Customer Reviews

The Sagan Diary [With Earbuds] (Playaway Adult Fiction)

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(9)
1 star:		(6)

 

 

I would start off by saying this is a wonderful book, but not one for the uninitiated. John Scalzi's book Old Man's War, its sequel, The Ghost Brigades, and the forthcoming The Last Colony form the trilogy that brings to life the universe that The Sagan Diary is set in. The 'novelette', as it is termed, are the private thoughts of Jane Sagan, one of the principle characters in this series. Topics of her musings run the gambit from love to war and back again, two often divergent ideas which dominate her life in the Colonial Defense Forces.

I've read both the positive and negative reviews from this book and can honestly say that I understand both opinions. This is a niche book in what is (undeservedly) considered a niche genre and one that is very, very different from the aforementioned novels.

If, like me, you have been swept up into the lives of John Perry and Jane Sagan, I truly believe that this book will further cement your love for the characters. Reading Jane's thoughts caused me to reflect on my own life and love, and for a science fiction story to do that it has to be remarkable.

I think John Scalzi did a marvelous job of capturing the essence of who Jane Sagan is, which paves the way for her further adventures with John Perry in Scalzi's next novel, The Last Colony. In spite of all the very enjoyable action and adventure in this series, it is the romantic subplot that helps elevate the books for me and this is a welcome addition to that aspect of the story.

Subterranean Press has put together a very beautiful book with wonderful pencil illustrations by Bob Eggleton.

I highly recommend that you read Old Man's War and the Ghost Brigades, then pick this one up and let it whet your appetite for The Last Colony.

My copy of John Scalzi's The Sagan Diary arrived Friday afternoon. Along with a Dunhill cigar and a glass or three of port, it made a great after-dinner treat.

The Sagan Diary differs radically from Scalzi's other published works. Unlike the Old Man's War trilogy, in whose universe The Diary is located, this is not a military sci-fi action tale. Unlike The Android's Dream, The Diary isn't premised on fart jokes. Instead, it is an introspective rumination on life, love, and words. Indeed, the first half might fairly be called a great writer's (prose) song about his love for words. The second half is a moving prose Valentine, in which Scalzi's Sagan ruminates on the experience of loving another.

I've been a fan of Scalzi's since he burst on to the scene with Old Man's War. Yet, The Diary shows an emotional depth at which his prior work has only hinted. It proves that this is a writer in whom one ought to invest for the long haul, as it suggests that he has only scratched the surface of his potential.

I just heard that the publisher is making the full-text online for free, which is great news since this is such a love-it-or-hate-it book for a lot of readers.

Personally, I'm thankful that I got it from the library before spending my money, altough normally I'm perfectly comfortable "taking a chance" on books by authors whose other work I like. But this... well, to me it felt like pure stream-of-consciousness, literary diarrhea (sorry, I know that's unkind) with little to no editing on either the author or publisher's part. Of course, I don't know that was the case, but that's how the book felt to me. I really have trouble believing this particular manuscript, or this type of writing in general, would have had much chance of being published if it weren't capitalizing on the success of the first two "Old Man's War" books.

The free online version will let people make informed decisions for themselves without risking their money. I applaud the publisher and the author for taking that step!

The title is very accurate. This is an intimate diary of Jane Sagan, wherein she reflects on many thing, primarily her love for... (well, I don't want to spoil it if you haven't read Old Man's War and Ghost Brigades). It really is all her thoughts on a variety of topics. In a sense it is a sequel to Ghost Brigades, and really should only be read after that to make sense of what Sagan is thinking. It extends the storyline a little, but it is really a very different book than the previous two in the series.

This is a short story (novelette) that came about as a sort of dare. For a fundraising auction, John (Scalzi) offered a bound draft version of `The Last Colony' for $5,000 -- plus a short story written by him for the winning bidder. Bill Shafer of the Subterranean Press took him up on his offer - and this is the result.

If you haven't read John Scalzi's `Old Man's War,' this new story might be a bit confusing to follow. But for those who have -- this `diary' offers insight into the thoughts and feelings of Jane Sagan, a Special Forces warrior - and love interest of John Perry (around whom the `Old Man's War' is written).

In the earlier work, John Perry is living a second life - inside a new, warrior's body. His wife (of his first life) chose not to be reissued. But her DNA was still re-cast - with a new life `born' fully grown into it - who became Jane Sagan.

This story reveals that John Perry and Jane Sagan, against all odds, somehow survive their ten year tours-of-duty and retire - to live out their `second' lives together in peace (as warriors no longer).

This diary is Jane's account (written to John) of her hopes and regrets - as she transitions from her `first' life (and body) - to her `second.'

