5.0 out of 5 stars
It could happen to you, September 25, 2010
This review is from: Rue the Day (Paperback)
One could rather hastily summarize "Rue The Day" with "There are mistakes for which you pay all your life." The mistake is a betrayal, not a voluntary one, but one made under stressful circumstances, fear of ghosts from the past and mental torture, but made "willingly", as confessions were willingly made Moscow trials.
The book is the story of the betrayer's guilt and remorse, but not as much lived out by him, as by the three women of his life, through whom we approach Jacob (who is not the most present character in the novel).
The betrayal could have been forgiven: no one is injured or killed; life has been momentarily shaken for Francesca, the betrayed women, but as the McCarthyism receded, things could have been patched up, behaviors explained and understood, even if not forgiven.
But, no. That betrayal is one of an utmost symbolic charge. It convokes the same behavior under the Nazi regime in Germany and the Fascist regime in Italy.
Freedman makes Jacob a German Jew, persecuted, detained and interrogated during Crystal Night, who manages to escape to the United State with his family before it is too late. Jacob, once in the US, joins the US army and fights in Germany, Tunisia and Italy.
People were and still are routinely denounced in totalitarian regimes by friends, family members, neighbors, colleagues out of fear of to gain favors.
Jacob's having been a victim in Nazi Germany could have been an extenuating circumstance. Again, no. Freedman develops a Greek tragedy; there is no escape or redemption. Even heroes have descent slowly the stairway down to their private hell, and hope that those who love them will still love them once they know what they did. That is the only consolation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No