Customer Reviews

Ride the Thunder: A Vietnam War Story of Honor and Triumph

5 star:		(38)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

[Reviewed from advance galley: I did not see the notes, photos, maps, or index.]

The product description supplied by the publisher to Amazon does not begin to do justice to this marvelous new entry on the shockingly misunderstood war in Vietnam. Ride the Thunder is not a traditional single-volume history of the long and very complex combat-diplo-war in Southeast Asia. Instead, author Richard Botkin (a former United States Marine Corps infantry officer) carves off an important slice of the story, packing and filling around the edges to provide a contextual telling of the events in toto.

Botkin's tale centers on the little-told and virtually unknown story of a handful of American and Vietnamese Marines who fought against horrendous odds and arguably WON the war by stopping a brutal 1972 invasion by North Vietnam (known as the Easter Offensive). These same brave souls lived to watch diplomats and politicians insert the surrender rug beneath their feet, yank it out, and knock down the victorious edifice earned by the blood of tens of thousands of men and women (including 50,000+ young Americans).

Central to the plot are a few individuals and their daring exploits, chief among them Capt. John Ripley (whose jaw-dropping raid to blow up the Dong Ha bridge is told here better than anywhere else I have ever read); Maj. Le Ba Binh (a South Vietnamese Marine whose men fought off and beat back more than 20 times their number), and Lt. Col. Gerry Turley (whose strategic and tactical leadership and personal courage helped stave off what looked to be certain defeat, and then turn it into a victory). By the time you finish this book, you will know these men, their families (in most cases), and their hearts.

"Everything Americans know about the end of the Vietnam War is wrong," claimed the author in a publicly available interview. "From the American side, I think most people have a completely uninformed or misinformed opinion of the Vietnam War. Most Americans, including people who served in Vietnam, didn't appreciate the level of sacrifice of the South Vietnamese. These people love freedom." Indeed this is true. Very few in the West--even at this late date--appreciate what took place there, especially during the war's latter years. As Botkin documents, the Communists (NVA) routinely and intentionally used artillery fire to kill thousands of helpless civilians (including the young the old, and the sick). "They would even place high-value targets near civilian centers." If you pay attention to modern events, the similarity to tactics employed by Hamas, Hezbollah, and Al Qaeda will come to mind. Politicians, including Ted Kennedy, promised one thing and then cut off support, guaranteeing that millions of people in South Vietnam would endure a life of misery, near-slavery, and mass butchery. This backstabbing effort, developed inside Washington, D.C., also ensured that Pol Pot would have free rein to fertilize the killing fields of Cambodia with the blood of millions of his own citizens.

Why, then, were we in the America fed lies of the worse kind? "The communists were masters at using propaganda against us," Botkin explains. Freedom-seeking Vietnamese endured untold pain and suffering unimaginable to most Americans while Communists released propaganda lapped up by Western critics of the war. Communist = Good, American military = Bad. The obvious lies spun from salons in Hanoi (and even inside our own Capitol Building) fit the media-spun meme of the times. The parallel to what is transpiring now in Honduras is palpable. There was no military coup there, but the media insist otherwise, and average Americans are duped in the process. It is as disgusting today as it was in the 1960s-70s. And just as dangerous.

Ride the Thunder is fresh in every respect, well-written, and often thrilling. Most of it you have never read before. The final pages detailing the years of untold suffering endured by Maj. Le Ba Binh and his family are heart wrenching (and among the best in the book). I heartily recommend Botkin's book as an antidote to the monographs and storylines heretofore offered up as truth.

I just finished reading this book and to be honest it brough tears to my eyes as I read about the heroism and sacrifice of the brave South Vietnamese and American Marines whose stories are told within its pages. As a Vietnam Vet and former US Marine, I found this book truly spellbinding and enlightening. Mr. Botkin is an exceptionally gifted writer who relates his story in a very compelling and entertaining way, filling every page with pathos, historical detail, action, and political insight. I personally know several of the participants in Mr. Botkin's book and he captures their personalities perfectly and in the most engaging way. Their acts of courage will inspire any reader who values the traits of a warrior. There is no need to resort to hyperbole when Mr. Botkin tells the story of several key participants in the defense of Quang Tri Province during the 1972 TET invasion by the North Vietnamese. Each of these participants, both Vietnamese and American, are larger than life heroes. Their stories are told in this book for the first time - and what stories they are! If you have an interest in the Vietnam War and would like to know the truth about how bravely our South Vietnamese allies fought and why they ultimately lost the war, this is a book you must have. I also highly recommend it for anyone with an interest in the human aspects of combat and the enduring triumph of the human condition despite overwhelming odds. In short, I consider this one of the very best books ever written about the Vietnam War.

Richard Botkin has written a vividly accurate account of one of the last American combat actions of the Vietnam War and what came after we Americans left. His portrayal of the critical actions of (then) Lt Col Gerry Turley, USMCR and Captain John Ripley, USMC is not only factually correct but punctuated with their personal insights and reinforced with multiple interviews of both U.S. and Vietnamese Marines who were there. Those of us who participated in these events are intimately familiar with the tenacity of the Vietnamese Marines, the individual battles for survival, the stand-out heroics of John Ripley and Ray Smith among others, and the tremendous leadership responsibilities executed by Turley. What we advisors, and no doubt the rest of America were not aware was the sacrifices by the South Vietnamese and their families and the severity and duration of the punishment levied against them by the North Vietnamese government when we left. If you have prejudices about the Vietnam War, put them aside and read this book. I am confident that you will come away with a broader view of this complex era, a deserved respect for those American and South Vietnamese Marines who fought that war...and, enjoy a fascinating, well written story along the way.

