I was introduced to The Roots when I heard the track "Distortion To Static". The track came from what I thought at the time was their debut CD,
Do You Want More?!!!??!. I eventually found out that their debut CD was
Organix. What I instantly liked about The Roots is that they instantly reminded me of a hip hop band. They used alot of live instruments and you had MCs and other members in the group who focused on just playing instruments and producing the music. Stetsasonic clearly was the hip hop blueprint to this but since Earth, Wind & Fire was one of my favorite r&b groups of all time, The Roots reminded me of the hip hop version of Earth, Wind & Fire.
Illadelph Halflife was released in 1996. The first single, Clones, is easily one of my favorite Roots' tracks of all time. Black Thought, Malik B, Dice Raw & M.A.R.S. provided nice verses and Kelo provided phenominal production on the track.
Things Fall Apart was released next and that clearly is my favorite Roots CD of all time. You could play the CD from beginning to end and rappers such as Mos Def, Common, Beanie Sigel and Eve contributed to quality verses as well.
Phrenology was released in 2002 and was clearly different than any other Roots CD that I had ever heard before. It definitely took more than one listen for me to become a fan of this CD.
The Tipping Point took the Roots back to basics with tracks like "Star", "Guns Are Drawn" and "Boom". A year later The Roots or should I say Geffen released
Home Grown! The Beginner's Guide to Understanding the Roots, Vol. 1 and
Home Grown! The Beginner's Guide to Understanding the Roots, Vol. 2. The best parts of both of these CDs are the alternative versions that are featured on both CDs and "Proceed 2".
Game Theory would be the 1st CD that The Roots released on Def Jam Records. The CD wasn't marketed properly but if you were a fan of The Roots you were able to tolerate the "dark" energy that came with the CD. Tracks such as "False Media", "Don't Feel Right", "Long Time" w/Peedi Peedi, and the tribute to J Dilla, "Can't Stop This" were my favorites and "Game Theory" was my 2nd favorite rap release of 2006 next to Ghostface's "Fishscale".
"Rising Down" was released on April 29, 2008. Before the CD was released I was privleged to have already heard "75 Bars", "Get Busy" w/Dice Raw & Peedi Peedi, "Rising Up" w/Wale and Chrisette Michele, and "Birthday Girl" (which you can only find on Itunes now because it's not on "Rising Down") on their myspace page and "Rising Down" w/Mos Def & Styles P. and "Criminal" w/Truck North & Saigon on hiphopdx.com. Other than "Birthday Girl" all of the other tracks that I heard were definitely tracks that would be right up there with your favorite tracks from The Roots. "Rising Down" features Mos Def, Black Thought & Styles P on a lyrical free for all that has them talking about things that are going wrong in the world we live in today. All 3 rappers have quality verses and this is my 2nd favorite track on the CD. The energy of "Get Busy" will definitely catch your attention as Black Thought rips this track to shreds with the help of Dice Raw & Peedi Peedi. "75 Bars" has ?uestlove giving an outstanding performance on the drums and Black Thought takes care of things from there. "Criminal" may take a few listens because of the Kevin Hanson chorus but once you listen to the lyrics, especially Saigon's verse, then this track will also be one of your favorites. "I Can't Help It" will just have you going crazy the first couple of times that you hear it. Malik B, who I am glad is back in the MC rotation again, gets things started and Porn ends things on a nice note. Mercedes Martinez of the group Jazzyfatnastees and Dice Raw do a nice job on the hook as well. "Singing Man" has Dice Raw giving an energetic chorus and Black Thought, Truck North, Porn and Dice Raw all giving nice verses as well. "Unwritten", which also features Mercedes Martinez, is more of an interlude that you will wish was a full length track. "Lost Desire" has Malik B, Black Thought & Talib Kweli on the verses and
?uestlove on the hook. You will be impressed with the energy and subject matter of this track. "Rising Up" is the first video that I saw from "Rising Down" and it features Wale & Chrisette Michele. The song employs a DC go-go beat and Black Thought and Wale will have you doing a 2 step every time you hear the track.
Overall, I feel that "Rising Down", is right up there with the rest of their top notch material. However, "Rising Down" contains the same "dark" energy that came from "Game Theory". In my opinion, if you are not a fan of "Game Theory" then you may not like "Rising Down". Because of the way sales are going and the push that is being made to make B.S. mainstream rap the focus of things in 2008, it seems that The Roots are doing their best to buck the system and make the type of music that they want to make, which I feel is the best way to go. If you are a fan of the majority of The Roots' previous releases, then you shouldn't pass up on "Rising Down".
James' Top 5
1) Get Busy w/Dice Raw & Peedi Peedi
2) Rising Down w/Mos Def & Styles P.
3) 75 Bars
4) Criminal w/Saigon, Truck North & Kevin Hanson
5) I Can't Help It w/Malik B, Dice Raw, Porn & Mercedes Martinez
Honorable Mention:
Rising Up w/Wale & Chrisette Michele
Lost Desire w/Malik B & Talib Kweli
Singing Man w/Dice Raw, Porn & Truck North
I Will Not Apologize w/Porn, Truck North & Talib Kweli