2.0 out of 5 stars
the weakest book in the rook series., June 8, 2002
This review is from: Rook (Bk. 1) (Hardcover)
My intro to GRAHAM MASTERTON and the ROOK series was SNOWMAN,
a book I enjoyed quite a bit and it made me want to read the other books in the ROOK series. So far, I've read SWIMMER, ROOK
and THE TERROR and ROOK is easily my
least favorite so far. I enjoyed the book, but it really does
have some major flaws. First of all, this SMOKE spirit is kind
of stupid..and annoying. He doesn't want JIM ROOK to tell any-
body about him, yet he shows up in his classroom and taunts him
there, right in front of the students. I mean, these kids may not
be too bright, but anybody would figure out that ROOK wasn't
merely talking to himself! I think the reason MASTERTON wrote it
this way was so ROOK's students could get involved more in the
story! I also think the identity of the
killer is revealed too soon in the book; indeed' it's actually
revealed on the front flap of the book and this takes away from
any suspense! JIM ROOK seems to accept very quickly that he can
see ghosts and spirits! There are other minor flaws, also. I did
enjoy the book and there are some gruesome things that go on
during the story, but this series got much better, especially
with THE TERROR, which I just got through reading and is now
my favorite book of the series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No