From Publishers Weekly
UFO researcher Pflock has written the definitive book on facts and fantasies surrounding the now-familiar series of 1947 events at Roswell, N.Mex., interpreted by many as an air force coverup involving extraterrestrial bodies at a UFO crash site. Over the years, in the fashion of urban legends, a modern mythology has developed around Roswell, providing fuel for TV movies, feature films, TV series and a full shelf of books, along with UFO museums and annual celebrations that bring tourists to the town. A New Mexico resident and former believer, Pflock offers exhaustive research, spanning eight years, a fascinating probe that has transformed him into a skeptic. With photos, drawings and interviews, Pflock focuses on secret high-altitude balloon research conducted for the U.S. Army Air Force by New York University in 1947. These balloon trains, taller than the Washington Monument, were launched from Alamogordo Air Force Base, 90 miles southwest of Roswell. Assembling formerly classified documents, along with 1947 United Press wire transmissions, weather data and 28 witness affidavits, Pflock attempts to refute past "witness" tales, expose claims made by other books on this subject and prove the U.S. government has no physical evidence. He has succeeded at this in a major fashion, creating an unusual and authoritative study. As Pournelle notes: "This is a courageous and important book." Many who come to it will be persuaded that it cracks the mystery, wipes the slate clean and exposes the hullabaloo about Roswell as nothing more than a fabulous fairy tale, peaking in a delightful paragraph that tracks the famed purple-pink "alien hieroglyphics" to a novelty company on New York City's Canal Street. (June 30)Forecast: Reviews, controversy and word-of-mouth will prompt both believers and nonbelievers to seek out this title.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
Just when it seems the market cannot bear another book on crashed UFOs at Rockwell, New Mexico, another book finds its way to publication, but this one will definitely need a place on the shelf. Pflock, a former Defense Department official and CIA intelligence officer, presents a well-argued, well-written, well-documented, and well-illustrated case against
the 1947 crash being that of an alien spacecraft. His approach is more tempered than those of other skeptics, including Kal Korff (The Roswell UFO Crash
, 1997) and Philip J. Klass (The Real Roswell Crashed-Saucer Coverup
, 1997). Step by step, he identifies the weak points in supporters' arguments, picks apart ambiguous evidence, reexamines critical testimony, and finds little more than wishful thinking for an alien scenario. The best case yet to explain the crash, according to Pflock? A Project Mogul balloon gone astray. Is this the last word on Roswell? Probably not, since Pflock shades a few questionable points in his favor, but an equally reasoned and comprehensive argument will have to be presented to counter Pflock effectively. George EberhartCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved