Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
fine children's book teaching the importance of thinking to solve problems--BRAVO, JULIE SCANDORA !!!, April 18, 2008
This review is from: Rules Are Rules (Hardcover)
Julie Scandora's first children's book, Rules Are Rules, tells the touching story of a young girl's path to resolving a problem she must face. For Maya, the young child in this story, the rules must be kept with precision. Of course, Maya is angry and upset about this because there's one rule in particular that she just can't stand. The story begins when Maya is angry and upset in her hiding place in the forest; she's so unpleasant that even the forest animals avoid her. Eventually the peaceful qualities of the forest sooth Maya; and when her mood lightens the forest animals come back and enjoy their lives. However, Maya is still grappling with a problem. Maya meets her old friend, Mrs. Morales, as Maya is walking in the forest. Maya knows that this elderly woman is both kind and wise; so Maya decides to tell Mrs. Morales what is troubling her. It seems there is a rule that Maya must always kiss and hug her Auth Trudy when Trudy comes to visit. Maya hates that because she doesn't like smelling like Aunt Trudy's perfume and besides Aunt Trudy holds her too tight. Mrs. Morales gives Maya space and nonjudgmental acceptance as she listens gently to Maya's dilemma. Maya begins to think that there may be a way out of this dilemma. That night Maya gets up the courage to tell her parents she doesn't like to be touched by Aunt Trudy; and after some discussion Maya and her parents work out an arrangement. Instead of having to hug and kiss Aunt Trudy; Maya will make her a card and merely give it to Aunt Trudy. That way Maya's Aunt Trudy feels good vibes from her niece at the same time that Maya is spared the uncomfortable feelings of being around Aunt Trudy. This book does a marvelous job of encouraging children to find creative solutions to problems that hurt no one at all. This is a powerful lesson for children of many ages. This book is a great experience if you read it along with your children, too; they may have questions about their own problems and dilemmas that can be discussed as you both go through this book. In addition, the watercolor illustrations are outstanding; they make for a beautiful book especially with those very attractive front and back covers. Julie Scandora's first children's book is a must-have for children learning about coping skills. This book shows children how to deal with their own feelings and those of others as they find new or creative solutions to their problems. I highly recommend this children's book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Lesson Learned!, April 24, 2008
This review is from: Rules Are Rules (Hardcover)
I have to say, as I read this story I definitely could relate to Maya, as I'm sure many children and adults will too. This little girl has a problem, one she desperately needs help with. She is told to follow a rule, but what happens when a rule makes you feel uncomfortable? Should you still have to follow it? Maya sits quietly in her forest and ponders what to do. She finds wisdom and is able to talk freely with a kindly woman friend and Maya musters up the courage to talk with her mom about this rule, and give her idea of a possible solution. "Rules Are Rules" is a very good book. The author blends the calmness that nature can bring into the child's life, the understanding that it is a good idea to talk with someone, and the realization they can come up with a possible solution. The watercolor illustrations add depth to the read and definitely help bring the story to life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Children's Book that Respects Children!, May 14, 2008
This review is from: Rules Are Rules (Hardcover)
"Rules are Rules" is an absolutely delightful children's picture book. The water-color illustrations by the author are beautiful and detailed and exactly fit Julie Scandora's tale of young Maya, who wants to respect her parent's wishes, but doesn't want to kiss her Aunt Trudy, who squeezes Maya "like a tube of toothpaste being squeezed empty" and "wears this smelly perfume". The story begins with Maya communing with nature, listening to the noise of the forest creatures and understanding their communication. Scandora broadens that metaphor as Maya meets her older friend Mrs. Morales, who guides Maya through her dilemma so wisely that Maya comes to a better understanding and her own logical solution to the dilemma of kissing Aunt Trudy. We see that Maya finds her own answer to her problem, and along the way gains new respect from her parents. Rules are Rules is a pleasure from beginning to end. Highly recommended for people like Maya, who are young, but deserving of respect.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|