Most Helpful Customer Reviews
114 of 123 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Makes me VERY sad to say this, July 2, 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
..... but this book is just bad. I tried to find another way to say it and make my comments softer, but I felt that would have been dishonest and a disservice to people looking for honest reviews to help make decisions about what to purchase and to read. I faithfully read Dorothea Benton Frank books and largely love them. I have read "Sullivan's Island", "Plantation" and almost all the others including "The Land of Mango Sunsets" which I recommended to anyone who would listen to me. When I was able to select this via the Vine program, I felt like I had hit the lottery since I was already on the wait list at the library even before it came out. With that background in mind, I have to say this book was really pretty awful. Had I not agreed to review it for Amazon and had I not been such a fan I think I would have probably stopped reading by the half way point. There is so much wrong with the book that I can't even begin to recount it all. I started writing notes in the front of the book of examples of the really terrible character development and the dialogue that was often so bad as to be funny. As soon as the characters are introduced you know who's the bad guy, who's the good guy, the romance that will fail and the romance that will succeed. There is no mystery or tension here -- it's telegraphed at the beginning and you just read along until what you knew was going to happen actually happens. The characters are shallow and largely irritating (the main character, Beth, is a recent graduate of Boston College who speaks like a pre-teen girl and has decision making abilities worse than my own 14-year-old). Usually DBF books have humor and wit that is hard to match by other authors but this novel lacked both and the ending was so jarring as to appear like it just got tacked on without thought -- she needed to get it finished under a deadline? Again, overall, I am a huge fan of DBF and will try again with her next effort...keeping my fingers crossed that it's significantly better. Had I not been in the position of loving this author previously, I might have even given it 1-star. It reads like the efforts of a first time novelist rather than the powerhouse author she can be.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Another Dorothea Benton Frank disappointment, June 27, 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I really wanted to like this book! I found Frank's book Sullivan's Island years ago and really enjoyed it. Her books have steadily gone downhill since, but I grabbed Return to Sullivan's Island as soon as I saw it, hoping it would reverse the trend. Unfortunately, it did not. Cecily was the only female character really worth getting to know, and she was a strong but secondary character. The protagonist, Beth, is a newly-minted college graduate who is pressured to put her life on hold for a year and return to the family's house on Sullivan's Island. She does so, but resentment rolls off of her in waves. She does finally come to terms with her decision, but then makes one foolish choice after another. Even worse, she knows they are bad choices, but plunges in headfirst anyways. The plot was heavy-handed and the entire story lacked subtlety, probably because all of the characters were stereotypes: the dutiful daughter, the judgmental matriarch, the good ole boys, Mr. Wrong-but-oh-so-delicious, etc. Finally, the conflict was resolved much too easily. If this book was a cheap paperback, it would be an okay beach read. Not worth the hardcover price, however.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Return to Sullivan's Island, July 18, 2009
I have read Dorothea Benton Frank's Lowcountry books over the years and this was the biggest disappointment. Don't we have enough Ponzi schemes and bodies stuffed in freezers in our every day newspapers? Dorothea should return to what the lowcountry is all about with beautiful islands and beaches along with the old traditions.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