"Ride the Thunder" reads like a novel, teaches like a training manual on leadership, dedication, devotion to duty and esprit de corps! It is a testament, not only to the principle characters, but to all Marines, US and Vietnamese alike, who "participated" in that most crucial battle which was launched by the DRV solely for the purpose of strengthening its bargaining position at the Paris peace talks.

Mr. Botkin goes one step beyond the usual warfare history and presents the personal sides of the main players. By bringing in family relationships, the reader gets a greater understanding of other things that came into play as critical battlefield decisions were made under great mental and physical stress at a time when the outcome of the situation could best be described as dire.

Another dimension to the story is what happened to many of the Vietnamese after the fall of Saigon in 1975. The trials and ordeals of those who were sent to the reeducation camps and their families has never received much attention. In presenting this phase of their lives, Mr. Botkin highlights the fact that the majority of the "reeducated" returned home stronger than ever in their desire to live as free men. Many, their children and grandchildren, are now US citizens and contrbuting members of our society!

This book is well written, well documented and painstakingly clarifies military terms and jargon which makes it less "threatening" to read for those not familiar with things Marine or military.

Read "Ride the Thunder"!

Thomas E. Gnibus
LtCol, USMC, Retired
Advisor, 2d Artillery Battalion, VNMC, 1971-1972

"Ride the Thunder" does what few other books on Vietnam accomplish: It humanizes the South Vietnamese fighting man beyond the characatures of graft, corruption, and cowardice. In fact many South Vietnamese fought superbly, effectively, and bravely.

This book sweeps away many of the overt canards of the cynical, morally bankrupt anti-war movement within the US, whose political maneuvering resulted in millions of civilian deaths in South East Asia following the departure of US forces and our craven withdrawal of material support in the 1970's.

It details the personal heroism of the brave Vietnamese who later blessed us all with their American citizenship. Think I'm exaggerating? Read the book and decide for yourself.

As we now grapple with a similar decision concerning our support of the war on terror, this book has added relevance.

"Ride the Thunder" is a must-read for young Americans attempting to make sense of a tumultuous period of American history. It ranks with "Dispatches" by Michael Herr, "In Love And War' by Jim and Sybil Stockdale, and "Hell In A Very Small Place" by Bernard Fall as one of the crucial books of the Vietnam conflict.

A great story of honor, courage, and commitment to something larger than yourself. Botkin has done what I might have thought impossible--get me to keep reading for almost 700 pages and wish there was more when I finished. Not a lot has been written about those years after TET when the South Vietnamese and their remaining American advisers turned back the most massive, all-out effort of the Communists to take over the South. What happened, and this book tells an important part of that South Vietnamese effort, is what could have happened in 1975 if America had lived up to its promise of air and naval firepower when the Communists ignored the peace treaty.
Botkin has written a terrific book.

"Ride the Thunder" author, Richard Botkin has written a well researched, powerfully compelling and yes; beautiful story that needed to be told. He pulls you into the story in the first few pages and holds you until the end.

Being the daughter, wife and mother of a Marine, this book is not just for the warrior or history buff. I highly recommend it to women and men who share a connection with those who serve in the military today.

For full disclosure, I am retired Marine officer who served with one of the Marines featured in this book during an earlier tour (1968) in Viet Nam. Like most of the reviewers, I absolutely loved this book. I am sure the author did not set out to write the definitive story of the war. What he does do, and does very well is tell the story of an epic battle, a battle that has not received the recognition (except in Marine Corps circles)it warrants. In telling the story of this battle he does provide additional information to set the stage and introduce a number of remarkable warriors. The war ended badly for the South Vietnamese government and the government of the United States played a critical role in that tragic end. There is no question, the government of South Viet Nam was not competent to defend itself without our help, and they did not have our help at the end. But that is not the story Mr. Botkin is relating. He has told the story of what we call the "Easter Offensive" and what the courage of individual warriors can accomplish. He does not sugar coat the performance of the South Vietnamese Army. He does use it to compare and contrast it with the South Vietnamese Marine Corps's valiant stand at Dong Ha. This is their and their U.S. Marine Co Van's story.

To those who wring their hands over the South Vietnamese government's alleged corruption, compare and contrast that with the absolute brutality of the North Vietnamese after the end of the war. A basically untold story is that of the Vietnamese who, like Lt.Col. Binh's family, have come to the United States and become wonderful success stories.

I review this work neither as a historian nor a critic. Rather, I am one who lived through the Vietnam years. This work adroitly captures both the deep discontent and dogged heroism of those years. I applaud Botkin for avoiding the temptation to lecture or sentimentalize. His account is straightforward storytelling at its best. That noted, a good story well told is the best mechanism for deep learning. Botkin's story gets the facts right while also completing the mosaic with the pain, discontent, and dedication of the era. In so doing, he introduces readers to real people, not icons or dogma. Well done!

Honor,courage and sacrifice are words often lost on todays self- centered world. The South Vietnamese Marines and the United States Marines serving with them during the Vietnam War highly exemplified these traits. This book highlights and profiles some of these courageous individuals who despite the polital posturing continued to fight against tremendous limitations to maintain their freedom. The personal perspective of a young South Vietnamese Marine Corps Officer and his service to his country before, during and after the war as told by Mr. Botkin gives the unique insight into self-sacrafice many of us will never understand. A must read for those that truly understand that freedom isn't free.

LtCol C.J. Burnett