Customer Reviews

Roberto Alagna - Berlioz

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

It seems that one of the chronic diseases of modern times is a lowering of standards of operatic singing. A decline or just a temporary slump? There was a comparable shortage of new voices of real quality in the inter war years of the last century, but things improved after ww2. It certainly seems that most of todays great singers are not as great when compared to their predecessors, but there are a select few that measure up i think. Perhaps most of us are so used to hearing butchers like russel watson, or better but still mediocre singers labelled as "great", that when someone truly great comes along we fail to recognise their quality.

Roberto Alagna is the finest tenor of his type (heroic-lyric) since 1960, when we lost the great Jussi Bjorling. His voice is warm, his style individual, his breathing technique simply phenomonal (listen to his long breath span in the La Juive aria on his french arias disc, and on numerous examples on this disc).

Did a review before mine label him as not being good enough to make a choir audition? was Jussi Bjorling a choir boy? was his predeccesor and compatriot the great Georges Thill good enough to be in a choir? These are questions we must seriously ponder. Maybe Caruso was a cold, inexpressive and inhuman singer? Maybe Pavarotti faked those high c's in Daughter of the Regiment? Does he really wear a fat suit? hmmmmm......

Anyway, when berlioz wrote his music, it was sung for him during his lifetime by singers much more like Alagna than Vickers. If we can listen to it without thinking that Alagna is trying to impersonate him, we might find that, hey, this tenor is very different, both in his voice and his basic approach to singing. His interpretation is his own.

Nowhere is it set in stone that only a purely dramatic tenor can sing this music. This is just the sort of repetoire that Alagna excels in. Infact no one today can match him in his singing of just about anything french, and this disc proves him to be the most significant french tenor since the late Thill.

Must have been one hell of a choir he was going for.

When I raved about Roberto Alagna's 'French Arias' two years ago, I commented that a disc from him dedicated to Berlioz was essential, especially since Berlioz is his favorite composer. This disc has now arrived, and is not only a tremendous artistic achievement for Alagna, it may very well be the most important classical CD released in this Berlioz centennial year.

What makes this disc so remarkable is that it shows just how devoted Alagna is to this composer - no other tenor has committed this much Berlioz to a solo recording, not even Nicolai Gedda or Alagna's great French predecessor Georges Thill. This isn't too much of a surprise because the music is often extremely difficult, and requires a great vocal, stylistic and dramatic range. Alagna is up to every challenge and sings even the heaviest music here with remarkable ease - considerably more so than he has been showing lately in dramatic Italian repertory - but still has enough sweetness and elegance for most of the lighter music. Not even Alagna's closest competitors in this music today, the splendid Ben Heppner and Marcello Giordani, can match him for sheer artistic imagination, character identification, and, for lack of a better word, Frenchness. Alagna's French diction dwarfs even many other native singers. And did I mention the gorgeous voice? To put the icing on the cake, EMI provides Alagna with the finest supporting forces. These include not only Alagna's wife, the magnificent soprano Angela Gheorghiu, and several superb choruses including the French Army Chorus, but in the most luxurious casting imaginable, the spoken lines are delivered by no less than Gerard Depardieu!

The album begins with Enee in 'Les Troyens', one of Alagna's dream roles. He ably handles the fiendish tessitura of Enee's entrance 'Du peuple et des soldats' - a passage reputably even more difficult than Otello's entrance. In 'Inutiles regrets' he experiences the full measure of Enee's heroism, frustration, and love for Didon. Turning to Iopas, in 'O blonde Ceres' , Alagna perfectly captures the innocent joy of being in nature and the sense of worship, even if he could have provided a bit less volume and a bit more gentleness. I regret that Alagna does not include Hylas' gorgeous serenade 'Vallon sonore' and hope he records it on a future CD. Another role in Alagna's future is Benvenuto Cellini, and on the basis of the two arias here (particularly a 'Seul pour lutter' superior even to Gedda's) it is definitely something to look forward to.

