Customer Reviews

Robot Dreams

5 star:		(20)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The wordless graphic novel for children. Adults, quite frankly, haven't a clue how to deal with them. But for those kids intimidated by words, new to the English language, or just fond of visual storytelling, these new forms of literature are nothing less than a godsend. From the picture book-sized, The Boy, the Bear, the Baron, the Bard to Andy Runton's remarkably popular, Owly series, wordless has never been hotter amongst the young `uns. More to the point, graphic novel imprint First Second has never been intimidated by new formats. Its mighty peculiar A.L.I.E.E.E.N., for example, was essentially wordless (not to say wuh-eird weird weird). Though First Second may tend to look to other nations for their stories, they're certainly not afraid of a little homegrown talent on the side. Enter Sara Varon. Best known at the moment for the wordless picture book Chicken And Cat, this Brooklyn resident has produced a full-blown novel of remarkable sweetness. Linear and lovely, broken up with daydreams and fantasies, "Robot Dreams" is a small "simple" story of friendship and letting go. Relationships have never pared down so perfectly.

A dog purchases a robot kit so that he might have a friend to hang out with. The robot, a mellow type, enjoys hanging out with the dog, eating popcorn, watching movies, and going to the library. A trip to the beach, however, turns out to be a less than stellar idea when the robot goes swimming only to rust up and find that it can no longer move. The dog goes home for the night, intending to take the robot along later. Unfortunately, the beach is closed the next day and the poor robot is stuck on the sand, dreaming of things both good and bad. As the months go by, both robot and dog have their own small adventures, real and unreal. By the end, however, they each find new and separate companions. The last image in the book is of the robot seeing the dog with another robot, and understanding that this is a case when you've just got to let the person you love go.

You get certain ideas about a book when you look at it. Reading about the concept and glancing at the cover, I had the vague idea that the title would be a series of small adventures shared by the dog and the robot. So when the robot seized up 18 pages into the narrative and was abandoned by his companion (with more than 150 pages to go) I admit that I was a little shocked. Out the window go all my assumptions about the story. Though it's difficult to call it "writing" without having any words to direct you to, Varon's grasp of what makes a good narrative serves her very well here. It doesn't hurt matters any that I also love Varon's style. She's one of those deceptively simple artists. You feel a real and solid attachment to the creatures she's created, no matter how odd they may seem. There's also a real emotional arc to the tale. For example the robot at one point dreams of the betrayal it would feel if the dog found a new robot to hang out with (as it does later in the story). The dog, for its part, finds a variety of different friends during its travels. Birds. Anteaters. A snowman that comes to such a subtle end that it makes Raymond Briggs look like a murderer in comparison.

Varon spots her book with little shout-outs to her various interests and inspirations. Canny readers will notice that near the end the robot and its raccoon friend are reading books like The Rabbi's Cat, by Joann Sfar. I was intrigued by this mention of a fellow graphic novelist. Yet as my husband was quick to point out, Varon is rather similar to Sfar in that her stories are about extraordinary creatures doing relatively mundane things. Of course, my husband also says that this book is akin to The Giving Tree, had the tree found someone new to love it instead of that nasty boy. I couldn't disagree more, but I thought I'd mention it here, just in case you want to see for yourself whether or not it's true.

By and large, "Robot Dreams" is that rare combination of the sweet and the emotionally resonant. To me, this is basically a story about friendship, love, and how to move on when your heart's been broken. It just happens to also be wrapped up in a very innocent tale of a dog and his robot. Undoubtedly this will fly right under the radar of a lot of people who will miss the serious thread lurking beneath the pretty packaging. It's no easy task to produce a narrative sequence without a single spoken word. Harder still to drill home a heart's journey. Varon, then, is one to watch out for. A weirdly magnificent tale.

An emotional journey of friendship, one that every person can relate to. This simple, wordless story reflects the joy and pain of friendship, but ultimately, how each relationship in our lives shapes us. Friends come and go, but they always remain within us. This book will act as a catalyst for discussion and reflection of friendship and relationships among readers of all ages. It is a rare feat for a book to evoke such emotion. Way to go, Sara Varon! You've created a timeless work of art!

Add my 5 stars to all the others here! I first came across Sarah Varon's work through her slim volume "Sweaterweather," and immediately recognized her remarkable gift as a comics artist. But as delightful as that first collection was, this is absolutely wonderful. All-ages in the best sense of the word, adults will enjoy this nearly wordless graphic novel as much as children -- but any child should embrace it wholeheartedly.

On the surface it's a story about a dog & his robot friend, filled with expressive faces & often funny situations. But it's far more than that, heading into bittersweet, thoughtful territory that explores the nature of friendship. Both Dog & Robot grow quite a bit by the time we reach the final pages, and they're both better for it. It's a truly sweet story, without ever becoming maudlin or cloying.

