Customer Reviews

Rimsky-Korsakov: The Tsar's Bride

5 star:		(9)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Out of all the four new operatic releases by Gergiev and Kirov the year this was released, this one by far is the newest of the crop. There is much impressive about this new recording, but something missing in the whole effort for it to really have cut to the heart of the matter. Among Russian opera fans, this is considered to be Rimsky-Korsakov's one 'verismo' opera. Apart from the one vulgar chemist in the mix, any hint of magic in his other operas is gone, and thereby as well the human element is more prominent in this piece. Some hint of Puccinian pathos, for instance for his 'little women' could be construed to have been written into the altogether rather brief, if not fully developed character of Marfa. Lyubasha and Gryaznoy make up the difference, with the extent to which Rimsky-Korsakov very ably fleshes these two characters out. The humanity of both of them gets as satisfactory and complex treatment as that of almost any other characters do in Russian opera. This is the second opera by Rimsky-Korsakov to treat a plot related to at least an episode in the life and reign of Ivan the Terrible, the first having been his first opera, Maid of Pskov. Ivan, in this case adn more or less a deus ex machina of sorts, is a mute part, as opposed to being quite close to taking top honors as protagonist in the earlier opera.

Gergiev plays the work in a most patrician manner - elegance, eloquence of the sound taking priority over much else. The orchestra of the Mariinsky Theater, as it is called now, offer playing of the highest calibre for him, nevertheless. Rimsky-Korsakov wrote this opera, in a way, as a tribute to his fallen rival, Tchaikovsky, so there is some merit to that. At the same time, the brilliance and panache of the execution of so much of the music, as performed here, takes over to the extent of glibly covering some of the most elemental facets of this enigmatic work. One's taste for a saltier approach to especially some of the choral passages, and to the wild anguish of the final scene, remains unfulfilled.

Most impressive in this cast is Olga Borodina as Lyubasha, just leaving to the imagination what her Amneris at the Met must have been like this season, in (in a number of subtle ways) a similar enough Verdi opera. Impassioned, voluptuous in tone to full measure, and incisive with the words, she is about all that anyone could ask, and almost surpassing Irina Arkhipova on the 1970's Bolshoi Melodiya set. Dmitri Hvorostovsky is also good and sympathetic as Gryaznoy, but shows a litle effort at delivering the earthier and more venal aspects of the character. In the effort, he comes out sounding just a tad bit too earnest for his own good. Marina Shaguch is the strident Marfa, perfectly adequate in relaxed passages, of which there are few in this part. She only finally comes into her own in her final aria. She is heard to better effect in Kaschhey the Deathless, also released by Philips last month. Evgeny Akimov is the thin, slightly reedy sounding Lykov, adequate enough in arias but not matching tone in duet with Shaguch well. The remainder of the cast is simply adequate, with the exception of Lyubov Sokolova as Petrovna (minor role), who is very nicely distinctive from the rest. Nikolai Gassiev puts in a fine cameo appearance as the lovestruck chemist who with Lyubasha and to help fulfill her vindictive ends, lets her strike up a mephistophelian deal of sorts with him. Given it is Olga Borodina, I certainly would not mind.

Five stars for Borodina, three for most of the rest. Given that the price is right so much more often so many places, the contributions of both Borodina and Hvorostovsky, and the relative and mostly undeserving obscurity of the material, I bump this set up to four stars.

This is by and large a great performance, particularly Olga Borodina as Lyubasha, great conducting and choral singing - true, Marina Shaguch is'nt as consistent as I've heard her, and is no match in terms of charisma and opulence for Galina Vishnevskaya on the old 70's recording, but she suggests the passive character of Marfa well. Sobakin (Bezzubenkov) and Griaznoi (Hvorostovsky) give characterful performances of great vocal stature.

