20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing insights into the mind of a writer, November 9, 2007
This review is from: Ron Carlson Writes a Story (Paperback)
My experience in finding this book, is just like the other reviewer, I was buying some books, and I was recommended this title.
With a name such as "Ron Carlson writes a story", I really had no idea what to expect. Who is Ron Carlson? I have never heard of this person in my life, is the idea of him being able to write a story worthy of a book, is it a man's triumph over the written word? No, it is a behind the scenes look at the making of a story.
Fortunately, the price was just ten dollars, a very low amount for something that could be of use. I love short stories, and I love writing, my reason for buying this book, was the possible glimpse inside the mind of a writer.
I am writing this review, because this is a great book, and the page here gives very little to go on. The author is a very gifted writer; his thoughts come through clearly, and cite countless ideas, and suggestions that will change the way you work.
I knew buying this, that it was more of a "making of a story" book, not a "how to write" book, hopefully potential buyers note this as well. Ron goes sentence by sentence (or paragraph) and explains what he is thinking while he wrote it. He analyzes only the finished story, not the first draft, we don't get to see him struggle on what elements he decides to keep and why, just how the story came to be, and why he does the things he does.
He also gives off ideas, how he approaches a tough spot, when the author gets stumped, what he likes to do, and gives off examples. I learned a lot from this book, it wasn't mind bending, it didn't change my world, but it did help, and it can help you too. The author writes with conviction, he prose leaps off the page, his characters are amazing, most every character he introduces in the story, I immediately wanted to know more about them.
Ron writes very organically, his story is told with no outline, it just flows, and through reading this book, you can get an idea of how powerful that is, and how powerful that can be. He creates a world I want to visit, and creates characters I want to meet, and learn more about.
If I have to give a downside to this book, it would be the lack of attention dedicated to story. Even the short story is not really a story; it's more of a vignette, a scene, a fond memory of things past. Be that as it may, I cannot fault this book on not addressing this topic; there are countless other books that focus on nothing but story. Though, it would have been nice.
In the end, if you are only going to pick up one book on writing, this is not that book. But if you have a passion for writing, you can do no wrong in buying this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Forget the coffee and keep writing, February 9, 2010
This review is from: Ron Carlson Writes a Story (Paperback)
Ron Carlson takes you through the process of writing a short story as he wrote it, with practical steps on things like naming your characters, filling in details when you're stuck, and to keep writing when that second cup of coffee is calling. In fact, that's when some of the best writing occurs: when you stay at your desk writing instead of grabbing that second cup of coffee when things get tough. The book is short but packed with practical advice on how to stay with the process to complete a short story.
It includes his short story "The Governor's Ball." As he says in the book, "The Governor's Ball" was written in a single day and it was a story he remembers how he wrote, so he's able to give a kind of "play-by-play" account of the writing process.
Some of the advice will be familiar to those who've read books of this kind, such as how to write dialogue, using active verbs, and eliminating unnecessary adjectives. But the account of how a writer writes a specific story is unique in my experience and the story itself is a good one to learn from. It's short but a model of the subtleties that make short stories fun to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great with a cup of Joe, December 6, 2008
This review is from: Ron Carlson Writes a Story (Paperback)
This book is directed at aspiring fiction writers. Since I don't write fiction, maybe I should be reading one of Carlson's novels instead. But I press on anyway. I am compelled by the sample story that Ron delivers in crisp, salty little chunks, like so many goldfish crackers scattered on the path through the dark woods of procrastination. But I am also moved by Ron's writing lessons: tips and truisms, warnings and reminders, all of it frank and funny and right, because each one is tied to the wagging tale of the story he's telling.
Ron's emphasis is on process, not craft, and hence on intuition and accident more than control. Writing is discovery; you need to listen to your characters, not tell them what to do. Writing dialogue, Ron tells us, is "like playing tennis against a real partner. It's not like playing tennis against a wall." Craft alone would be mastering the wall; but process means creating characters who feint, parry, and giggle uncontrollably, keeping the writer on her toes.
A lot of the book isn't about fiction writing at all. It's about time management. In a sharp little chapter called "Coffee," Carlson writes, "No one among us suffers the radical appreciation for coffee that I do. It calls to me, but I have learned not to listen." Coffee takes you out of your seat; it breaks concentration; it persuades you that "you might be smarter in the next room." And every coffee machine has a vacuum cleaner as its neighbor. Or an email account. Or a Face Book page.
This is a quick, fun, and enlightening read, a great book for anyone who likes to write, or to read about writing. I recommend it with a cup of Joe.
[...]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