Scalzi uses Jane's perspective to show us that a manufactured human, a warrior -- is still very much a product of her physical self and her experiences - and is yet a human being, nonetheless.

As originals, I guess it's always easy for us to assume that our form of human -- will forever remain the gold standard, but John Scalzi subtly unveils for us - that that might not always be the case!

The `Sagan Diary' is but a very small, thought-provoking piece - of a much larger pie - and one which I enjoyed immensely! I'm sure you will, too!

I really liked this book, but it is admittedly offbeat. It's short, but very well done. More of a psychological story than science fiction, the reader is given the opportunity to get to know the mind of Jane Sagan. Her viewpoints are interesting and there are some unexpected and quirky twists and turns to her internal logic. I gave this a high rating to reward the very successful writing exercise that John Scalzi has undertaken. It's refreshing and unorthodox. Hope to see more of these experiments from Scalzi!!

As you read through that other reviews here, you'll note, (as I did) that almost all the negative opinions are based on people not getting _what they thought_ they were getting. But hedging my bets, I got it from the library first. And then I immediately bought it.

So, let's cut to the chase. It's a diary of Jane Sagan, it's 100 pages (small) with illustrations, and it's written like a diary.

That's a really, really good thing.

In the Sagan's words, you feel the influences of the Herbert's Dune, Valerie's Letter from Moore's V for Vendetta and other works. She speaks with a voice that is uniquely hers, human, but not quite as we understand it, and with the problems and fears that being other-human brings to the table. It's a must-read primer for really understanding Sagan in The Last Colony.

If you're an Old Man's War universe fan, and you're into the characters, go get it. You won't be sorry you did.

Who knows, it might matter even more after Zoe's Tale?

This is perhaps closer to being a prose poem rather than a story. It's the inner thoughts and ruminations of Jane Sagan as she prepares to transfer to a `normal' human body and give up her life in the Colonial Defense forces. As such, this story falls in-between The Ghost Brigades and the forth-coming Last Colony novels, and to truly understand some of the sub-text of this, Old Man's War and the Ghost Brigades really should be read before this, although it's certainly possible to read this in isolation.

But this work is certainly an adventure in style, written in first person, and very, very different from the earlier works set in this universe. There are some sentences and whole paragraphs that can take your breath away for how neatly they are constructed and how well they capture emotions twined about some very deep philosophical ruminations about killing, death, fear, love (especially love), war, and the isolation of one human from another. As you proceed through this, Jane's character blossoms, becomes far more richly detailed than the brief glimpses we have been given in the earlier works. But there is little real story here, not much in the way of plot or action, so at most this can only qualify as a `character' piece, which some may find disappointing, given John's previous rather action-packed works. Still, there are more than enough issues raised here to keep you thinking long after you finish reading this, no small feat for such a short work.

As a piece that adds richness to his universe, this work is excellent. But it only fills in a very small piece of his story, and should not be expected to do more.

---Reviewed by Patrick Shepherd (hyperpat)

I've read the "Old Man's War" trilogy. I loved the universe John Scalzi created. I was more than happy to see "Zoe's Tale" and this book were added to the trilogy. This book is less than a hundred pages and takes place across the first two books of the trilogy. It's all about Jane's birth into this new world, war, friendship, and love. It's a nice read and gives a little further insight into this powerful character.

This book is also available for free now at the publishers website but I felt compelled to add this hardcover edition to my collection. It was the least I could do for this author who had created so many hours of entertainment for me.

Those familiar with John Scalzi's Old Man's War and Ghost Brigade will have to reprogram themselves a bit for this little gem. It stands apart (and well above) a lot of other spec fiction I have read, and adds a nice flourish to the author's adroit future history. But it's not really a part of that epic; it's more of a sidebar. And what a sidebar.

You're not going to get much of a galloping story here, altho there is plot movement that wraps up very nicely. Instead you will be treated to beautifully crafted excerpts from the thoughts of a person who has been through experiences (albeit imaginary ones) that could easily had embittered or corrupted a lesser being, and who applies the lessons of those experiences to the universal topics of life, love and death. In other words, wisdom. This book is poetry; those who are not much interested in reflective expression will probably not be taken with it. Those who are will be delighted.

In a word, The Sagan Diary is sublime. There are ideas in it that go well beyond page-turning entertainment, and they are expressed in an economical, thoughtful prose that is sheer delight to read. Take a minute and reflect on some of Jane Sagan's observations and apply them (hopefully, however, not every one of them!) to your own life experiences, and the value of the book will emerge.

It's one you'll want to reread more than once. You'll come to know Jane Sagan very well.