Customer Reviews

Return to Halloweentown (Ultimate Secret Edition)

5 star:		(17)
4 star:		(10)
3 star:		(5)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I thought this movie was good although I agree that Kimberly was missed. I too was disappointed.. But the new girl (Sara) did alright--> big shoes to fill don't you think? As far as Debbie goes she could get as much screen time as she wants.. She obviously did not want anymore than what she had. Remember she is really up in age now.. I know I am 50.. I have watched her movies since I was a little girl.. I very much missed her too in this movie.. I was more disappointed that "Sophie" did not a part in this but I was glad "Dillon" did.. All in all I liked it.. I hope to see more of Halloweentown with Young Sophie...??

I was extremely disappointed that Kimberly J Brown was not playing Marnie in this movie. Sara Paxton does an OK job, but it's just not the same since the character of Marnie had been played by the same person in the 3 other movies. Also, I love love love Debbie Reynolds - she's the reason my family started watching this series. Unfortunately she is barely in this movie. I'm talking maybe 5 minutes out of the hour and a half that it runs.
The story line is good and follows the other movies (to a point), but (my opinion) it would've been so much better if Miss Brown had played Marnie instead of another actress and of course, if Debbie Reynolds had been given more screen time. :)

I and my daughter are a huge fan of the "Halloweentown" movies. We were both disappointed about the fact that Kimberly J. Brown didn't reprise her role as Marnie Piper. Sara Paxton is okay, but she had some big shoes to fill in my opinion since Kimberley did such a great job in the previous 3 movies. If you have seen the first 3 and not this one, I would advise you to check it out on Disney channel first before buying it.

I bought this DVD for my daughter, she loves all the Halloweentown movies and it's a great family picture.

My daughter loved this movie she has all of the Halloweentown Disney DVD'S, Another movie I highly recommend is Hocus Pocus.

Hoestly this movie wasnt the same without Kimberly J Brown. I didnt enjoy it and this new Marnie I didnt like that much either. The first three were a lot better.

Wonderful movie for the whole family. All the halloweentown movies are equally as good.

Disney has created some really cute seasonal (in this case Halloween) movies. This series of Halloweentown is one of the better ones.

This movie absolutely succedded the first three. It was still a dissapointment that Kimberly Brown didn't star as the main character Marnie,but Sara Paxton did a pretty decent job. It was also a let down that Aggie only had a few apperances throughout the movie. She's the one who made the series excellent! I mean after all if it wasn't for her coming home to visit in the first movie then Marnie never would have known she was a witch and she would have lost her powers. Now the movie did have a good plot and Marnie got to go back in time and see her grandma when she was young which amazingly she looked identical to her. I absolutely give this movie 5 stars even though their were a few things I didn't agree with.

I love to watch all HalloweenTown and this teach us more about Crowell family's past.