From School Library Journal
Grade 2-4-The rapid rise and demise of a Nevada gold-mining town is recounted in Siebert's narrative verse and enhanced by Frampton's colorful woodcuts. Each spread features a page of text framed by a detailed border opposite a full-page illustration. Frampton has creatively extended Siebert's rhythmic text by placing desert creatures, including coyotes, lizards, and scorpions, around pages describing the arrival of the first two prospectors in the area in 1904. The art accompanying the lines "Word traveled fast. More people came/-Soon families and their friends arrived./A little town was born and thrived" features people traveling by covered wagon, stage coach, and early automobile, one miner walking and pushing a wheelbarrow filled with tools, and a group riding in on horseback. As the mines grow and the town expands, the pictures of workers become reminiscent of WPA mural art. In many woodcuts, the coyotes, which figure prominently in the poem as bemused onlookers that "watched with laughing eyes" and "knew what coyotes know," gaze heavenward at swirling stars or earthward at humans panning for gold or erecting power lines. When the town's boom years come to an end and the inhabitants move on, the borders feature a landscape littered with broken crockery, discarded mining implements, and ghosts. A wonderful example of a well-crafted picture book.
Ginny Gustin, Sonoma County Library System, Santa Rosa, CACopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 2-4, younger for reading aloud. Handsome woodcuts are the highlight of this rhyming story about the boomtown of Rhyolite, which sprang up almost overnight in 1904 after two men discovered gold in southwestern Nevada. The population quickly reached 10,000, then dwindled to almost nothing in a few years, following a financial panic. Frampton's woodcuts, more intricate than much of his previous work, suit the historical tale with their rustic feeling and glowing palette of oranges, browns, and golds. The full-page pictures and attractive borders around the boxed text convey information about the time and place. There's also a nod to multiculturalism, though the characters are, unfortunately, depicted stereotypically: an Asian worker has yellowish skin and a Native American has reddish skin. Siebert's verses bounce listeners from the discovery of gold, through the town's growth that brought a symphony and tennis courts, to a ghost town with crumbling buildings. The iambic tetrameter couplets grow monotonous and occasionally awkward, detracting from the impact of a story that some children will find quite fascinating.
Kathleen OdeanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved