From School Library Journal
Grade 1-5-Places sacred to Hindus, Buddhists, Jews, Christians, and Muslims are the focus of this striking tour of 28 religious sites around the world (omitting only the South American and Australian continents). After a two-page introduction to the five religions covered, the dual-level text begins. For younger readers, a few words in large type comment on the concept of the sacred and its association with specific places, accompanied by three-dimensional cut-paper illustrations. These necessarily general remarks climax in the observation that "some sacred places aren't made by people at all," and a picture of the night sky. On a second level, each picture has a caption that, although brief, captures specific practices of the religion that considers that site sacred. Simplification means that the differences across sects disappear. A positive emphasis means that cremation is not mentioned in the Ganges caption, and readers glean no hint of conflict around Jerusalem (where the Dome of the Rock "was built-as a symbol of the unity of the three religions that worship the God of Abraham"). Nevertheless, Sturges's open-minded view of religious aspirations is a worthy one. Laroche's rich and detailed art balances architectural impact with situation, use, and cultural context as a photograph could never do. Following Bridges Are to Cross (Putnam, 1998), these amazingly precise, subtly colored, and engagingly textured pictures and concise words show how places in the world can be bridges for the spirit.
Patricia Lothrop-Green, St. George's School, Newport, RI Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 4-6, younger for reading aloud. The text is simple and stately: "People all over the world have made special places where they gather to worship, celebrate, meditate, and hope. These are sacred places." Giles Laroche's exquisite paper cuts of places of worship are stately as well, though they are anything but simple. Impeccably detailed and saturated with color, they bring places of worship excitingly to life. Information about the God of Abraham and five other religions, which begins the book, appears on a two-page spread, which means that not everything is explained as well as it might have been. For example, the sentence "Jesus was declared a heretic and was crucified on the cross" could be interpreted as cause and effect. Numerous sites of worship are introduced--pagodas, mosques, Hindu temples, synagogues, and churches. Some sites "aren't buildings at all": the most breathtaking spreads show the Ganges River, where Indians bathe, and an aerial view of the Kabba, in Mecca, where pilgrims come by the millions. The captions sometimes don't give much information; for instance, there is no explanation of the black stone kissed by people making the Haj. But despite some of these missteps, this evokes a feeling of awe--not just for the sacred places but also for the artistry of the book itself.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved