6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reining is sublime!, August 21, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Richard Strauss: "Der Rosenkavalier" / 1949 Salzburg Festival / Reining, Novotna, Güden, Vienna Phil., Szell (Audio CD)
I completely disagree with the other reviewer. To many, Maria Reining is the elegant, but rather past-her-prime Marschallin in the famous Erich Kleiber recording. Here, several years earlier, she is at the tail end of her prime, singing with a radiance and sweetness that dimmed somewhat by the time of the Kleiber recording. Hers is the most wonderful, moving, humane performance of the Marschallin I've ever heard. Her beautiful diction (you could take shorthand dictation listening to her) and warm, sincere manner are incomparable in this role. So many portrayals of the Marschallin veer in the direction of sentimentality, over-voluptuousness, melodrama. Not Reining's. She maintains a marvellous elegance and restraint and her portrayal is all the more moving for it. Just listen to the last 20 minutes of Act 1, I simply can't imagine the role being sung to greater perfection.
The rest of the cast is mixed -- Gueden excellent, Novotna in rough voice. Szell's conducting is swift and he keeps the conversational pace of this opera as Strauss/Hoffmansthall intended.
This is not a first Rosenkavalier for beginners, but those used to historic sound who want to hear a great portrayal of the Marschallin, and one of the few samples on CD of the art of Maria Reining at its peak, must have this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exquisitely Dancing Style..., January 23, 2006
This review is from: Richard Strauss: "Der Rosenkavalier" / 1949 Salzburg Festival / Reining, Novotna, Güden, Vienna Phil., Szell (Audio CD)
I'm currently listening to this recording on XM Satellite Radio, and I'm very much impressed. For me, Rosenkavalier is best when it so strongly counterbalances Strauss's love of dissonance and density with pure lyricism. I love the old Lehmann/Schumann recording, except for the lack of depth in recordings from that period, and a tendency towards thinness in the soprano singing--a kind of over-delicate, girlish quality.
Perhaps the sound quality of this live recording is not up to snuff with contemporary studio recordings, but it's remarkably clear and bright (in this digital radio offering).
And the big surprise for me is the exquisitely apt, dancingly rhythmic style Szell brings to the whole thing.
We don't normally, I believe, think of Szell as a conductor who generates a stylish, limpid sound. I think of him, anyway, as one of the bigger, noisier, more boisterous conductors--like Reiner in a certain vein or Solti (but not so loud).
But, like Reiner, Szell can bring a wonderful lyric musicality out of an orchestra--especially these Viennese musicians.
Operas, and live recordings especially, depend so much on a kind of mysterious coherence, the ability of the conductor to create an elastic pulse that continues from measure to measure and scene to scene and act to act so that the work coheres as a whole, rather than falling into separate 'effects,' however lovely.
Szell does that here, as Beecham does for his justly famous Boheme, von Karajan does for his old Magic Flute and Knappertsbusch does for his better Rings.
Having heard many modern recordings of Rosenkavalier and several older ones, I find this Szell recording a pretty much perfect reading of the work as a whole. Yes, others are more lush, have more perfect voices, are more delicate or more powerful here or there. But this one involves you from start to finish and gives you pleasure upon pleasure.
Go for it.
The above review was written before I ordered this CD. Now that I own it, I'm thrilled. It's a lovely edition of the work. The sonic restoration is as good as one can hope. It's a huge thick thing, with the entire libretto, lovely smart little essays, and gorgeous old photos, different ones in each language version of the essays. This is the way CD publishers should make money: adding value.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great historic recording, February 15, 2010
This review is from: Richard Strauss: "Der Rosenkavalier" / 1949 Salzburg Festival / Reining, Novotna, Güden, Vienna Phil., Szell (Audio CD)
Sorry I can write only italian or french.
Produzione fantastica con grandi specialisti nei rispettivi ruoli (Novotna e Reining su tutti)
Superba e brillante la direzione, che non sfigura accanto a quella di Karajan e Kleiber (anche se entrambe inarrivabili).
Grande merito di Andante riproporre questi superbi live: di questa serie fanno parte anche Meistersinger e Falstaff diretti da Toscanini che già possiedo.
Grazie ad Andante!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
