3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Improving upon the movie, December 19, 2010
Of all the prequels, I think there's unanimous agreement that
Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith is the best of the bunch. Yet, even this finale faltered at times with choppy dialogue and unclear plot twists. Now, imagine you could reedit the movie and make perfect. That's what Matt Stover's
Star Wars, Episode III - Revenge of the Sith is like. This novelization takes the movie as a base and makes it even more of an epic.
First, Stover's writing style mixes "stream of consciousness" sections, with glimpses into the minds of characters. While potentially risky, Stover pulls this off well, showing the inner emotional turmoil at which the film can only hint. Anakin's motives for joining the Dark Side become a lot clearer as we Stover explores the depths of his confusion. And he manages to really capture certain character dynamics well with just a few choice phrases, such as calling Obi-Wan and Anakin a team.
Beyond that, Stover also expands the plot beyond what was covered in the 2.5 hours of the movie. Palpatine's discussions with Anakin are longer and more intense. I particularly thought Palpatine's depiction of the Jedi-Sith conflict as a dispute over "philosophical differences" was quite clever. In the book, he's so effective at blurring the line between good and evil that I almost felt like I was falling for the Dark Side! Meanwhile, we actually get to sit in on the deliberations of the Jedi Council and hear some of the shockingly candid disagreements amongst Yoda, Mace Windu, and Obi-Wan.
Just as important sometimes is what Stover left out of the book. For example, Palpatine does not scream "Power, ultimate power" when he's zapping Mace Windu with lightning. Nor does Vader scream "Nooooo!" upon hearing about Padme's death. In fact, overall, the book and the characters' dialogue have a more dignified "age of heroes" feel. If only Stover had had a bit more influence over the final script.
Of course, the novel isn't a substitute for the movie, particularly for the action scenes. They're short and often not particularly exciting. I thought the first few pages of the space battle were the only slow part of the book, although they're a visual feast in the movie. It seems - wisely in my opinion - that Stover essentially left the epic action to the movie and focused on plot and dialogue.
Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith is probably one of the most compelling Star Wars stories ever told. If for whatever reason - the acting, CG special effects, Jar Jar Binks - you were not enthralled with the story as told in the movie, you owe it to yourself to enjoy it as told through Stover's adaptation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
FANTASTIC, January 19, 2012
This book is the prime example of when a book is better than the movie. The book can go into so much more in depth insights into character motivation and behind the scenes machinations - that the story makes infinitely more sense.
Dont get me wrong, I am a star wars fan and I still saw the movie 3 or 4 times, and I liked it. But I still found myself going - why the &)*%# would they do that? What kind of response is that ? Etc...
I recomend this book to anyone who likes star wars, and especially if you are into the EU books. It is a rich and vibrant tale that should be mandatory reading after seeing the movie. I will grant there are moments the horse gets beats a bit to death, but it is a fair trade for buyable explanations of way the pieces fit together airtight.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Your a typical book better than a movie must read, January 16, 2012
Say what you will about the Star Wars prequels, no form of media captures Anakin's fall and Vader's Rise to power more than this book. A Sci Fi Greek tragedy at it's best. This piece of text captures Anakins spirit even more so that the clone wars series does, and let's not talk about the choice of the actor that portrayed him onscreen. I always feared and yet respected Vader as a kid and loved the legend of Luke's crazy father the Jedi General reckless hero that every other Jedi shakes their head at because of the way he gets results on the Clone Wars on cartoon network, but the way this book portrays Anakin and Obi-wan as literal superheroes coming to rescue the leader of the galatic republic, the depiction of each Jedi Fighting style's (especially Mace Windu's) and the manipulation of Anakin by Palpitine is just pure candy. The Detail of Order 66 was as chilling as anything I've ever read and very realistic, as I truly think that the Jedi would not see that coming. It will have you begging Anakin not to make the decision we all know hes going to makeBut the most chilling thing about this tradgey and the reason why I totally changed my opinion about Vader, since the end of Return of the Jedi, because lets face it, we heard all the stories but never really seen exactly how evil Vader was, but to actually witness (as much as you can reading books) the killing of the Younglings by Anakin/Vader and the pure hurt and damage done to Obi-wan's soul when he first found out and the shock and disbelief from Padme when he told her was actually felt real even though it was words off of a book. I challenge anybody who said the movie was terrible to read this book and not come out better for knowing the story the way it was meant to be portrayed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No