BUT .... not one of the previous reviews mentions the music! This is one of Rimsky's most performed operas simply because it has a more conventional story with love interest and vengeance (and doesn't have the incredible scenic demands of his other operas, flying swans, invisible cities, melting snow-maidens etc.) It has to be said that much of the music is conventional and uninspired - Rimsky was a peculiar opera composer in that he was not touched by portraying the human condition, he excelled in depicting the legendary and fantastical. There are fine pages in 'The Tsar's Bride', a spirited overture, Marfa's two arias, which are gorgeously melodic and memorable, a few choruses, and he does manage to make the final scene work, but there is much in-between that is manufactured. If you are new to Rimsky's operas, and are curious, don't start with this one - hear him at full stretch re-inventing a fairy-tale Russia in Sadko or Kitezh, not trying to be Tchaikovsky, or a Russo-Italian halfway between bel-canto and verismo. The quality of the music in those latter works is much superior to this - Gergiev has taken 'Snow Maiden' into the Kirov's repertoire - hopefully they'll record that.

I think back to the day I first listened to this recording with nostalgia. This is the first Russian opera that I have listened to and I consider myself extremely lucky to have chosen this one. The music is simply gorgeous and there are some stunning vocal talents on display here.
Please forgive my superficial cliche when I say that the music sounds very "Russian" in a mesmerising way. Unlike Prokofiev and Shostakovich, which tend to be more dissonant and atonal (perhaps more typical of 20th Century music forms), this opera is heart-renchingly melodious. Again, by comparison, this is not the Bellini/Donizetti influence on other Russian compositions such as Glinka's Ruslan and Lyudmila (which sounds very "Italian" in my view). The dramatic force of the opera has been relayed by other reviewers. I only add that the haunting slavic chords do not disappoint: check out the Introduction in Scene 1 of Act 4. On to the singers.

Of ALL the Russian sopranos I have heard, Shaguch is my favourite. Her technique may not be perfect: her singing is described by some as initially "edgy" or "breathy", though this is not as off-putting as it sounds and she settles very well into her roles soon enough. But where the role calls for an innocent, young voice, MOST off-putting for me is the heavy, full rich vocals that are so RAMPANT within many recordings of Russian opera. What's worse is that this is often accompanied by a violent wobble that is forever beyond me. Shaguch, sounding every bit as Russian as she is/should, has a beautiful, youthfully sweet and compelling voice, with a moving vibrato (NOT wobble). Her interpretation of the role is immediately convincing and her mad scene is the stuff of legends! She would have been the IDEAL Fevroniya for Gergiev's recording of Kitezh but the only other available Kirov recording featuring this wonderful soprano is the fairy-tale opera "Kaschey the Immortal," also by Rimsky-Korsakov. She is also ideally paired with the youthful tenor of Evgyeny Akimov. Akimov sounds a little strained during the beautiful quartet in Scene 3 of Act 2, but gives a shining performance otherwise.

Dmitri Hvorostovy's dramatic baritone reminds me of a modern Sherril Milnes: warm yet firm, emotional and vocally stunning. His portrayal of Gryaznoy's arrogance, bravado, scheming and dispair is grippingly convincing.

When I heard the first notes sung by Olga Borodina's Lyubasha, I was immediately struck by (forgive the rhetoric) her smooth, honeyed tone! "Zdorovo klostnij" caught my breath in my throat. On the down-side, however, she could be more dramatic. Impressive as the recitative in Scene 4 is, her violent death in the final scene passes in silence. It is mainly her vocal gift that brings off her role so well.

Nikolai Gassiev's Bomyelius is also noteworthy. His character's craftiness and lust comes across very well. His appeals of "Lyumi menja" carry a strain that shows Bomyeli's sexual frustration.

Gennady Bezzubenkov's Sobakin is a towering monument. Here we encounter the deep Russian bass that has been so famous. The low last note at the end of his lament in Scene 1 of Act 4 separates the men from the boys...it CANNOT be faked! Only a TRUE bass can hit, let alone hold such a note.

