5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Oddly Poetic Course in Subtle Sociopathy, January 6, 2009
If the parole evaluator's job is to determine if the violent criminal's child within is still locked in a vault unprocessed resentment towards those who violated him (or her), there's plenty of territory to look over. The rage of that inner child may be understandable, but what does that matter to the next victim?
Grand has done a remarkable -- if unusual -- job of examining several of the major issues simmering in the minds of "violence channelers" who were themselves violated. She does so from a predominantly psychoanalytic perspective with a substantial dose of psychodynamic object relations tossed in. Her principle influences appear to be Balint, Bion, Buber, Fairbairn, Fenichel, Guntrip, Horney, Klein, Ogden, Riviere, Searles, Sullivan and Winnicott, in all of whom she's thoroughly grounded. We also see Akhtar, Becker, Herman, Stern, Van der Kolk popping up expectably.
But Grand is no ivory tower academic. She's spent decades in the long-form trenches and offers her analytic grasp of several very interesting cases. In the process, she turns out several really illuminating essays on rejecting retaliation, countertransferential introjection of guilt from a subtle but dangerously vicious passive-aggressive, the possession of another's "things" as deserved compensation for parental bestiality and a means of defeating death, and the errors (and psychic costs) of righteous vengeance-seeking.
I may not agree with everything she says, but as a course in the issues and how to examine them, The Reproduction of Evil was a vital learning experience for me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No