The finest selection here is from `L'Enfance du Christ' - clear, simple, dignified, full of tenderness and reverence. Also splendid are the selections from `La Damnation de Faust'. After a gentle, sensuous and awestruck rendition of 'Merci, doux crepuscule', Alagna is joined by Gheorghiu for a magnificent account of 'Ange adore', notable not only for Gheorghiu's usual radiance and passion but also for Alagna's glorious ascensions to sweet, high C#s. Thanks to the perfect blending of their voices, it nearly equals their finest duet recording - again Berlioz - the 'Nuit d'ivresse' on their first duet album. This is followed by Alagna's second recording of 'Nature immense', which may have just a bit more intensity and edge than the one on `French Arias'. On a lighter note, this tenor most famous for his astonishing Romeo now gives us his fleet, elegant Mercutio. He is also an eager, charming, and appropriately love-struck Benedict.

As in all his solo and duet recordings, Alagna unearths and performs rarities that may be unknown to all but the most fanatic historical collectors. The most notable of these is 'Lelio', the symphonic poem Berlioz wrote in order to recover from the hellish experience of writing the 'Symphonie Fantastique'. In the Song of the Fisherman. Alagna not only has an excellent rapport with pianist Jeff Cohen, but once again makes ascensions to miraculous high notes look easy, and truly brings out the poetry of the words. Based on this, I am eager for Alagna to perform more song repertory with piano both on recordings and in live recitals. How about 'Les Nuit D'Ete', almost never recorded in its entirety by a tenor? As Lelio, Depardieu provides a perfect portrait of despair and longing - and I had never realized just how beautiful HIS voice is! And in 'O mon bonheur', the heavens really do open on Alagna's gorgeous high A (?). However, while I again applaud Alagna's questing spirit for bringing out the earlier tenor version of Mephistopheles' Serenade (not from 'La Damnation de Faust' but from it's precursor 'Huit Scenes du Faust'), he sings it a bit too heavily. Nor does he really sound like the 'singing voice' of the baritonal Depardieu.

The disc ends with a thrilling rendition of the Marseillaise, where Alagna and the massed choral forces do a splendid job. I have always wanted to hear him sing this, and am delighted to report that he also did so at a Parisian rally last May to counter French fascist Jean-Marie Le Pen.

Bertrand de Billy is one of the finest conductors of French opera of our day, providing excellent support for Alagna and evoking luminous and sensitive playing from the Covent Garden Orchestra. Although I regret that, unlike 'Bel Canto', the documentation does not include a note from Alagna, the thick booklet contains full texts and translations, as well as an essay about Berlioz and his tenors and notes on each track by British Berlioz scholar Hugh McDonald.

Alagna recently turned 40 and seems to be in his prime - at least in French music. I would be overjoyed to hear more complete Berlioz from this team, but if that is impossible, let's just have another five or six French solo albums from Alagna, and a French duet disc with Gheorghiu. In the meantime, Alagna's work here will give any lover of Berlioz - or someone who wishes to become one - much to savor and discover.

Roberto Alagna gets it.
Berlioz' music is a challenge. In fact I find it difficult to find performances that shed true light on what Berlioz was attempting to create. (Witness Placido's voice cracking on the Mets, le Troyen.) As with most recordings of Berlioz' works, you get a glimmer, but it's a taste not quite the feast. Something is missing. Not by fault of the performer in most instances, in fact it's the extremes that the composer imposes that render the performance just slight of a true rendition.
Berlioz' music consists of difficult extremes, from faint subtlety to extreme bravado. A performer must be of true virtuoso ilk to take his works on.
Listen to "Chant de Bonheur". Alagna scales amazing extremes like a true Master. But not as a means to an end, instead, engendering true grace to the piece itself. Of this piece, it's the best recording of it I have ever heard.
Roberto Alagna is an artist that, like I said before, gets it. He takes the bull by the horns so to speak and tames it beautifully.
Ben Hepner's disc which came out last year, was a welcome bow to certain pieces that one had not heard for a long time. Refreshing, but not virtuosic. It felt forced and pale. A rather typical "Operatic" rendering of the works.
An attempt.
This disc on the other hand is more daring. From the choice of the pieces to the execution, it delivers an excellent experience.
My most coveted and beloved tenor piece "Sur Les Monts Les Plus Sauvages" is given the royal treatment here. Listen and please let me know of any performance that renders it with such subtlety and utter bliss.
All in all a disc well worth it, highly recommended especially in celebration of the bicentennial of a composer that is most often misunderstood and neglected. But one that also enabled a musical vocabulary that we use, rather matter of factly, to this day.

Robert Levine's review for amazon is far more accurate than the outraged negative rants seen here.

Roberto Alagna is a superb French stylist, as one would hope to find in a native Frenchman. Moreover, his voice is well-suited to the extremes of Berlioz' writing - it's not a huge voice, which is very much to his advantage, since he can control his piano singing and provide nuances that other singers don't. And unlike most French-style tenors, Alagna's voice has enough bottom weight and more than enough ping to avoid being too nasally or tweety. There's a lot of emotion in his work as well as intelligence, and I really like the way he shows us new ways of hearing... every singer's voice is individual, very different, and that's especially true of tenors - Alagna's not afraid to explore that. Berlioz is a great match for him. It's one of my favorite CDs.

I just got this excellent recording.

While driving to work, I played over the cell Cellini's aria "Sur Les Monts Les Plus Sauvages" ,for a female friend.

When it was over she said :"I hope you pulled over while you were playing this for me".

Why, I said?

Because it is orgasmic the way Alagna sings this aria!

And she is right. This aria alone is worth the price of the disc.

A program of difficult and complex compositions by Hector Berlioz is a challenge that Roberto Alagna who is the voice of the century has no problem with and this is a stunning collection of masterful performances that are unmatched today. Anyone who wants to enjoy one of the greatest tenors in our lifetime will play this brilliant and beautifully produced collection endlessly and grow to love it as one of the greatest ever vocal recitals. Sit back with a fine bottle of wine and marvel at a magnificent singer who sings with beautifully shaded vocal beauty and emotional depth that is spectacular and rare in the wonderful world of music!!! Enjoy and don't miss this awesome masterpiece...anyone who loves a great voice will love this stunning collection of powerful performances that will make a classical musical lover out of anyone in a quick musical minute along with Mr. Alagna's wonderful "French Arias" vocal masterpiece!!! Bravo Roberto~you are the greatest!!!

I have not paid much attention to this singer and yesterday, on the way out of the music store, I grabbed a copy of this CD out of a display.

The first tracks are excerpts from Les Troyens. Alagna is really out of his depths with this one. Why pretend he's Vickers or Heppner when he is just good enough for the church choir! It is TERRIBLE and it doesn't get better whith the rest of the CD. I'm not going to give any more attention to this CD, that's for sure.

Alagna does not have the vocal heft for Énée nor are his renditions of the "Benvenuto Cellini" arias comparable to Nicolai Gedda's. Like his wife, Angela Gheorghiu, he is recording stuff he would NEVER be able to handle on stage. This is the worst form of studio trickery and should be frowned upon by all opera lovers. This practice of opera singers recording things that they would never be able to sing on stage is an outrage, especially in today's opera world!

It was a big shock to hear Yu Qiang Dai's debut cd. He is, I think, the best lirico-spinto tenor nowadays. He has a lovely voice, which is very well produced. The center is wonderful, the lower notes are good, the high notes are shining and of fantastic quality... the singing through the passage is very well handled. He is an itelligent musical interpreter and singer, with an interesting and appealing line and sense of style. Very good dynamic changes. He offers some of the absolutely best renditions of some arias (nessun dorma and cielo e mar, for example) that I have heard in many years.

He still has to work his Italian (specially the consonants) and his French. But there were great historical tenors with bigger idiomatical problems.

Despite taking spinto repertoire, Yu never pushes, never tries to make the voice sound darker than it is, everything is always under control, and he takes the chance to give very stylish renditions (for example, of una furtiva lagrima), which is strange for tenors who "want to sing spinto".

The tenor is a fantastic discovery, one of the best ones around. Actually, all my criticism goes to EMI and the production of the CD: no choirs, no solists (for example, for the aria of Cavalleria, where the mother should sing her line), and the acoustic "atmosphere" has made some people to doubt if Yu's voice is really as big as it seems (people who saw his Cavaradossi at Covent Garden say that it is very big, actually).

Not a the best production job by the people of EMI, but five stars (ten if possible) for the singer. Simply wonderful.

I have not paid much attention to this singer and yesterday, on the way out of the music store, I grabbed a copy of this CD out of a display.
The first tracks are excerpts from Les Troyens. Alagna is really out of his dephts with this one. Why pretend he's Vickers or Hepner when he is just good enough for the church choir! It is TERRIBLE and it doesn't get better whith the rest of the CD. I'm not going to give any more attention, for sure.

Listening to Alagna's nasal, metallic tenor voice is torture beyond belief! Avoid this CD at all costs!