At the recommendation of my baby daughter's pediatrician, we decided to try introducing her to a straw cup rather than a sippy cup at around 6-and-a-half months old. (Pediatric speech therapists believe that prolonged sippy-cup use can cause speech delays). I first tried the Playtex Lil Gripper Training Cup, the Zoli Bot, and even boxed water (with a straw, so I could squeeze the box and push the water up the straw into baby's mouth). But no luck; my little-one didn't know what to do with the straw in her mouth. At most, she would chew on it like it was a teether, but she wouldn't suck on the straw, no matter what I did. I was THISCLOSE to caving in and buying a regular sippy cup when I spotted the Safe Sippy 2 (SS2) in my local health food store. It seemed to be the best of both worlds ... I could use a "sippy cup" to teach my baby to drink from a straw! (And even if my little-one ended up preferring the sippy to the straw, the SS2's straw-shaped spout would still be better for her speech development than traditional sippy-cup spouts).
I started out using the SS2 without any valves. I tipped it slightly so the water would slowly flow into my baby girl's mouth and show her that there was water in there. When she caught on, I put the sippy-valve into the SS2 and continued to tip it towards her mouth to teach her how to suck/sip liquid through a valve. Once she began to associate the SS2 spout with sucking, I replaced the sippy-valve with the straw-valve & straw and tipped the cup down, and ... voila! By her 2nd time using the SS2, my baby was drinking from the straw like a pro, and hasn't looked back since. The next day, she figured out how to hold the SS2 by its handles, and now drinks from the straw on her own. Finally, success, thanks to the SS2!
It's also a bonus that the SS2 is made of eco-friendly stainless steel and is safe for babies, since it contains no BPA, phthalates, PVC, etc. And while it's not completely leak-proof, it is spill-proof, which is more-than-enough for my needs. My baby only drinks water from the SS2 at or right after (solid food) meals when she's sitting still (e.g., in a high chair), so there's not much opportunity for leakage. (And even if it did leak, it's just water!) And even on those occasions where she dropped the SS2 or knocked it over, no water spilled out thanks to the spill-proof mechanism.
I gave the SS2 4 stars rather than 5 because it does have a few minor shortcomings:
- Because the SS2 cup is made of stainless steel (and there are no measurement markings inside the cup), it's impossible to tell how much your baby has drunk.
- Like virtually all straw sippy cups, if the SS2 is left standing (esp. at room temperature or warmer) for longer than a few minutes, capillary action will cause the beverage inside to flow up the straw and spill out of the top of the spout. However, unlike most other straw cups, which have a flip-top mechanism to close-off the straw to prevent these types of leaks, the SS2 has a "travel plug" that you insert into the underside of the spout instead of the sippy valve or straw adapter. Then, when baby is ready to drink, you have to remove the travel plug and insert the sippy valve or straw adapter. This can be pretty inconvenient, not to mention unsanitary. When you're out-and-about with no easy way to wash/sanitize your hands, the last thing you want to do is be fiddling with the sippy/straw cup parts through which your little-one will be drinking their water/juice/milk, etc.
- The SS2's plastic spout is very hard. My baby girl bonked herself on the nose a couple of times when she was trying to figure out how to direct the spout to her mouth, and we had to act fast to stop her from knocking herself in the forehead or poking herself in the eye with the spout. If you're planning on having your little-one move around independently while holding their sippy/straw cup, you might want to look into getting a cup with a softer, more forgiving straw/spout that's not as likely to cause injury. Kid Basix should consider making the spout of the SS2 out of firm silicone, or even the plastic that the straw itself is made of, rather than the diamond-hard plastic that the spout currently made of.
- The SS2's straw doesn't go all the way to the bottom of the cup, so between a 1/2-ounce to an ounce of liquid is wasted each time you use the cup because it's inaccessible. Not such a big deal if (like me) you're only serving water in your sippy/straw up. But it could be quite annoying if you're using the SS2 to serve breast-milk, formula, or even regular cow's milk to your baby or toddler.
- Because it's made of stainless steel (plus the silicone sleeve), the SS2 is heavier than your average plastic sippy cup. This can make it a bit difficult for small or inexperienced hands to hold and maneuver.
All in all, I'm very pleased with the SS2, and I'd buy it again in a heartbeat. I'd highly recommend it if you're looking for an easy way to teach a first-timer to drink from a straw cup or to transition your baby from a sippy cup to a straw; or for an eco-friendly alternative to plastic sippy cups.
Grade: A-