3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Behind the "Behind the Music", January 28, 2009
This review is from: Rock Bottom: A Novel (Paperback)
In rock and roll mythology, there are two linked stories that seem to be told over and over again: Pride, and The Fall. We admire a band's success, marvel at its excess -- and then, like motorists passing a grisly accident, we rubberneck at its self-immolation. VH1's Behind the Music series has made an industry out of telling and retelling this story -- adding, for the sake of narrative, a Part Three (call it Aftermath, or Redemption) and bending over backwards to force every band into their up-down-up, N-shaped rubric. The effect, of course, is facile, the glossy television product of elided facts and carefully edited interview snippets.
Rock Bottom, Michael Shilling's debut novel, bears a paradoxical relationship to this old rock and roll story. In recounting the very bad last day of the Blood Orphans -- a very bad band that could, once upon a time, have been very good -- Rock Bottom is at once a raucous celebration of rock mythos and magic and a searing portrayal of what it might actually be like to be caught at the center of a VH1-worthy storm. What makes this novel noteworthy is Shilling's ability to reconcile these objectives. Rock Bottom embraces the myths of rock even as it explodes them.
This feat is the product of an apparently egoless author. Like a good impresario once the band has taken the stage, Shilling makes himself invisible: the narration of the novel is given entirely over to its central characters, the four band members and their female manager. Jumping, in successive chapters, from one troubled head to the next, Shilling writes in an extremely close third-person that occasionally verges on stream-of-consciousness. The effect is remarkable: constructed completely from the actions, memories, and language of the characters themselves (none of that intrusive Behind the Music narrational presence), a complete picture of the Blood Orphans' dissolution emerges. The language may be salty, but one of the pleasures of this novel is the way in which it speaks through its characters. To deny them their F-bombs would be to deny them a certain degree of reality on the page. Shilling, to his credit, never flinches.
It would be unfair to call these characters "unlikeable" and leave it at that -- more often than not, these characters don't like themselves. Each is responsible, in his or her own way, for the failure of a band that began with such promise; the power of the novel lies in its relentless plot, which forces each bandmember and their manager to face that fact. Think of that line from Nixon: "Mistakes were made." With the passive voice, he camouflages his culpability. Scene by scene, Shilling strips the camouflage of passive denial from his characters until at last they see themselves -- and we, as readers, likewise see them -- clearly.
Because of this, though it brims with brio and black comedy, Rock Bottom is also a novel haunted by the specter of what could have been; a keenly rendered awareness of loss inflects many of its best passages. (Consider the deeply tragicomic moment, early in the novel, when Bobby the bassist stumbles upon a Blood Orphans display in a record store.) The path these characters follow is mythic, but by their humanity -- Shilling has imagined each so intricately, in all his or her particularities -- they rejuvenate it. Shilling's is an exciting new voice: muscular, ballsy, and heartfelt.
At a key moment in the novel (I won't reveal where, or in what context), a blue arc of electricity appears. Its purpose, I think, is to remind us: the Rock Gods are present here. Rock Bottom is a myth expertly repackaged. Through the humanity of its characters, it transcends its subject, finding art where VH1 finds only sensationalism. Rock Bottom takes an age-old rock and roll story and retells it in a funny, fresh, and surprisingly moving fashion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Shilling Nails the Musicians, February 24, 2009
This review is from: Rock Bottom: A Novel (Paperback)
I thoroughly couldn't stand some of the characters in this book. Therefore, I thoroughly enjoyed this novel. Shilling created living, breathing personas and was able to talk about the last day in the life of a band named Blood Orphans. More than just a story about five individuals that made up a completely dysfunctional rock n' roll family, the author showed how absolutely dreadful people can be to each other yet still delude themselves and hold on to a common bond.
Some people may mistake Shilling's take on relationships to be one whereby he believes that every person can be magically fixed by finding a special person in their lives, but I believe it can go deeper than that. What he may really be driving at is that, on some level, sometimes all we need is for someone to see the good in us and believe in it. Also included is a cautionary tale of how that belief can be completely derailed once you get to know someone. There are also times when Shilling also overreaches in trying to come up with detailed terminology (being involved in the medical field, I can tell you that some of what he put down was incorrect), but that can also be very charming and I found myself chuckling with all the rock references that were included.
This is definitely a solid first effort and an engaging story that isn't just about some of the stereotypical rock-god-complex driven musicians. I look forward to see what else the author has in store for the future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Day In The Demise, February 7, 2009
This review is from: Rock Bottom: A Novel (Paperback)
Rock Bottom is about the final day of a band's collapse. The Blood Orphans are formerly ironic former rock gods turned Ugly Americans in a washed up band. None of the characters are particularly likable in the beginning, but by the end of the novel I found myself rooting for all of them. Rock Bottom is fast paced, mostly funny, and occasionally touching. It's not the next Great American Novel, but it's a strong first showing from Michael Shilling. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No