Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
True East, April 2, 2007
This review is from: Rolling Thunder Logbook (Paperback)
I gave this four stars because I don't think Sam would want it to get five. That would make it too perfect, and once you read Jack Kerouac's On the Road, you're always wary of making things too perfect. That also seemed to be the idea of the Rolling Thunder Revue: to let things fall together even though that means they may fall apart (and by Sam's reckoning they eventually did).
Coupled with J. D. Salinger stream of consciousness writing, Sam dragged Kerouac's real time typing into the deconstructed stage with all four walls down. I only know Sam from his portrayl of Chuck Yeager in the Right Stuff from the book by Tom Wolfe-- the book full of Wolfian gimmicks but the film made the old fashioned way, his plays like True West, and the fact that his mom once toasted my fledgeling writing career-- I hope one day to make her proud.
Sam was hired to make a film of the Revue tour, and wound up making a book. While that means it has pages, photos, and a cover, within that loose definition, it falls apart as much as it can. Sam uses the "f" word, but as a word, not for effect (it is a word). There are bits of writing like this: "Fans are more dangerous than a man with a weapon because they're after something invisible."
The thing that galvanized the tour was fighting to get Rubin Carter released (which eventually happened), and Dylan penned the amazing "Hurricane", an absolutely riveting song when you hear it on the Bootleg Vols 1-3 CD set (or various other ways it exists), not only for the lyrics and music, but Dylan's delivery, at once cool and impassioned, the crazy quilt of images, skewed syntax, sprung rhythms, and well, Sam Shepardness of the whole thing.
But was it all a museum set piece? More safely enshrined rock history? Or can it happen now? Will someone rise up today for Eric Volz? Let the thunder roll on.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another perspective on RTR, December 27, 2010
This review is from: Rolling Thunder Logbook (Paperback)
For fans interested in the Rolling Thunder Revue, this logbook adds another perspective on what this tour was like. I would also recommend Larry "Ratso" Sloman's On the Road with Bob Dylan, Anne Waldman's beat poem "Shaman Hisses You Slide Back into the Night" in Kill or Cure, and the film Renaldo and Clara, as well as DVDs and CDs of the tour.
I was annoyed by Shepard's apparent lack of attention to detail with respect to Dylan song titles (e.g., "How Does It Feel?," "Everybody Must Get Stoned," "Hattie Carroll," "It Ain't Me," "My Masterpiece"...). It made me wonder about the accuracy of other information.
I did enjoy the journal-like quality and variety of writing styles (e.g., essays, lists, scripts, news clips) and diversity of focus for individual pieces (e.g., events, places, people). The variety sustained my interest and sometimes encouraged me to want to learn more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shepard Pitch-Perfect with Sense of Time and Place, October 5, 2010
I consider myself a pretty big Dylan fan. So much of the music is always playing on continual loops, rattling around inside me. And though I'm a big fan of the music, I've never been big on the books. I just don't need to know times and dates and historical record. My die-hard geek devotion to Dylan has never been statistical. It's always about song, the man's own words, and great anecdotes. But, when I stumbled on a book about my favorite Dylan period written by Shepard, I bought it right away.
And, it's dead-on. Shepard is right there. At all times. What's most impressive is how Shepard never compromises his own prose style ( it's all Shepard in tone and word choice ) and yet is somehow able to fade to the background and just lets the perfect moments rise to the top. Two particular moments blew me away. Shepard does a fantastic job of pulling you into Ginsberg reading a poem about motherhood to hotel guests, most of which are Jewish moms of another generation. I can feel them twitch and pause as Ginsberg pours his soul out over them. Shepard gives you a whole extra layer, making the great connection between Ginsberg, religion, and audience, tapping into more than most would have the skill or eye to do. The Shepard eye also does a phenomenal job of letting you just sort of sit with the Dylan mystique. I particularly like how Shepard discusses Dylan's great use of silence in conversations. It's a great, fast-paced read that harnesses the manic feel of a time and an idea. It's awesome.
Chris Bowen
Author of Our Kids: Building Relationships in the Classroom
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|