Most Helpful Customer Reviews
45 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Big One, February 8, 2002
This review is from: The Rift (Mass Market Paperback)
The New Madrid Fault lies in the south central part of the United States right on the Mississippi River. It is very real and very ominous last heard from in 1811-1812 in an 8.9 earthquake. So "The Rift" is not an apocalyptic fantasy, but a meticulously researched epic of what could happen tomorrow. You well may ask why isn't the earthquake of 1812 a part of every American child's history book as famous as the Chicago Fire or the San Francisco earthquake of 1906? The answer is how lightly populated the area was at that time; the number of people who could report on the catastrophe were few, so at present day we have little documentation. Mr. Williams has done an awesome job of investigation from everything concerning an earthquake to nuclear reactor plants. Every chapter is interwoven with contemporary accounts of the 1812 earthquake. We read what transpired over miles and miles of countryside, and then the author shows us what the same devastation would be like if that "countryside" had the City of Memphis sitting on it as it does today. I learned a little about the Richter scale: an 8.5 is not just a "little" stronger than an 8.3, but a thousand times stronger. An 8.9 (the top of the scale) is just short of affecting the entire planet. For comparison purposes the San Francisco quake registered 8.25 on the Richter scale. To bring us a story and give us a human's eye view of such mass destruction, Mr. Williams gives us a cross-section of characters, most of whom were sharply defined and realistic. From Jason, a young teenager who is Kalifornia Kool but displaced by his parent's divorce to Cabell's Mound, Missouri to Nick, an unemployed weapons engineer recently separated from his wife. (For some reason, I pictured Nick as Bryant Gumbel in the middle of the earthquake.) The hustling dealmaker Charlie struck me as the most poignant. He only existed in the cyberworld of suppose; when the earthquake hit, all he could think to do was dial 911 on his cell phone. "The Rift" is a monumental work in all senses of the word, but unlike many worthy tomes, highly readable and entertaining. Grade A
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
53 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wild Adventure on the Mississippi, March 26, 2003
This review is from: The Rift (Mass Market Paperback)
I love this book. At the age of three, 'way back in 1939, my parents brought me to Reelfoot Lake in the heart of the New Madrid fault country. I've never forgetten the eerieness of that experience and look for books about the historical earthquake or sci-fi projections of future ones. Most, like Hernon's 8.4, aren't any better written than a Robin Cook, but THE RIFT is different. It's literature! I am sure it's no accident that the plot is far more than a disaster novel. It's a picaresque travel-tale and its structure parallels the greatest of all American novels, HUCKLEBERRY FINN, with a rebellious white boy and an intelligent black man confronting dangers and weirded-out characters on the Mississippi and along its banks, and finding great depths of resourcefulness in themselves, as well as friendship and trust. And you get a delicious sci-fi disaster story on top of all that! Who could resist? I've lived in the South about half my life and found the characters entirely believable. Like Mark Twain, Williams shows us the murderous underside of fundamentalist religion, yet at the same time doesn't demonize the preacher and his surprisingly creative wife. Murderous fanatics they turn out to be, but a lot more likeable than the Ku Kluxers and the drugged-out Militia creep from Detroit. (I've lived in the Detroit area, too, and that little piece of smarm could be patterned after a few racist haters and baiters who got in the news.) Yet even he is not without a soul. Williams understands the politics of the American lumpenproletariat, the reasons for resentment and their unfortunate tendency to blame everyone but their genuine enemies. So you get a political analysis, too. Samuel Clemens, I am sure, must have read this novel in Heaven about as many times as I've read it down here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
What happened Walter Jon?, June 10, 2005
This review is from: The Rift (Mass Market Paperback)
I have to say before anything else that I am a huge Walter Jon Williams SF fan. This may cloud my review somewhat, because I came into the book with high expectations. Unfortunately these were really not met.
The highs of the book were (for me):
1. very good character development, not as good as some of his other works, but very good.
2. well researched
3. reader develops genuine feelings about the characters (see 1)
The lows:
1. He spends hundreds and hundreds of pages meticulously building this little world, then just seems to lose interest and throws it all together in the end. The book doesn't build to a crescendo, the characters just all end up together, good beats evil, and everybody goes home. It's almost as if it was looking like it would drag out to another 500 pages as he was writing it, so he just wrapped it up. He took one character he had developed over several chapters and just unceremoniously mashed him with a barge in a short paragraph and moved along smartly.
2. Related to 1, there are tons of loose ends left untied at the end of the book. What was the nature of the Sheriff's chest pains? What happened with the General's vision? her political future?
I just was left with the feeling that he sat back and said, Geez, this thing is getting too long, how can I wrap it up? Well, I'll move this guy to here, these people over there, kill this one, stuff them all in here, kill some more, whiz bang done.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|