Sometimes I despair about the condition of the modern world ... then a small jewel like this comes along, reassuring me that there's more than bad news to life. A perfect book for any child ... but don't hesitate to buy a copy for yourself!

This was the first--and only--graphic novel I've ever read, let alone purchased. Long after I finished I found myself thinking about it, and also brooding over the memories that this book evoked, of failed friendships. Then I started to cry. This story ought to click with anyone who's ever had a friend, because I think it's a pretty universal thing about the human condition that all friendships change, and some don't last. The book is a bittersweet reminder of that.

I found out about Robot Dreams through a comic publisher's website. I thought the pictures looked evocative and I was not disappointed with my purchase. While the images look like they might belong in a children's book, the ensuing story is filled with emotion and superb narrative. Even without words, the story speaks so keenly of the fragility of friendship and the impact one simple experience can have on our lives. A wonderful book that will stay on my favorites shelf forever.

I bought this today thinking I was going to give it to a friend's son (a kid who likes robots as much as I do) and now, having read it, I'm not so sure I want to give it up. Maybe I should buy a second copy. In any case, one of the (bitter)sweetest stories I've seen between two covers in many years. Another first-rate book from 1st Second.

It's supposed to be a cute tale about making peace with moving on. Unfortunately it falls apart upon analysis. Spoilers are necessary to explain.

About the Dog, You don't bring a friend to life (heavy stuff) and then abandon them paralyzed on a beach in a time of need. Also you don't stop trying to save them because of a "no trespassing" sign. It bugged me the dog didn't try harder, I kept wondering why he didn't keep going back. Determination was totally overlooked, imagine if a parent left a child helpless on the beach because they couldn't lift them, not likely. It was obvious the dogs lack of ambition was necessary to facilitate the ending.

About the Robot, he's a good sport, but in the end should have let the dog know he was still alive and well. Humming the music wasn't enough, I'd hate to find out someone close I thought was dead was still alive and didn't tell me. For any of this to make sense, some sort of actual reunion/reconciliation needed to occur.

Visually it's nice, but it's hard to imagine anyone would act so passively in somewhat dire circumstances.

What am I supposed to be learning from this book? If you love somebody, set them free? Or abandon them on the beach and forget them? Or get ready, because rejection hurts a lot?

Sooner or later, someone new comes along... an imperfect reflection of the first and truest friendship... you'll be happy again, but you will always remember the first TRUE friendship with nostalgia... and you'll never give your heart like you did the first time.

If country music had robots and dogs, this would be a song.

Love the illustrations, though.

"Robot Dreams"
by Sara Varon
(First Second Books)
---------------------------------------
Note: Mild Spoilers below
---------------------------------------
A heartrending and deceptively simple graphic novel about a love affair between an anthropomorphic dog and his/her robot companion. The dog builds the robot from a kit, and they are best friends forever until the day he takes the robot to the beach and leaves it there after it rusts up. The dog feels bad about abandoning his friend and makes one half-hearted attempt to rescue it, but gives up all-too-easily and goes back home, throwing himself into finding new friends to hang out with. The robot, meanwhile, lays immobile and is covered up with sand while still optimistically dreaming that the dog will come back and love him again. Told almost entirely in pictures, with a handful of incidental words, this book has a universal appeal and is okay for younger readers (five and up?) even though the issues of romantic love and betrayal are a bit deeper than the cartoonish art might lead you to believe. Although it is a very sad narrative, the book is filled with beauty and imaginative wonder -- an engaging story that shows the strengths of the comicbook medium. Recommended! (Joe Sixpack, ReadThatAgain book reviews)

For me, a book like Robot Dreams is just begging to be read. When our new book order came in last week, there it was in the stacks, quietly making itself known. Call me a sucker for the decidedly doodle-esque cover art, but I was ready to give this one a once-over. I picked it up, I sat back, I opened it up ... wait a minute - where are the words?! I then recalled the author's previous work and it all started to make sense. But, being down with all forms of literacy, the wordless format did not sway me from my mission of digesting this volume in one big gulp. I "read" on.

I'm pretty happy I did. The story begins with Dog purchasing and assembling Robot. The two become fast friends, bonding over videos checked out from the local library (who says DVDs don't belong?).

It is their fateful summer trip to the beach, however, that sets the story in motion. Unaware of his being made of metal, Robot follows Dog into the surf - with rusty results. Robot seizes up. With no way to carry him, Dog heads home alone. Over the course of the fall, winter, and spring Dog is repeatedly rebuffed in his attempts to retrieve his friend. On the beach Robot has dreams of what will happen to him (and his friendship with Dog) in the meantime. As robot is slowly disassembled for parts by various passersby, the reader is left wondering if the two will ever be reunited.

Dog and Robot do cross paths again, but not in the way you would expect. The, shall we say "circular", ending may leave some readers unsatisfied. For me however, it was an appropriate way to wrap up this rewarding and surprisingly mature story of friendship.