreamed of penning it. Dean is abetted by a fine Skip Martin arrangement. Not to be missed. And while you're on the way to that track, stop by Keely Smith's "Always True To You In My Fashion" (also arranged by Skip Martin, who's Riddle-like sound is no stranger to anyone at Reprise or Capitol for that matter) And for a laugh or two, the always comical Lou Monte asks the rhetorical question "Where Is The Life That Late I Led?", along with Billy May and orchestra, another bunch of comics, per se. The "Finian's Rainbow" sides are equally well performed, although I'm not a fan of the Hi-Lo's; they seem to cramp Dino on "If This Isn't Love" and seem over exuberant on any tracks they touch. Rosie Clooney's "Look To The Rainbow" is wonderful, and the reprise of "How Are Things In Glocca Morra" will astound you. The "South Pacific" package boasts some wonderful music as well, including "der Bingel" on "Younger Than Springtime", and a great reprise of "Some Enchanted Evening" by Frank and Rosie Clooney. The standout here is Sammy Davis Jr.'s "There Is Nothing Like A Dame" with Marty Paich's great arrangement. The "Guys And Dolls" disc closes the set, and from Billy May's overture to Sinatra's beautiful "I've Never Been In Love Before" (orchestrated by Nelson Riddle) right down to Sammy's "Sit Down Youre Rockin' The Boat", its one wild ride after another. Debbie Reynolds is spectacular as the bewildered Miss Adelaide on "Take Back Your Mink" and with Allan Sherman on "Sue Me". The ultimate gem for us Rat-Packers to own, we just need Reprise to re-issue the soundtrack to "Robin & The Seven Hoods" now, and we can relax....whether you're a Broadway aficianado or just a great music fan, get this set today!

Forget all the Rat Pack nonsense, this collection represents some of the brightest recording stars of the sixties under the Reprise umbrella and headed up by the Chairman of the Board himself, Francis Albert Sinatra. Yes these are serious interpetations of four of the all-time biggest Broadway Hits, Finian's Rainbow, Kiss Me Kate, South Pacific amd Guys and Dolls.

The highlights are too numerous to list, but for starters there's....How Are Things In Glocca Morra beautifully sung by Rosemary Clooney and Old Devil Moon by Frank, both from Finian's Rainbow. If you've enjoyed the recent Broadway revival of Cole Porter's Kiss Me Kate, as I have then you'll love Frank, Dean and Sammy's version of We Open In Venice. Sammy's Too Darn Hot is just that and Keely Smith, who would sound great doing the weather report, does a beautiful rendition of Always True To You In My Fashion. Also the lovely Jo Stafford shines on Why Can't You Behave. From Rogers and Hamerstein's South Pacific we get Sammy belting it out on There Is Nothing Like a Dame and Dinah Shore's delightful reading of I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Out Of My Hair. The real topper of this set goes to Frank Loesser's masterpiece Guys and Dolls. This material suits the boys to a T. There's Frank, Bing and Dean hamming it up on The Oldest Floating Crap Game and Frank's stellar rendition of Luck Be A Lady. Dinah Shore is positively charming on the perennial If I Were A Bell and I love Sammy's swinging, Sit Down You're Rockin The Boat.

With beautifl packaging, inteligent liner notes and exclusive photos, this boxed set is a must-have for both broadway afficiandos and newcommers alike. I'd give it a dozen stars if I could, that's one for each great artist represented here.

I first became aware of these recordings back in the early 1970's when someone gave me a few dozen LP's they no longer wanted. Like the other reviewers, I found much to admire and enjoy in them. Recently I was able to acquire them on reel-to- reel tape at an on-line auction site. It was nice to hear the music without the clicks and pops; but, to be honest, the quality of the sound on tape was faded in comparison to the sound on vinyl. So when I recently saw the opportunity to acquire CD versions of this material, I jumped at the chance to obtain what I thought would be the ultimate recorded version. What a disappointment!

I have recently acquired quite a few CD's of material recorded back in the 1960's; and the remastering was so good, they sounded as if they were recorded within the last decade. Whoever did the transfers on these CD's did not put in the same kind of loving care and attention. I suspect that secondary tapes, rather than the original masters, were used in the transfer process. Sad to say, there is more transparencey and sense of space on the original LP's. On the CD's the sound is much more compressed and claustraphobic in character. So while I agree that these performances are truly gems; the sonic setting leaves much to be desired.

Sinatra, wise beyond his years, hired the Hi-Los when he formed Reprise. This vocal group is perfect in range, technique, quality of musicianship, arrangements, wit, and has won every Jazz Poll hands down while they recorded and performed! Their use on these recordings is a delight.

I would also add that Johnny Prophet -- a name as true to life as Johnny Rocket -- is a revelation...Especially in the KISS ME, KATE section. The arrangement of WERE THINE THAT SPECIAL FACE is magnificent, penned by an arranger's arranger. (Note that well, Billy and Nelson!). Also, his SO IN LOVE is a gem.

Needless to say, Sinatra, Martin, Sammy and Crosby are amazing, as always.

This is an essential album for fans of Sinatra, and the great American songbook!

They sure don't make music like this anymore!

It's great music like this that is made when artists control the company. Sinatra and Co. -- Sammy Davis, Dean Martin, Bing Crosby, Keely Smith, Jo Stafford and many more make provide a wonderful and highly entertaining set of four of Broadway's best musicals (Finian's Rainbow, Guys and Dolls, Kiss Me Kate and South Pacific). The diverse cast leads to some wonderful duets like the pairing of Bing Crosby and Debbie Reynolds or Frank Sinatra and Keely Smith.

While my personal favorite is Guys and Dolls, all of these are a treat. This set is not to be missed!

These four albums are combined into one cd set at a very reasonable price. Many of the cuts on these discs have not been released before on CD, and the Dean Martin selections were never made available anywhere else except the vinyl versions of these albums. For those who treasure the generation of vocalists, and those who cherrish muscial stage productions... this is a heck-of-a combination of both and we are so very lucky that they were recorded by Frank Sinatra's own record label, Reprise. Reprise used state-of-the-art recording equiptment to capture the most lavish sounds of the time, and Sinatra had the best musicians under his employ at the time. The original recordings sound so good, that they even sound better than some artists' recorded today... over thirty years later. If you're tired of going to the cd stores or browising through 'popular vocalists' to find something new... grab this fast! I highly recommend the set! admin@deanmartinfancenter.com

I searched high and low for this collection at every used record store in my neighborhood. I finally came up with a copy and was pleased with the variety of artists and the quality of each track. I am looking forward to listening to each of my formally scratchy favorite songs on this new compact disc release. Defititely a music lovers "must have".

Wow! I was blown away by this album. I love both broadway showtunes and music from the 40's so this combination was unbelievable. I don't know who came up with the concept, but it's incredible. I've heard all of these musicals in their original version and have enjoyed them for a time. This album did a fresh take on all of those songs, reviving them once again for me. I accidently found this while doing a search for Jo Stafford CDs. Boy, am I glad I did!

These performances are better than I remember them way back when the LP's were first issued (if some remember, they were originally only available from the Saturday Evening Post!)

Unfortunately as mentioned elsewhere it sounds like the recorings were made from the 2 track LP masters and not the original multi -track session masters. Still, it's good to have them available again.

As far as "Robin And The Seven Hoods" that album is coming shortly from Artanis Records.