6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Drive-by exubrance, November 18, 2008
This review is from: Roadside Americana (Hardcover)
You can probably fill a bookcase or two with books like this. They pop-up in tourist souvenir shops everywhere, aimed at a general readership and most of them are easily forgotten. I bought this one mainly because of the large size though as another reviewer has rightly said the photo quality, overall, is average and I can add to this by saying the page design is bland and predictable.
However I think there are good points, the coverage is rather comprehensive, from the Hollywood sign, Randy's Donuts in Inglewood, Los Angeles, Haines Shoe House, York, Pennsylvania to the Cadillac Ranch in Amarillo, Texas. These are all sort of national treasures and there are plenty more in the book, as large photos, too. Americana in the title helps define what should be included though that also raises the question: just how tacky and temporary can a structure be before it's not worth including, fortunately not too many here fall into that category.
If you can find it cheap enough this isn't a bad buy (at the original price I would have definitely passed) but if you like this sort of roadside exuberance check out Jim Heimann's lovely
California Crazy and Beyond: Roadside Vernacular Architecture, David Graham has done four roadside books and the leader of the pack John Margolies has several books. Ones I've enjoyed are:
Fun Along the Road: American Tourist Attractions - Another Amazing Album from America's Number One Roadside Observer and
The End of the Road: Vanishing Highway Architecture in America in several editions but his greatest book is
John Margolies: Roadside America, a stunning coffee-table book with four hundred big page photos.
***SEE SOME INSIDE PAGES by clicking 'customer images' under the cover.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great concept brought down by inconsistent image quality, February 23, 2006
This review is from: Roadside Americana (Hardcover)
"Roadside Americana" consists of just under 200 images that record a slice of American history related to automobile travel, and almost anyone with experience in long-distance road trips will be familiar with a few of the roadside attractions depicted. From a curiosity standpoint, the subjects are fun and intriguing, and likely to evoke a chuckle or two; however, considering photographic quality, the range is all over the board: first-rate professional to downright amateurish. It's the latter characterization that brought about a bit of disappointment.
The best examples I've seen of Americana imagery of this type come from a photographer named John Margolies, who possesses the professionalism and diligence to capture countless roadside oddities using the best angle and optimum light. He is serious about the latter criterion, as one of his trademarks is to insist on having a blue sky as a background for his subject matter. Unfortunately, no Margolies photos appear in this book (he's published many of his own, and Smithsonian magazine featured him back in November 1988).
What you get are nearly 200 images, almost all color, ranging in size from 3"x4" to nearly a whole page. I'd say about 60 percent of them are of excellent artistic quality: good color, lighting and exposure. John Elk III, Jack Olson Photography and Nick Wheeler Photography are a few examples of those that contributed noteworthy ones. Much of the remaining 40 percent are marred by photographic let-downs, such as poor framing, odd perspectives, unfortunate lighting (e.g., pesky shadows or a washed-out sky) and even sloppy focusing. Each photo has an accompanying caption which gives a history of the object in a few sentences. These and the descriptive text at the beginning of each chapter are well written by Eric Peterson, and I found them quite enjoyable.
The subject matter is grouped into six chapters: landmarks, statue gardens, architecture, "world's largest," gas/food/lodging (my favorite) and "unclassifiable." That makes sense. On the downside, the photographic credits appear at the very beginning of the book, alphabetically by photographer; so, in order to find credits for a given image one must scan the whole list to locate a page number. This becomes really annoying for those pages where there are two or more images.
Overall, as an Americana photo log, most will enjoy this book. As a presentation of photographic artistry, I'm afraid the shortcomings are a bit too frequent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Giant roadside tourist attractions for the road trip, November 30, 2009
Nice coffee table book to thumb through, although I confess to reading the whole thing cover to cover. I really enjoyed looking at the weird stuff each town comes up with. I mean most of us have see the giant lumber jack, but giant corn? When I was a kid, my dad refused to stop and look at these, as he thought they were too corny, but I still like them. The book is 12 by 12 in size, close to 200 photos spread over 128 pages. The book explains the history of the roadside attraction, especially anything that has been built to giant size. The picnic basket on the cover is an office building by the way. It is broken into easy to find categories. The photos were satisfactory, and the text was informative. I have a couple of books on this subject, and I think this is my favorite.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
