Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another Perspective on American Independence, December 3, 2007
This review is from: Rough Crossings: The Slaves, the British, and the American Revolution (Paperback)
Schama is always an interesting writer, but he has seldom been as easy to read as in Rough Crossings. Perhaps the subject itself is so unambiguous that he finds his way to simplicity. That subject is the fate of African and African-American refugees from the Thirteen Colonies, the bold proclaimers of Liberty, during and after the Revolutionary War. Unmentioned in most American textbooks of history, thousands of slaves and some free blacks took refuge with the British army and navy during the war. After the war, many of them were transported to other British lands, especially to Nova Scotia. Schama details their hopes and their misery quite eloquently. Eventually, the tale focuses on the efforts of English abolitionists to establish a "homeland" for liberated American and British slaves in Sierra Leone. The English abolitionists, especially John Clarkson, are the central personages of the book, but the former slaves themselves are the most compelling figures.
For a sometime-American reader like myself, the most enlightening portion of this book comes first, i.e. the chapters that describe the role of the defense of slavery in the southern colonies against perceived threats of abolition and strategic offers of freedom from Britain. The motives of our Founding Fathers, in other words, were not always as idealistic as we were taught. An understanding of the American Revolution can't always be limited to Boston and taxes. The story of Virginian expansionism, the problems of colonial indebtedness, and colonial racism towards both slaves and Native Americans must also be told, and Schama does a good part of that job. Particularly revealing are Schama's pages devoted to George Washington, whose slaves were as willing to run away to the British as most others. Inevitably, certain British generals who have been execrated in American history books emerge as more sympathetic and honorable than "we" expect. I don't want to "spoil" the narrative with too many revelations; taken as a "novel of facts", Rough Crossings is an exciting book to read, with plenty of picturesque scenes, humorous encounters, pathos and rage.
The book won and deserved to win the National Book Critics Circle Award.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Is British Air Really Too Pure ?, September 25, 2007
This review is from: Rough Crossings: The Slaves, the British, and the American Revolution (Paperback)
This well written and informative book provides yet another useful reminder that Americans like me shouldn't be too smug about being shining beacons of freedom throughout the world. It goes into interesting detail about the debates in the Continental Congress on slavery prior to the Revolution, the compromises made, and who made them. The British offered freedom to slaves who came over to their side during the Revolutionary War, and they actually tried to keep these promises, but not always to the satisfaction of the freed slaves. However, a movement to abolish the slave trade was gathering momentum in Britain, one result of which was the establishment of the state of Sierra Leone in West Africa as a home for many of these formerly enslaved people and their families. It is a very interesting story, and the author tells it in a lively style.
However, I can't help wondering if the author hasn't applied a little melodrama to add sparkle to his story; for example, individuals and groups of individuals tend to be characterized as all good or all bad. The author also uses rather nasty sarcasm in describing people and events. I can see his point in using it to describe George Washington's hypocrisy, but he also uses it when talking about Granville Sharp, who may have been quite an eccentric but nonetheless was a leading figure in abolishing the slave trade. It seemed mean-spirited. Finally, I wish I had counted the number of times the author referred to British air as being "too pure for slaves to breathe." Maybe it was, but that never stopped the British from fouling other countries' air: India, Australia, South Africa, etc., etc., etc.
On the whole, I recommend this book as a readable history of an important but not widely discussed event in the establishment of the United States.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting topic presented with a very uneven writing style, May 15, 2009
This review is from: Rough Crossings: The Slaves, the British, and the American Revolution (Paperback)
An interesting book about a part of U.S. and British history a lot of us didn't hear about in school.
Schama's book is primarily a history of African Americans who were loyalists during the American Revolution although it delves deeply into abolitionist history, especially in Britain.
The British made promises to the blacks, but as is so often the case in history when government makes a promise, it was not always kept. And when a promise was kept, it was often with an eye toward the word of law rather than the spirit.
Until reading the book, I had no idea that the British promised freedom to blacks who fought for them during the war, nor did I know that those freed blacks were to be transported and given land in Nova Scotia.
The book provides a fascinating history of the founding of the colony at Sierra Leone and the progression of Britain from a slavery-condoning nation to a free one.
The big problem with the book is the writing. Schama is not the liveliest writer in the world and his style is very uneven. It whips from quick-paced to a dull slog from page to page. It's just not that enjoyable a read. If the topics and history itself had not been so interesting, there is no way I would have stuck with the book.
Read it for the story it tells. Just know that it is not going to be the best writing you have read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
