Most Helpful Customer Reviews
29 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Eye Candy for All Anime Fans, December 28, 2005
Robot is not so much a manga book as it is an art book. Few of the stories have any clear-cut meaning, especially since few of them are more than five pages long. And almost all of the stories have as confusing an ending as you'll ever find in an anime or manga. The book is officially called "Super Color Comic: Robots 1: Works in Progress" so none of what is found in this book is a surprise. What is shared by all the stories, however, is that they are smart, and beautifully drawn and colored.
The stories cover all ranges of genres. A lot are haunting tales of murder, while some deal with childhood and the love. One fantasy story deals with witches who are curious about their human neighbors, while a horror story deals with necrophilia and murder. There is a Cowboy Bebop-like actioneer, and not one but two stories about angels, both with a disturbing slant. There is even a few pages donated solely to manga art, no story whatsoever. However, even though some of these stories seem very innocent, this is not a book for children. Nudity, blood, and gore can be found in every other story; there are no "bald spots" in this book (long time anime fans know what I mean).
Range Murata, who created characters for Blue Submarine #6 and Last Exile, compiled this book of supreme Japanese art, and I'm praying that it sells extremely well so that others in this Robot series are released. He was able to get the liveliest collection of artists around, including the character designer for Burst Angel. In the future, there is no telling who else could make an appearance in these books. So, for fans of manga out there, please buy this book. If not for the stories then definitely for the art. Artists or fans of fantasy art should also take a look at this book. It's only so long before this type of art gets recognized in art books like Spectrum, so get a grip on it now while you can.
Beyond that, I'd recommend it to veteran fans of anime. The names and the art styles in this book may seem familiar to some of you. For those of you who like those artsy anime wallpapers that can be found on many websites devoted solely to this, I'd also recommend you take a look. It will be a matter of time before the art in this book becomes available as wallpaper.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
There Isn't Much To Say, May 18, 2006
There really isn't much to be said about this artful collection of manga, other than that it is a masterpiece. Visually, it's one of the best art books I've ever purchased, and I'm a collector of books on art and the like. The artists that contributed their work to this collection, while not all seasoned professionals, are some of the best in the digital manga field, and it's apparent that they put a lot of love into these stories and the artwork in them.
My personal favorites were "Dragon Fly 2" a continuation of the action story presented in the first Robot; "Wasteland 2," another continuation from volume one from the creator of Lain; "Delicious Adventures," a cute story about three ants' first day out of the hole; and "Eventyr" another continuation though in this it explores a different part of the Eventyr world than in Robot 1. But still, very little in this book left me disappointed, so saying these stories are my personal favorites really isn't saying much. I liked every story in this book, only some a little more than the others.
In the end, though, this isn't a manga. Yes, it uses the manga styling and has some story in its pages, but it is, more than anything, simply an art book showcasing some of the greatest works in digital manga art around. While I'd love to recommend this book, and the first one, to everyone, I really can't because for those of you looking for great stories you'll likely be disappointed. However, if you just want to see some high-quality artwork, then Robot is the top of the field there, and I'd say pick this up as quickly as possible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Beauty and innovation, October 7, 2005
With its striking cover and impressive collection of artists, Robot is sure to draw quite a bit of attention, and for the most part it lives up to expectations.
The only reason you should be buiying this collection is for the art, and it certainly delivers on that aspect. Most of the artists have backgrounds in animation, and it shows. While I'm not a huge fan of anime art, it's undeniable that every story in this is stunningly drawn. With a wide range of styles and techniques, there's something in here for everyone. Each style lends to the story, and some of the atmospheres created (particuarly in the second story and third) are breathtaking.
As for the stories themselves, the fact that many of the artists have little background in manga shows. Most of the stories really aren't worth mentioning. Some don't even attempt to have a coherent narrative, instead focusing strictly on the atmosphere. There are several tales that really leave an impression on the reader, in particular the wonderful slice-of-life story set in the future as well as the haunting "Bitting Summer Play". Even if most of the other tales don't reach this level of exellence, none are particuarly horrible. Besides, you shouldn't be buying this collection for the writing; it's stricktly eye-candy.
So while it doesn't break any new ground in terms of narrative or storytelling, Robot fufills its promise of providing gorgeous visuals. As of October, it looks like this is the best manga artbook of 2005.
*Concerning the other reviewers complaint that the binding came loose, DMP has fixed this issue in time for the first printing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|