18 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
"Peter Washington: The Barbarization of Latin Poetry", May 15, 2002
This review is from: The Roman Poets: Everyman's Library (Everyman's Library Pocket Poets) (Hardcover)
Peter Washington's fine selection of Roman poets is sadly watered down and barbarized by the translations he chose from English poets and playwrights, ranging from the sixteenth to the twentieth century, who had no regard for the genre in which the Latin poets originally wrote in. The epic meter, from which all the Latin poets modeled themselves off of, is discarded and the rhyming couplet is tragically substituted. Peter Washington's reason for this is that the epic meter is only fit for longer poems. Tell that to Horace, to Claudian, or to Virgil--tell that to any of the Roman poets and they would simply look at you with overwhelming disgust. All of them wrote in iambic and daclyctic hexameter, that is, Greek heroic verse, or in basic Greek lyrical form, as may be found in the works of Catullus or Horace. The rhyming couplet, then, was a fault all the ancient Greeks and Romans avoided both in poetry and good oratory; therefore it was completely alien to them. The great John Milton realizing this said that it was "the invention of a barbarous age, to set of lame meter and wretched matter," which inaugurated this tradition in English poetry, and therefore effected all their translations of the Roman poets' works. Sadly enough, this volume was not spared from "the troublesome and modern bondage of rhyming." However, this volume does have its bright spots. The editor's selection of Roman poets shows that he made a noble attempt to popularize some of the more obscure poets of antiquity, such as minor ones like Petronius Arbiter, Tibullus, Claudian, and Ausonius. Also, what better way is there to make Roman poetry known than by placing it into the context of modern English poetry, in a small, pocket sized volume, under the label of one of the most prominent publishers to be found, Everyman's library. Furthermore, the rhyming couplet at times--and the editor's minimal selection of lyrical verse--can be pleasant and bring forth deeper meaning out of the poetry. And at last, the detailed and vibrant illustrations, relevant to the poet and theme of their poetry, make flipping through these pages and reading aimlessly an engaging effort, worthy of leisure. In this anthology the Roman poets are Lucretius, Catullus, Virgil, Horace, Tibullus, Propertius, Ovid, Seneca, Petronius Arbiter, Martial, Juvenal, Claudian, and Ausonius. This volume may come as a disappointment to those seeking to find these poets' works translated to the fullest degree in their original genre, but it still remains a good anthology, noble in scope, and charming in its simplicity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No