Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Utter Crap, August 23, 2005
This review is from: SMC SMCWMR-AG EZ-Stream Universal Wireless Multimedia Receiver (Personal Computers)
Ok, so I know it sounds harsh... but please read first and then you can decide for yourself.
I bought the unit (new) about a year ago.... searched the web, researched the company ("supposedly" good routers), and concluded based on the hardware options that it seemed like the best choice.
Being a bit of a gearhead, I figured that I could work out any bugs (I assume that a new product that has software will have a few bugs...see Microsoft =). I get home, try to install it....no dice. Looked at SMC's web site...downloaded the updates...and got Internet Radio. No mp3s, no Video, and parts of small jpg's.
Phoned SMC's "tech support" ... I use quotes on purpose.... 1-800-India ... had to phone back 3 times to get someone who spoke English... to whick they followed their canned troubleshooting script. I was a little offended by the "just buy another computer and install it there" comment. (My PC was 2 mths old at that point, and near-bleeding-edge).
So the re-calls to "Tech" support goes on and on for months... SMC ended up exchanging the product (which did absolutely nothing) ... and was about to throw it off my balcony (being that pissed off and frustrated)....when I came across some 3rd party software that allowed me to at least get the thing to work (most of the time (TVersity) ... now, it's only the firmware that's buggy....hangs, restarts on it's own, menu overlay issues, etc etc.
The issues with this piece of crap are well-known out on the Net... so if I were to be buying knowing what I know now, I would have to decide between the Hauppage and the D-Link 320... there are a lot of D-Link folks that hate the Server Software (and are using TVersity BETA software as it's so bad)... but at least the hardware is good.
To those out there who say / review this as a good product, my simple response (as an IT guy) is that SMC/Vendor Sales Reps should not be writing deceptive reviews for an unsuspecting public. Companies should not be trying to sell a product where the software/firmware is not even up to "Beta" standards (think how angry you would be to get Microsoft XP Beta, when you think you are getting their buggy ver 1?)
If you do decide to buy it....you have been warned.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Just what I was looking for, but didn't quite make the grade, February 21, 2004
This review is from: SMC SMCWMR-AG EZ-Stream Universal Wireless Multimedia Receiver (Personal Computers)
I was looking for a networked media receiver that supported 802.11G which I've been using for my home network. When I discovered this SMC Multimedia Receiver I was very excited to make it the solution to converging the entertainment center with the breadth of content (photos, music, and videos) available on our PCs. The SMCWMR-AG was reasonably easy to configure (although 802.11* can be tricky for any technophobe). Once I installed the content server software on my PC, and pointed it at my mp3, jpg, and mpg content everything was ready to go. The first disappointment came when I wanted to start a slideshow from the hundreds of pictures of our infant. The pictures are separated into folders based on events and dates, but I couldn't get a slideshow to work across folders (without rearranging the files or copying to a new directory). Also, the slideshow function froze intermittently (not sure what the issue was here). MP3's seemed to play fine (along with viewing pictures simultaneously), with the same limitation of playing across folders. I didn't get a chance to setup new playlist to see if this solved these problems. I was also disappointed in the limited types of Internet radio streams supported, but I'm sure that could be improved through software in the future. The clincher for me returning the device to the store was playing video. Home movies encoded in anything but the lowest bitrates played fine for a few seconds then did an unwatchable jerky dance. The wireless network reported an excellent link and 54Mbit and occasionally 36Mbit connection speeds. Finally, the user interface seems a bit crude and slow to respond. Again, this may be upgradable in the future so there is the potential for significant improvement. It just didn't meet my expectations at this time. So, I'm considering trying competitive devices such as the Prismiq or Play@TV products. If they don't do the trick it is time to build that media-center PC in an entertainment center-friendly case and be done with it. That still leaves the challenge of sharing content throughout the house unsolved. :-(
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
OK if you are geeky enough to persist with it, January 2, 2005
This review is from: SMC SMCWMR-AG EZ-Stream Universal Wireless Multimedia Receiver (Personal Computers)
So I am geeky enough...but my wife wouldn't be, or my parents or anyone else who expects the appliances in their home to just work when turned on. Yeh, I know this is supposedly leading edge but if it's going in the home next to the TV it needs to be a hell of a lot more reliable. I'm not talking about the network knowledge you need to set it up, I guess if you have a Wireless Access router you are already geek enough to set this up, actually that part of it is pretty easy. It's reliability, stupid. My VCR never "hung" nor should this. I shouldn't have to run upstairs to reboot the PC every hour to restart the server software. The remote control's functions should actually work, not hang the unit needing a power cycle to free it up again. It's temperamental, buggy, and prone to hangs & crashes at both the receiver and PC Mediaserver software end. As another reviewer said, "not yet ready for primetime". The market of geeks like me willing to persist in spite of the bugs is not big enough to support these products, the sooner these businesses realize that and get to the same level of easy-for-the-average-Joe and reliability of something like a Tivo the better. Better still; just build this functionality into something already existing like the Tivo, now that would be a product. Summary: Buggy as hell but cool when it works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|