From School Library Journal
Grade 4-7-Matty's brother Henry gets his turn to relate his adventures when he leaves their Kansas farm to become a Pony Express rider in this fourth book in the series. But even though the first-person narrative describes scary and bone-breaking work, it lacks good character development, particularly in its portrayal of William Cody, the teen's friend and a colorful individual in real life. Only Nine Finger Louie, a curmudgeon with a soft heart, comes alive; Ephraim Levy represents the traveling Jewish peddlers of the time. Natural pitfalls, Indian raids, and outlaws plague Henry but they are often dispatched with a lucky accident or two. The descriptions of an avalanche that traps him and Cody in a cave at Christmastime engage readers, but the boy spends more time as a scout, station attendant, and waiting than he does as a Pony Express rider. The volume has an excellent list of Web sites and, like its predecessors, an extensive section of historical notes. Choose Diane Yancey's Life on the Pony Express (Lucent, 2001) for the facts. For fun, recommend Brix McDonald's Riding on the Wind (Avenue, 1998), which has little historical accuracy but captures the thrill and weariness of the Pony Express with a girl rider, and Kristiana Gregory's Jimmy Spoon and the Pony Express (Scholastic, 1994) for a fast read.
Tina Zubak, Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, PACopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From the Author
Riding by Starlight is the story of Henry Trescott's adventures. The story idea was suggested to us by one of our friends, Judy Cowell, a middle school teacher who has been a great supporter of our books. After reading
Blue Creek Farm, Judy commented that Henry was such an interesting character that he needed his own story. When we wanted to write a fourth book, it seemed that Henry's story was a natural.