7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly Written., May 14, 2006
The Ruling CLass by Francine Pascal appears to be poorly written and poorly thought out. I read this book in a few hours, and was disappointed in it overall.
Working backwards, the ending is a letdown. Being the climax of the book, it is not led up to very well, and is very short. There does not seem to be much of a conclusion on the new status of all the students, and it seems as if Francine was in a rush to finish the book.
As for the characters, they are all a little odd. For one, it is increasingly annoying to read 'like', used by all the characters. It is one thing to be a teen and say it in speech, and a complete other thing to write it in literature. Even when pertraying a teen. The book is written in the perspective to two major characters, Myrna Fry and Twyyla Gay, both of whom are unrealistic.
This book seems to be a bad Harry Potter jock. In the sense that there are a lot of background questions that are not answered. Yet, unlike Harry Potter, there are not 6 more books coming out, and they will not be answered. Why is J.S. so mean? How are the R.C.s choosen? Does the school learn anything? Is there a reason Ryder and J.S. are still messing around with each other yet Ryder is asking Twyla out? Also, I'd like to know what went on with the people chasing Twyla after the mall incident. Sure, it made the night awful.. but were they really nessicary in the book? Especially since nothing else happens with them?
Lastly, I think the book is aimed for an older reading crowd, yet it seems like a book for the younder crowd.
I would recommend this book to anyone looking for a quick read on a weekend afternoon, but not looking for anything too indepth thinking-wise.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Thoughtless, March 4, 2006
I'm from the East Coast, and know nothing about life in Highland Park, Texas. But after reading the first few pages of this book, I thought, "This is an avalanche of stereotypes. This is obviously an East or West Coast person's idea of what 'those backward Texans' are like." I checked the book jacket, and sure enough the author was from the East Coast. I was not at all surprised to find user reviews from real Texans who objected to the book. The character of Myrna is so stupid that she is totally unbelievable. We are supposed to be reading Myrna's inner thoughts, but what we get is actually the excuses that she might tell someone else to explain her behavior. It doesn't really get to the heart of what a "follower" type feels on the inside.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Yeah...., January 6, 2007
I found the plot laughable. The characters over the top and over-exaggerated. I know, I know I may be bias being from Dallas and HP, but I truly went into to this book trying to keep an open-mind. It was a waste of my time to read it and to me it seemed that the author was trying a little too hard to make this a novelization of Mean Girls. Anyway this book was quite disappointing and very offensive. These girls act more like junior high students then high school students. Yes HP has a valid reputation of being racist and wealthy. But this book took it to another level and completely over the top.
Poorly done Ms. Pascal.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No