Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Imaginative and Entertaining Storytelling, January 20, 2002
This review is from: The Ropemaker (Hardcover)
This is a startlingly good example of the kind of gems that can get hidden in the YA section of bookstores and libraries. The author proves himself very adept at word use, world-building and storytelling in an amazingly rich story. The young female protagonist of this story lives in a peaceful valley that has remained sheilded for generations from the depredations of those who live on either side of the valley. But when the magical defenses begin to fail, it is up to Tilja, her grandmother and a young man and his grandfather (along with one ornery horse) to venture beyond the valley and seek the one person who might help them. The bare bones plot is not new, but this author is a master--he handles the adventure of these four and brings the tale full circle with care and precision. The images are powerful and for anyone who recognizes the power of stories, the author's underlying message will ring true. Being a YA book there is some limit to the adult reader who might desire an adult protagonist, or more mature themes explored that are not dealt with in this story. Beyond that, I highly reccomend this book to any fantasy reader as an example of high caliber story telling. Enjoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Encore! (Sequel!), March 17, 2005
This review is from: The Ropemaker (Hardcover)
The Ropemaker will keep you involved and leave you wanting a sequel (which doesn't exist yet, unfortunately). Be prepared for the fact that there is a bit of a disconnect between the title and the actual main character. You won't meet the title character until well into the book (p. 142), and he turns out to be, although important to the outcome, tangential in terms of character development. The story line otherwise revolves around the main character, a teenage girl named Tilja, who is initially despondent about the fact that in a world of magic, where even her own little sister has the gift (horrors!), she is decidedly non-magical. Magic things lose their magic in her touch. But, wait, if there's bad magic out there, that's a good thing, right?! And there is the story. Tilja must risk everything in an attempt to protect her beloved home valley from military attack as well as from the forces of evil. The valley has been protected for 20 generations by a spell cast by a now-dead enchantress, and so Tilja and her companions must find a new magician to renew the spell. This quest in itself is an exciting story and well-written, with a lot of very creative and detailed development of this strange world and society. (For example, the emperor exercises the ultimate taxing authority by forcing people to pay in advance for permission to die of old age!) As Tilja and her companions pursue their life-or-death quest to save their homeland, we get a lot of build-up about how Tilja's "power" may elevate her to a position of prominence, but her potential is never reached or explored in this book. Likewise, the "good" magic of the Ropemaker is unique, with hints of power to come, which are not developed. I hope the cryptic Epilogue isn't a sign that no sequel is planned. This book is, nevertheless, a very good and engrossing read. My 12-year-old daughter loved it, too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Ropemaker, March 3, 2002
A Kid's Review
This review is from: The Ropemaker (Hardcover)
The Valley is the only passage between the horsemen of the plain and the Empire, which means that it is constantly under attack. The residents of the Valley can¡¦t withstand all these killing and raiding; therefore, they send some of their people on a long, difficult journey to find a magician powerful enough to get them some peace. Two people, Reyel Ortahlson and Dirna Urlasdaughter, found a powerful magician, Faheel, and he promised the people of the Valley peace for twenty generations. After twenty generations the magic wore off and the Valley fell again in turmoil. Tilja, Tahl, Meena, and Alnor decided that the must find the magician again to restore peace. With extraordinary luck and many breath-taking adventures, they found Faheel on an island. However, Faheel is too weak to do what they asked for, he is already on his deathbed. Before he passed away, Faheel gave them a magical ring and told them to give it to another powerful magician, the Ropemaker, who can restore peace in the Valley with the help of the ring. I had a great time reading this book. Every book that has to do with magic has to have an explanation of how magic works. The explanation in this book is very reasonable and makes perfect sense. This makes the book a lot easier to understand and enjoy. The author tells of how magic is flowing everywhere, and only gifted people can make use of this magic. When a person is more gifted than others, he/she in turn can take control of larger amounts of magic at a time. Nevertheless, when a person is overwhelmed by the magic of another, he/she will lose their gift to use magic and can very possibly die at the same time. My favorite part of this book is when Tilja realized the power she possesses. Before, she had thought that there were only two kinds of magicians: ones that remake the magic in the air before they use it and ones that simply use the magic in the air without remaking it. When magic is remade it becomes more powerful. On her journey to find Faheel, Tilja discovered that whatever remade magic makes contact with her is reversed into natural magic. With this power Tilja is able to protect herself from all remade magical attacks. Not only that, she can also suck away all the magic in any magician without getting hurt. Tilja decided that she must be the third kind of magician.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|