It is unfortunate that the more matronly roles in many Russian opera almost always suffer the violent wobble I described earlier. Irina Loskutova's Domna Saburova is almost rediculous at first. This takes some getting used to. True, there are some beautiful moments, but the wobble is so vocally ungracefull it sounds as if she sings the notes AROUND her vocal line rather than follow the tune. This, for me, was the biggest set-back within the recording, but with such stunning music, the poorly sung role is actually compensated somewhat. The other roles are all well sung.

Yet another achievement for Gergiev and the Kirov Chorus and Orchestra. Gergiev conducts with feeling and the chorus is well synchronised. Though perhaps not as imaginatively as von Karajan or Abbado may have done, the score is well-conducted. Moreover, the fact that neither conducter actually DID (on record at least) makes Gergiev an undisputed hero.

From here, I would then recommend von Karajan's Rimsky-Korsakov arrangement of Mussorgsky's Boris Godinov (Decca); as well as Abbado's Shostakovich arrangement of the same opera (Deutche Grammophon). Following this, Abbado's Khovanshchina (also composed by Mussorgsky) would be a good idea....then, the world of Russian opera can be your playground!

This is better than nothing, I'd say. Much better was Galina Vizhneskaya and Irina Arkhipova's version. A pitty this version does not exist anymore. Less dramatic, less "true"...As very often Gergiev does...

Martin

Out of all the four new operatic releases by Gergiev and Kirov this year, this one by far is the newest of the crop. There is much impressive about this new recording, but something missing, in the whole effort really cutting to the heart of the matter. Gergiev plays the work in the most Imperial, patrician manner possible. As Rimsky-Korsakov wrote this opera, in a way, as a tribute to his fallen rival, Tchaikovsky, there is some merit in that. At the same time, the brilliance and panache of the execution of so much of the music takes over to the extent of glibly covering some of the most elemental facets of this enigmatic work. One's taste for a saltier approach to especially some of the choral passages, and to the wild anguish of the final scene, remains unfulfilled. Most impressive in the cast is Olga Borodina as Lyubasha, just leaving to the imagination what her Amneris at the Met must have been like this season, in (in a number of subtle ways) a similar enough Verdi opera. Impassioned, voluptuous in tone to full measure, and incisive with the words, she is about all that anyone could ask, and almost surpassing Irina Arkhipova on the 1970's Bolshoi set. Dmitri Hvorostovsky is also good and sympathetic as Gryaznoy, but a little effortful at delivering the earthier and more venal aspects of the character. In the effort, he comes out sounding just a tad bit too earnest for his own good. Marina Shaguch is the strident Marfa, perfectly adequate in relaxed passages, of which there are few in this part, and only finally coming into her own in her final aria. She is heard to better effect in Kaschhey the Deathless, also released by Philips last month. Evgeny Akimov is the thin, reedy sounding Lykov, not matching tone in duet with Shaguch well. The remainder of the cast is simply adequate, with the exception of the Petrovna (minor role) of Lyubov Sokolova, who is well above that. Five stars for Borodina, two to three for the rest.

This is a magnificent recording and provides a great introduction to the operas of Rimsky-Korsakov. The story reminds one of Verdi or Bellini might have written in that the story revolves around betrayal, love and jealousy. The story is loosely based on an event from the reign of Ivan IV (the Terrible) whose third wife, the daughter of a Novgorod merchant) died following her wedding. The Tsar is never on stage but his eye falls upon Marfa, whom he surprisingly selects as his bride. Marfa is betrothed to Ivan Lukov but is desired by Grigory Gryaznoy, who wants to discard his current lover, Luybasha. Lyubasha is equally determined to hang onto Gryaznoy. There follows plots and counter-plots with a sinister German named Bomelius dispensing love potions and poisons.

