Customer Reviews

Rich & Mad

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I have had this book on my radar for a while now even though many readers have found this book less than great. Maybe the cover kept appealing to me, maybe the summary had me hooked, but I just knew I wanted to read this book.


First of all, let me say that a lot of people have had a hard time reading this book due to certain sexual scenes that can come across offensive. That is fine and I agree that some of it didn't really need to be in the book to make the point. What I will add to that though is I am well past my teen years, but I have children who are just entering this stage. I don't censor their reading at all because that is my parenting style. I would have no problem with my daughter reading this book even with the talk of porn, sex, virginity, physical abuse and sexual orientation. I feel what is the book going to hurt when they hear about this stuff from friends anyway. Besides, I have been that age and I remember that books were not the source of info on this stuff--my friends were. Not trying to sound preachy here in my review, but if you don't feel the same way, be cautious of your teen reading it.


With all of that being said, the book was still just an okay book for me. I loved the character of Rich, even though at times his though process made no sense. Who thinks writing a letter from the pope is going to help get a girl to like them? I found that funny and less than attractive. Rich just didn't think that one through. Maddy was a great character that you would like for a friend. She is naive in many things, but she still gives a person the benefit of the doubt. These two were so naive in ways of thinking love should be.


Some of the side characters were great. I loved Cathy and Max. They were funny and what you would expect in normal teenagers for friends. Grace was a piece of work who needed serious help, but I can also understand part of the problem she has. Without going into spoilers, I hope teenagers have learned that this way of thinking by Grace is not love. Joe was up and down for me. At first he was sweet, then I despised him, and then the author does a complete turn around that redeemed him and made him the good guy again or all along.


I loved parts of the books, but there were little things that added up to negatives for the book as well. While I enjoyed it, I didn't fall in love with it like I thought I would. I love the cover the most! It seems romantic and gives you hint at the tenderness that can be found with certain characters of the book.

This novel had me varying between wanting to put my hands over my eyes or cover my ears even though I wasn't hearing anything but it certainly felt like I was. I didn't realise when I picked up this novel so much content would be packed into its pages and I suppose maybe if I had connected with the characters more I would want to splash cold water on my face to distract me from what it shoved in my face. What I was expecting to read was a cutesy light hearted novel about two teens finding their way together and creating a love that had bells ringing in an `awe and ahh' because I don't know about you but with my lack of love life it is nice to read about some loved up couples and dream about the possibilities of the ups and downs of a relationship. However what I was served up was not the dinner I had ordered, no it came with a serving of Brussels, (if you love this particular vegetable, please imagine something that makes you screw your nose up in an eek expression).

The characters in this novel just didn't grab my attention; they left me feeling quite bland which in reality meant they were just bland characters themselves. Nothing particularly grabbed me enough to make me really care about them or become attached. Maddy and Rich were cute enough; I thought it was lovely how they explored each other in loving way and it wasn't written in a way that would make you feel like you should put the book down, walk out of the room to give them some privacy, it was sweet, tender and innocent because it was exploring the unknown of each other's bodies. It was commendable of the author to give them time to really get to know each other before either knew they would end up together. The led up to their relationship while didn't leave me with a simmering `come' on get together already' but a slow boat ride that made me skip to the end. I suppose what I have come to the conclusion of is that this book didn't have a passion or at least I couldn't feel the underlining passion outwardly, it merely was there, just waiting to happen. And after waiting for them to get together I didn't have the moment of `finally' as I sigh, nope, I merely thought `well it is about time I guess,' I just wasn't invested in their relationship at all.

All in all; I don't know whether I would recommend this book, if you're comfortable walking smack bang into uncomfortable subjects then this will probably float your boat but if you don't have a strong stomach for this subject matter, then steer clear.

SHE KNOWN AS JESS

Reviewed for Mundie Moms by Cynthia

I was inexplicably sucked into this book from the first few chapters, I really don't know why, the plot wasn't unique I've read about first love, first everything, many times before but this one had a little something. I think it had to do with the writing, for me it flowed easily and even though it had an immense amount of dialogue through most of the book I found myself really liking the story and the main characters.


