Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Intelligently Written, but Ultimately Disappointing, January 25, 2010
I put this book on my Christmas list, because I saw it in the bookstore and was intrigued by the beautiful cover (yes, I admit I sometimes judge books by their cover) and the synopsis on the back. It sounded right up my alley - a little psychological suspense, historical interest, a mystery, a little romance, and to top it off, something a little mystical or mythical about it.
It started out well, and was an intelligent and intriguing read. But halfway through I started to lose interest. The plot began to be bogged down with tons of arcane information, there was sometimes marginal reference to some of the puzzles (which I only realized were reproduced in the back of the softcover version when I went online to see if I could find them) and the suspenseful element completely broke down. I only read the whole thing because my young daughter had bought it for me with her allowance -- had it been a library book, I would have given up, because it began to be more work than seemed worthwhile.
I am normally very good at suspending disbelief but I came away not understanding how the puzzle makers in the 16th century were able to create puzzles about events in the 20th century, how numerology and the number 34 really fit into the puzzles and the plot, why Lucy herself and her childhood and birth date were apparently crucial to the resolution of a story that did not directly involve her family (except for the somewhat tangential heart transplant) etc. (I have university degrees, am well read, and reasonably intelligent, and I love books that are smartly written and sophisticated, yet I came away from this book feeling really dumb -- or else it was geared only toward gifted intellectuals and lovers of the arcane and esoteric). Many facets of the plot seemed to go nowhere in the end.
I was disappointed because I did catch glimpses now and then of how the book could have been a really good one. There are a lot of so-called bestsellers out there by authors who don't know how to construct a proper sentence and who write dumb fiction. I am rooting for Ms. Hardie and hoping that she learns from her mistakes and manages to write a much more pared down and plot-driven book with better-developed characters who manage to hold the reader's interest and keep him/her awake at night to finish another chapter.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Intellectually Stimulating - A Must Read!, May 30, 2008
From the moment I picked up this book, I just knew it was going to be an amazing read. It truly is a love story of great poetic brilliance. Enchanting from the outset, I always had a strong suspicion that Lucy, with her heart transplant, would be the key to a world of enticing mysteries.
Finding it hard to put down, I raced through the pages of the Rose Labyrinth absolutely enticed by this amazing story of love and romance. Indeed, I do admit that some parts were quite dense, but the force of this book towards a deeper revelation kept me enticed throughout.
This book itself is presented ever so beautifully: a hard back cover with puzzle pieces to unravel, the Rose Labyrinth is presented just as well as it is written. However, this book may not be for all - especially those who have aversions about questioning our beliefs and re-incarnations - but it is definitely intriguing.
The author presents such a wide range of knowledge about Shakespeare and indeed the Elizabethan era that sometimes I felt like I was on a history tour. Titania is able to incorporate these all important facts into a modern London setting that everyone can recognize with ease.
This book will challenge you, but it will provide you with a delightful sense of pleasure. A must read for anyone looking to stimulate their minds while getting lost in a truly romantic love story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Dan Brown may be a trash novel writer, but at least he can entertain me for the length of a plane flight., March 26, 2010
*spoiler alert, btw*
I wanted so badly to like this book, I really did. I read it all the way through, got to the end, and was happy it was over.
The only likable character in the entire book is killed off in the third chapter - always a good sign. The main female is supposed to be a strong willed woman who's been given a second chance at life, but instead is a whiny, crying brat who puts herself into danger for the purposes of tension. The main male is supposed to be a stoic man with a loving interior, but instead comes off as creepy protective and possessive. The main 'villain' is propped up as some horribly EVIL man, despicable, insane, and deadly. He kidnaps the main female, offers her tea and biscuits, and lets her go in the morning - he even forgets to make any clear demands. The four main protagonists are supposed to be laymen, yet they all suddenly become experts in history, and all talk with the same unrealistic, non relevant tone about information that you'll never retain, and don't need to since it has nothing to do with the plot.
This book tries so hard to have The Da Vinci Code's gripping writing, and fails in every way. The characters are given riddles that you never see. They solve them, but you're rarely told why. They use the solutions in their decisions, but you're barely ever told why it's significant. You're taken to many historical settings, which are in reality beautiful and mysterious, though they're nothing but skimmed over plot devices barely worth a description beyond 'It a church and it has windows'.
'Flashbacks' in history are supposed to be mystical and meaningful, but really come across as smarmy, enigmatic, and pointless.
Ending tried so hard to be a Disney fairytale and all it ended up being was me thinking 'Uh... you guys... haven't... actually solved the plot.... you know that, right?'
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|