The music is perfectly suited for the intrigue and double-dealing of the story. The famous overture sets the tone for the opera of excitement and is rousingly performed by the Kirov Orchestra. The cast in this recording is superb: Olga Borodina is terrific as Luybasha and Dmitri Horostovski makes an excellent Gryaznoy, a part that is difficult to bring off as a sympathetic villain. Marina Shaguch is great in the role of Marfa, the mad scene being particularly well sung. Valery Gergiev conducts with sensitivity for the drama of the opera and allows the singers full expression of their characters. The Kirov Opera Chorus is on top form.

The Tsar's Bride is popular in Russia but is rarely performed in western countries. I hope that it discovered by opera companies in the US but until then, we have the superb recording.

Rimsky-Korsakov's The Tsar's Bride is one of my favorite operas. The role of Lyubasha, portrayed by Olga Borodina, is quite complex: is she a villain or not? Marfa's mad scene in the end is another highlight, filled with nostalgia and pity. Her high Ab, beautifully done by Marina Shaguch, sits over the orchestra and is filled with the emotion from the scene. Borodina's rendition of Lyubasha's song is perfectly on tune and her phrazing and tone is good as well. Hvorovstovsky's Gryaznoy is average. He is often quite sharp in the first act, and his dynamics are not as broad as I would have liked.

This is one of my desert island CDs. It's not because of an outstanding cast (I do believe Olga Borodina was quite good, though I disliked Hvorostovsky), but it is for the music.

Lyubasha's Song is done very well by Borodina. When the clarinets and horns come in with a short two measure phrase (the rest of the aria is unaccompanied), one can tell Borodina has stayed on pitch the entire opera (not gradually moving sharper or flatter).

My favorite phrase in the opera, the last line of Marfa, has an exquisite a2 which has so much unknown sorrow and nostalgia in it one cannot help but feel an overwhelming amount of pity for Marfa.

There is an aria for almost every character, but the transitions are just as beautiful as the arias themselves. The intermezzo between acts one and two sounds exactly as one would imagine dusk to sound, beginning with pizzicato strings and violins and adding more and more instruments until the chorus comes in as well.

The Tsar's Bride isn't Rimsky-Korsakov's best opera (it doesn't hold a candle to Legend of Kitezh, Snow Maiden, Sadko or Christmas Eve), but this recording is surely one of the best Rimsky-Korsakov opera recordings available. The opera is apparently still popular in Russian opera houses and the music is definitely engaging, but somewhat lighter and jollier than most other Rimsky scores (the payoff is a loss of magical fairy-tale atmosphere), but the marvelous, inventive orchestration is all there, and Rimsky's musical imagination was surely at the top when he composed this one - variegated, colorful and often memorable. The plot is wordy and the libretto has a tendency to seem stuck at time, but Rimsky usually saves the day, and the work doesn't really contain any really boring moments, from the catchy overture to the well-constructed final scene.

Fortunately the singing is quite simply superb overall; Olga Borodina has all the power, resources and range needed for an impressive and excellently sung Lyubasha, and Marina Shaguch is very satisfying as Marfa - if perhaps stronger in terms of intensity and character than actual beauty of tone. I must also mention Evgeny Akimov as Lykov, whose characterization is warmly rounded, almost sensual. Yet it is Hvorostovsky who stands out, as Gryaznoy - his singing is utterly impressive, so nuanced and colorfully characterized it is almost a marvel. The chorus and orchestra give riveting performances; all details are there, and carefully shaped and shaded, but the forward momentum is never jeopardized - indeed, the most notable feature of this performance is probably the sheer brilliance and forward drive Gergiev accomplishes. Sound is good as well, and this set is recommended with some enthusiasm.

While I agree with the previous reviewer about his concerns about this recording I do not agree with his star rating. Olga Borodina and Valery Gergiev make this recording. They are marvelous (as is the Maestro's orchestra and chorus). I simply could not let the Borodina/Gergiev/Kirov/Phillips recording stay at three stars. Thanks, Mr. Spence for your insight and Ms. Borodina and Maestro Gergiev for your gifts. (I hope Amazon does not tire of my Gergiev reviews!)