5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ed Falco's Mastery, October 24, 2009
This review is from: Saint John of the Five Boroughs (Paperback)
This is the second novel I've read by Ed Falco (and novels are just the half of it: the guy's a master of short stories, and if the world were just his stuff'd be everywhere heralded) and, like his last book (Wolf Point, also from Unbridled), St. John is a dynamite book focused on 'unorthodox' relationships, the battles and fatigue that come from those relationships, the ways in which people wish to be and the ways in which they deal with and/or handle (or, often as not, fail) all aspects of self.
I'll admit to being baffled that anyone'd complain about this book being a drag, or slow-moving, or hard to get into: if anything, Falco's writing's deceptive precisely *because* it's so fast moving--stuff happens at a quick, cinematic pace: in the first fifty pages the reader sees a party, sees a relationship strained, sees the instigation of two strange relationships...there's tons. The richness in terms of plot is more than worth the price of admission. And it's deceptive because, at speeds like those Falco works, a reader might be used to a book which is simpler, shallower--a read that'll provide the popcorn frizz of fun but not the real satisfying heft of Truth or Reality. Falco's working the latter category, strongly.
Stress that word 'cinematic,' actually: I can think of few books--hell, few writers--with as keen a sensory focus as St. John: Falco's work is immersive and rewarding in all sorts of ways, not least of which is that we can, in the best way, both feel and feel for the characters, and we're able to feel so much because we see them so clearly, can see the scenes--we can see that party at the start, can smell and feel what's happening (meaning, of course, that Falco's about as generous an author as one could hope for, willing to give the reader enough to get fully invested not just in the story but in the whole world of the story). Plus there's ideation/theme stuff: we've all read books in which a character is merely a stand-in for some idea the author's trying to hawk or use to prop certain thematic developments; we've all read books in which the characters are, ultimately, beautifully rendered but without any depth or substance, characters which don't offer the reader a way to trace larger currents running beneath the story.
But Falco gives us, instead, Avery and Grant (there's a whole set of characters, but these are the two you'll miss most at the book's close), flawed, complicated, confused, trying-damn-hard people. If great writing's made of sentences which honor the world's complexity, which honor the confused and confusing ways each of us tries to balance desires and fears, to balance hope for what's next and frustration with what we've already done, Ed Falco's St. John is right at the highest echelon of great writing. Buy the book. Read the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Double Excellent, October 25, 2009
This review is from: Saint John of the Five Boroughs (Paperback)
I read St. John of the Five Burroughs in three sittings; couldn't stop wanting to find out
how the plot and characters were going to evolve/resolve. Excellent excellent book. Falco's
richest and most complex so far. Such great, multi-layered characters -- even when they're
making really terrible decisions I totally understand and sympathize with their logic. There's
so many things to think about with each of them -- the various questions they raise about
responsibility and obligation -- to self, family, art, spirit, society. All woven smoothly into
a compelling narrative.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Gangsters, New York art scene, infidelity and love, October 24, 2009
This review is from: Saint John of the Five Boroughs (Paperback)
Reviewers have rightfully stressed the seamless writing, the well crafted world building, and the book's quick cinematic pace. On the one hand, the book reads like a well crafted indy film. Edward Falco creates unorthodox characters that are painfully real in their motivations and logic, which is part of the book's appeal.
On the other hand, I found the unorthodox and real characters to be too "real" at certain points. I could easily picture Lindsay's response to her brother's deployment and her demand that their family relocate to New York City, but just as I could readily imagine Lindsay, I found her to be flighty and annoying.
While I might not have enjoyed Saint John of the Five Boroughs as much as many of the other reviewers, it was just not my thing. Other readers will surely appreciate the clearsightedness with which Edward Falco creates his characters.
Publisher: Unbridled Books; 1st edition (October 20, 2009), 424 pages.
Review copy provided by the publisher and Unbridled Book Tours.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No