Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not bad., October 19, 2001
This review is from: Reunion (Star Trek: The Next Generation) (Hardcover)
The book is well-crafted, its characters -- both previously established characters and newly created ones -- well-developed and for the most part plausible, the exception being the "villain" of the piece, whose motivations are too cardboard and trite to be plausible. The dialogue works, and the plot, while it starts somewhat slowly, becomes compelling as the story moves along. Unfortunately, the ending is somewhat unsatisfactory; the story is, essentially, a detective murder mystery in Star Trek's clothing, and I do not feel that the answer to "whodunnit" had been adequately foreshadowed in the earlier storyline. In retrospect, there WAS some attempt at foreshadowing, but it simply didn't ring true when the actual would-be murderer was revealed. Definitely a good read, but just as definitely flawed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The 1st Entry in the Stargazer Series!, February 14, 2008
This review is from: Reunion (Star Trek: The Next Generation) (Hardcover)
Reunion teams Picard with his former Stargazer crew to solve a murder mystery. One of the crew is picking off Enterprise crew members one by one. Picard and his staff must discover who the culprit is before the Enterprise is destroyed. Star Trek is hardly the place for a mystery. However MJF makes the book work with solid pacing and characterization. This book sets Friedman's Stargazer series into motion. We get to see interesting characters, prior to the Next Generation. I wish Friedman were still writing Trek fiction because his characters were always true to their TV roots. In the new fiction all the interesting characters are gone! B4, Riker,Troi, are no longer part of the crew. They were replaced by characters that aren't quite as compelling to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A well crafted, tightly wrapped story, September 26, 2009
This review is from: Reunion (Star Trek: The Next Generation) (Hardcover)
As a consequence of one of them ascending the Daa'Vit throne, several members of Captain Picard's former crew aboard the Stargazer are on the Enterprise and traveling to the coronation. The Daa' Vit and Klingon Empires had been at war for some time before the interjection of the Federation caused a cessation of hostilities. Despite the years of peace, the hostility remains and it is very difficult for the Klingon Worf and the Daa' Vit Morgen to occupy the same room. All of their instincts are to fight to the death, yet Morgen is a Captain in Starfleet and a close friend of Picard so both of them must bury their instincts and learn to tolerate each other. That tolerance must quickly be turned into a working relationship, as there is an assassin on board the Enterprise that is determine to kill Morgen. The assassin is extremely competent in the technical sense, able to reprogram a holodeck into a killing machine as well as reprogramming food synthesizers and also extremely skilled in hand-to-hand combat. The situation is made even worse by the Enterprise inadvertently entering a subspace slipstream that moves them along at warp 9.5 and seems impenetrable. A secondary subplot is the effort that Dr. Crusher must make to keep her dead husband from her thoughts, for Jack Crusher served on the Stargazer and was killed rescuing the ship. The action is fast, furious and consistent with the usual actions of the Next Generation crew. All perform admirably, Worf is the gruff Klingon that puts duty over personal feelings, Geordi is a miracle worker in engineering and Riker manages to woo and bed a female. Picard's former shipmates prove to be quite talkative to the point of insubordination yet in general they are all appealing, their conversations are much more open and honest, something that the Enterprise crew cannot do given their positions. Of course, the Enterprise is saved, the assassin discovered and disarmed and Morgen ascends the throne and galactic peace is preserved. Some of the best stories are those where you know the literary destination beforehand yet the path there is so engaging that the foreknowledge is rendered irrelevant. This is one such story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|