6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding, Moving Biography, July 24, 1995
By A Customer
This review is from: Robert Louis Stevenson:: A Biography (Hardcover)
Incredible, exciting, poignant biography of an
underrated writer and wonderful man.
Although McLynn is obviously a fan, it never becomes hagiography.
This will have you reading Treasue Island again and wanting to
travel to Scotland and Samoa.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fine Work, but Focuses More on Fanny than Stevenson, October 28, 2005
This review is from: Robert Louis Stevenson:: A Biography (Hardcover)
This biography starts off well, with vivid descriptions of Stevenson's youth and days in Edinburgh. In fact, when I met someone from Scotland, I could talk about Edinburgh as if I'd been there, so vivid were many of the scenes and stories.
There's also very good and in-depth looks at Stevenson's relationship with his father, as well as his family's indignation when Stevenson refused to continue in their religious faith.
Once Stevenson's wife enters his life, though, she takes over the book to the point where you resent her even more than Stevenson's parents did. One might think this is simply being accurate to life, but the Index says it all - there's three entire columns devoted to Fanny, including seven pages on Fanny "as gardener."
I picked up this book to know about Stevenson the writer, and there's precious little of it to be found here. Again, from the Index, for Stevenson it lists forty-one pages on his "attitude to sex" and just one page "on the art of writing prose." There's also just two pages on "literary training of" and just one page on both "influences" and "influences on later writers" (both the same page).
But if you want the whole marriage drama, there's twenty-six pages on Fanny's hypochondria, twenty-seven on "depressive illness of" and over thirty pages on her "antagonism between her and Henley," including pages 288-302.
The other fault I found with the book is that there's numerous passages of poetry and other works written in French and Latin, but with no translation in the footnotes. With the web, one could type it all into Google Translate to find out what it says, but I read this fifteen years ago, and it was very frustrating not to be told what those passages say.
In the end, it's a well-researched and a hefty book with a handsome look to it, but again, it focuses on such aspects as a listing of what was in Fanny's picnic basket on a trip into the country, but little about Stevenson working as a writer. So for anyone seeking to know about Stevenson's marriage, this book is perfect. Otherwise, I'd recommend it right up to the point where Fanny arrives.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A detailed first- rate life of Stevenson, September 12, 2010
This review is from: Robert Louis Stevenson:: A Biography (Hardcover)
I do not know the work of Robert Louis Stevenson that well. 'Treasure Island' was required reading in Eight Grade, but the still vivid and somewhat frightening impression I have of it comes from the movie version. 'Kidnapped' I found unreadable. And I have no knowledge whatsoever of Stevenson's longer fictions. I read 'Jekyll and Hyde' a couple of years ago and found it disturbing and unpleasant.
So a great fan of Stevenson I am not.
Why then did I go through an over five- hundred page biography on him? First of all I suppose because I love reading biographies of writers. But secondly, because this one is so well- done and contains interesting detail on the life on every page.
Stevenson was the son of a very wealthy and historically prominent Scottish family, who were the lighthouse- builders of Scotland. The first part of the volume tells much about Stevenson's conflict with his Calvinist strong- minded and strong- willed father. Stevenson who was sickly all his life had an extraordinary feel for language and for Beauty.
A good part of the book has to do with his life with another close character his wife Fanny Osbourne. In this biography the conventional picture of her as saintly devoted wife is trashed completely. She is seen as principal cause for the stress which led to the disastrous stroke which ended Stevenson's life at the age of forty- four. Her son Lloyd who was pampered by Stevenson also infuriated through what Stevenson regarded as his immoral and irresponsible behavior.
The book also tells however of Stevenson's many literary friendships and one of its most beautiful passages is the condolence letter sent to his widow by Henry James.
MacLynn is a very intelligent writer and provides excellent analyses of Stevenson's major works.
Perhaps more than anything else it is a realistic picture of the difficulties of life of a person of extraordinary privilege and above all literary genius.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No