70 of 79 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful Stories, November 17, 2004
This review is from: Runaway (Hardcover)
If you have not read Alice Munro, how I envy you. You have so much pleasure ahead of you. She writes for all of us about wonder- the wonder of everyday life; the small things; the touching things; the things that make you say, yes, this is the human heart; all of these are her fictional world, much as they are our pasts, and our presents. This is a strong collection and an excellent place to get to know what she is about. After this, explore her backlist. My personal favorite besides this is an early collection called,The Moons of Jupiter, which is still in print in a nice paperbak format. I hope you enjoy discovering her as much as I have.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
56 of 63 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Through the prism of time. . ., November 15, 2004
This review is from: Runaway (Hardcover)
Alice Munro's newest collection of short stories is about time, how small events change lives, and how different those events look as time passes. Several of the stories span the lifetimes of the characters, focusing on one event that changes things forever.
Take "Chance," "Soon" and "Silence," a trio of stories about Juliet, a young woman whose choices about who to speak to on a train change her life forever. Munro masterfully picks three incidents, the train ride, a visit home, and a search for a daughter, and through them tells the story of Juliet's life. I found it sad to see how the great passion of the first story ends in an accident by the third. Or "Tricks," perhaps the most painful story in the collection. The story opens with Robin saying the most banal thing one could imagine, "I'll die if that dress isn't ready." Then we learn why, and when Munro repeats the line again we see it's fraught with meaning. We learn of a chance meeting that offers a promise that's snatched away a year later; only at the end of her life does Robin learn what really happened.
Suicides, lost souls and disappointments thread through these stories. Munro's world is a lost and lonely place, and be forewarned--none of these stories promises a happy ending. But they're beautifully written and struck a chord--don't we all recall brief, seemingly trivial moments years later and wonder what if?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Munro's "Coincidental" Epiphanies, December 12, 2004
This review is from: Runaway (Hardcover)
Alice Munro may well be the best short story writer working today, but what's strange is that at first it's a little hard to see why she's so good. She doesn't use any fancy-pants language, she doesn't worry about making her characters warm and sympathetic, and she doesn't try to reach at the typical sorts of short story epiphanies, the straining towards lyrical proclaiming and the conclusive moment of a personal vision's consolidation.
What she offers instead is a conversational tone that is quirky and fractured enough to rise above the blandness of a typical conversational style. For example, this is how she renders a crucial scene in one story where the protagonist has entered the house of a man she has a crush on. Note the parenthesis, the incongruous academic metaphor, and the sentence fragments: "Juliet hears the door of the truck close, she hears him speaking to the dog, and dread comes over her. She wants to hide somewhere (she says later, I could have crawled under the table, but of course she does not think of doing anything so ridiculous). It's like the moment at school before the winner of the prize is announced. Only worse, because she has no reasonable hope. And because there will never be another chance so momentous in her life."
Furthermore, her stories don't so much ask us to root for the characters so much as to examine them, to consider their mistakes and misperceptions. For example, Munro's stories often break out into reflective moments like this one: "While she was running away from him - now - Clarke still kept his place in her life. But when she was finished running away, when she just went on, what would she put in his place? What else - who else - could ever be so vivid a challenge?" Personally, I was rooting for her only insofar as she really did want to leave her husband, who's rather grouchy and mean and worth ditching. But Munro doesn't care about making her into an idealized romantic hero; she instead wants to depict something far more difficult to understand, which is why the character would stay with her husband.
Also, rather than being a steady climb towards a typical epiphany, her stories derive their structure from what might be called "the coincidental epiphany." What I mean by that term is that, over and over in her stories, there are moments of crucial importance that also happen to be utterly coincidental. These moments come as utter surprises and derive their incredible power from the way they occupy the climaxes of a story, the places where what's supposed to be the focus is the protagonist's action and the question of whether it succeeds or fails. Munro's "coincidental epiphanies" instead recontextualize the concerns that led to the protagonist's actions in the first place.
By way of illustration, I'll do a long quotation. The "trick" this passage refers to had accidentally ruined a love affair the protagonist was in; she is just now realizing that what seemed to be have been fate was really just the result of this random, accidental "trick":
"It was all spoiled in one day, in a couple of minutes, not by fits and starts, struggles, hopes and losses, in the long-drawn-out way that such things are more often spoiled. And if it's true that things are usually spoiled, isn't the quick way the easier way to bear?
But you don't really take that view, not for yourself. Robin doesn't. Even now she can yearn for her chance. She is not going to spare a moment's gratitude for the trick that has been played. But she'll come round to being grateful for the discovery of it. That, at least - the discovery which leaves everything whole, right up to the moment of frivolous intervention. Leaves you outraged, but warmed from a distance, clear of shame."
Throughout her stories, it's as if Munro is saying, "the crucial moments in life are often the coincidences, not the moments of decision and action that we think of as the real core of our lives. Stories should thus focus on these moments in order to understand and cope with them." In other words, Munro is a perfect guide to the farcical aspects of human life, the overlooked details and unexpected twists that change everything.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No