We get to see the story unfold from the point of view of Rich and Maddy, they are both "in love" with the wrong person, and I used quotation marks because to me it seemed like infatuation instead of love. I did find that I could relate to them because I remember feeling that way in high school, thinking I was in love with someone that I never even spoken to just because they were really hot or had certain qualities, of course I know NOW that it wasn't love but I found myself relating to both of these characters. I really loved Rich, more than any of the others, he was sweet and vulnerable, I just felt like giving him a big hug through most of the book. Maddy seemed very naïve at the beginning which was a little frustrating and I felt like slapping her sometimes, but I loved that she toughen up a little after she gets "heartbroken" and starts looking at love and guys in a whole different way.

Now I want to warn you that this book will not be for everyone, yeah it's one of those that you'll either hate or love. It has a lot of language and very "detailed" sex scenes in it that might make you cringe or look behind you to make sure nobody is reading over your shoulder. It's definitely not for younger teens, I wouldn't even let my 30something year old sister borrow it because she's not used to these type of books.

I was able to overlook all of that because I enjoyed the story and the characters, I liked that we get to see them unexpectedly grow closer to each other and fall in love. There's also a lot more to the story than just the sex and unrequited love, there's lots of deceit and lies and unpredictable twists to the plot that when you think everything has already been resolved the author throws one more surprise at you and I personally didn't see it coming. Rich and Mad wasn't perfect, it wasn't filled with romance, it's not really something I would call a love story. It was a more realistic and definitely not sugarcoated version of teenagers and the many mistakes they make, the eye openers about life that they go through, the wanting to be madly in love, that I myself remember feeling when I was in high school. It won't be right for everyone but I ended up liking it a whole lot.

My Thoughts: I had really high hopes for this one. And, yes I did enjoy it. But it didn't get 5 cupcakes from me as I hoped it would. It has an interesting feel to it. We meet Rich and Maddy and of course they aren't interested in each other but people who they believe are unattainable. They've noticed each other throughout the years but just as friends would. Rich likes the popular girl who is kind of friends with Maddy and Maddy likes the guy who doesn't even really know she exists. Plus he already has a girlfriend he's crazy about. Maddy agrees to try to help Rich out but that doesn't go so well either. There were so many twists and turns I did not see coming. People messing with one another's heads. Most of the time I didn't know what was going to happen. The friendship that blossomed between Maddy and Rich was nice though. I liked the ending of the story more than the beginning. Rich and Maddy were interesting characters to read about and the problems they were facing and how they helped face those problems together. It also goes into great detail about love, sex, and issues that not every person will want to read about, even though I didn't mind.

Overall: I liked Rich and Maddy but didn't love it as much as I hoped. I just went into this book hoping it would reach beyond the 5 cupcakes but I left feeling a little less great than I hoped I would. Its still an amazing book, it just takes a lot to lead up to the parts I enjoyed the most.

Cover: Love the cover! I think this is one of my favorite things about the book. You can't see their faces really but it looks really cute! The way he's holding her chin!

What I'd Give It:
4/5 Cupcakes

Taken from Princess Bookie

Maddie wants to fall in love, so deeply and madly in love that she can't think. She's even found the perfect candidate in Joe, who is incredibly cute and popular. Too bad he has a girlfriend, but if he's dating Gemma, then why is he sending signals that he likes Maddie back? Rich had had a crush on Maddie's friend Grace for the longest time. He knows there's no chance Grace would like him back, but that doesn't stop him from trying to win her over anyway. In the midst of all the lies and confusion, Maddie and Rich both struggle to figure out love and relationships. In the end, though, they'll find that love sometimes comes from where you least expected it.

Rich and Mad is a detailed and realistic exploration of romantic relationships, first love, and everything that comes with that. Nicholson does a fantastic job of portraying teens. I find it rare that an author will go so in depth in discussing love and sex; this novel is less a romance than a question and answer of what love is. With varied but always believable characters, Nicholson is able to write about relationships and opinions of love from multiple angles. Everything about this story, from the content to the questions it presents to the emotions of the characters is sure to resonate with all teen readers. Though some of the plot is predictable or just strange, Rich and Mad remains a very sweet and enjoyable read.

Rich and Mad should be read by teens everywhere and will particularly appeal to those who enjoyed Crash Test Love by Ted Michael and Into the Wild Nerd Yonder by Julie Halpern.