-Church History March 2002
"[A] useful research tool and outstanding teaching resource...an excellent contribution, highly recommended for libraries and courses in US religion.."
-"Religious Studies Review, January 2002
"Carroll offers another excellent volume in the 'Routledge Atlases of American History' series. His small but extremely important publication provides a succinct, current atlas with the most up-to-date commentary.... Highly recommended for every library."
"This interesting approach to exploring religion's impact on U.S. history will be useful in the religion and history collections of academic libraries."
-"American Reference Books Annual, 2000
"An excellent reference book on America's rich religious history."
-"Christian Science Monitor, 2/21/01