Most Helpful Customer Reviews
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Rome and Her Enemies, September 24, 2007
This book appears to be written by 2 groups of authors (Note: Jane Penrose is listed as editor not author). 1 group are the standard Osprey history writers. The other group appears to standard journalist(s).
The sections written by the Osprey writers are objective and informative. For example there are sections detailing the training and fighting methods of the Roman Army, Gallic Army, Celtiberian tribes and several other armies. Most of the sidebars in the book are objective and give interesting informatiuon such as explaining the Roman road sytem in Britian. Also the maps and the drawings in this book are clear, colorful and informative.
The sections of the book written by the journalist(s) are based on political correctness. For example, the writer criticizes the portrayal of Attila the Hun as a menace to society stating "his "greatest crime was to be different, in physical appearance, cultural background and attitude towards urban civilisation." However, in reference to China's belief the Huns were a menace to their civilization the journalist(s) claims that those were different Huns.
The journalist written sections also claim during Partia's existence "Rome - apart from a few fleeting successes - had been held as bay for 3 centuries." However, in the chapter concerning Persia's overrunning of Parthia and challenging Rome, the journalist(s) state "The change was significant since the Romans had generally dominated the Parthians and indeed repeated Roman successes had contributed to undermining royal prestige.." This may be 2 politically correct journalist not coordinating their political correctness.
The journalist(s) also blame Rome for causing the Punic Wars stating "the Romans saw an opportunity to advantage themselves" and that Roman expansion was "unconstrained". While there is some truth to these statements Roman expansion was not the sole cause of the wars. Carthage's goal of controlling all of the western Mediterranean (including Sicily) and limiting Roman influence to the Italian peninsula was the other major cause of the Punic Wars.
There are other examples of political correctness throughout this book.
Rome and Her Enemies could have been a very good book but political correctness ruined it.
Hopefully, in the future, Osprey will stick with its standard history writers rather than using journalists otherwise, in my opinion, it could mean the decline and fall of Osprey.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Too sloppy, November 22, 2008
This review is from: Rome and Her Enemies: An Empire Created and Destroyed by War (General Military) (Paperback)
First off, you can get some valuable introductory information from this book. It's not bad as a general reference, but the amount of mistakes in the little facts of this book make me extremely wary of recommending it to anyone not already well versed in Roman history.
Just one example: The author does not know the differance between a military Tribune and the office of Tribune of the Plebs. It is stated in the book that the Military Tribune over time became the other office of Tribune. This is blatantly incorrect. The office of Tribune was created expressly to guard the interests of the Plebians in the government, and had no connection at all to it's military counterpart. There are too many such misunderstandings of what should be common knowledge of anyone who writes a history of Rome. It's either poorly researched or poorly edited.
Much of the information is questionable and in cases colored by modern aapoligetic concerns as an earlier reviewer has pointed out. It's ok as a quick read, but you can do much better somewhere else.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Combination of many titles, March 17, 2011
This review is from: Rome and Her Enemies: An Empire Created and Destroyed by War (General Military) (Paperback)
It appears to be that this book is a combination of host of Osprey military history books from their Men at Arms series, Campaign series and host of other series. The book is published by Osprey and all the illustrations came from various different books previously published as well as the written accounts are in this book. I am not sure what role the editor played outside of mixing written sources from various books and putting it into one book format. I don't think she wrote anything in this book that other reviewers may have believed.
The book only weakness lies in the fact that many of the Osprey books it came from may be outdated by new information that came out. Some of the titles seem to go back 20 years. If you owned many of the Osprey's books dealing with Rome and her enemies in various series out there, this book may not be worth your effort since most of the stuff written here are on your shelves already. I am not sure if Tom Holland's introduction is worth $19.95 asking price (paperback). There are other books like this dealing with the Greeks and Medieval period. Both of those books are combined from older shorter Osprey books and put into a single source book like this book.
So if you are just getting into the Osprey military books, then edition like this will save you time and money. Its a good introduction to Roman military history but since the source authors are so many, you will encountered many various different presentations as you read the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
