The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New Guinea (Case Studies in Cultural Anthropology) [Paperback]

Gilbert Herdt (Author)

Book Description

Publication Date: December 15, 2005 | ISBN-10: 0534643833 | ISBN-13: 978-0534643836 | Edition: 2

This cultural and psychological study of gender identity and sexual development in a New Guinea Highlands society includes rich material on initiation rites and socialization studies, and contrasts the Sambia with other societies, including the United States. For example, Sambia boys experience ritualized homosexuality before puberty and continue this practice until marriage, after which homosexual activity is prohibited. The implications are developed cross-culturally and contextualized in gender literature.

Product Details

• Paperback: 208 pages
• Publisher: Wadsworth Publishing; 2 edition (December 15, 2005)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0534643833
• ISBN-13: 978-0534643836
• Product Dimensions: 9.2 x 6.5 x 0.3 inches
• Shipping Weight: 9.6 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.2 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #27,969 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Discover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Challenging the Way We Think of Sexuality, May 6, 2010

By 

Anthro Student (CA, USA) - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New Guinea (Case Studies in Cultural Anthropology) (Paperback)

A classic and ground-breaking study on sexuality, The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New Guinea offers much to learn to the beginning student of Anthropology and those interested in understanding other cultures and other configurations of sexual practices. Sexuality was once a tabooed subject and avoided by most, even anthropologists. Gilbert Herdt, having come to age as an Anthropologist during the 1960's, followed in the footsteps of Bronislaw Malinowski's and Margaret Mead's work in Melanesia to produce this study which would lay the ground work for many future anthropologists interested in sexuality.
Herdt's initial difficulty understanding Sambian culture through a Sambia discourse is demonstrated by his initial classification of Sambia as practicing "ritualized homosexuality". Herdt admits that this terminology was ethnocentric in nature: the Sambia themselves did not possess a lexicon to understand that two men or two women could be recognized as partners. It was with this western discourse of sexuality that Herdt had initially mistakenly conceptualized the Sambia, and this highlights the difficulties anthropologist must overcome when studying other cultures. Likewise, Herdt's work is often understood to be evidence that homosexuality, as practiced in the west, is natural. However, there are two inherent problems with this conclusion. On the one hand, it assumes that western cultural is itself unnatural. However, human behavior is always natural, and thus, never in need of a justification for its "naturalness". This conclusion also exploits the idea that tribes such as the Sambia are primitive and in some way more natural due to their less "evolved" and somehow static state. The latter assumption, possessed by social-cultural evolutionists, has been heavily critiqued and out right rejected by anthropologists. Furthermore, to assume that sexual actions constitute a sexual identity, as they do in the west, is to be confined by the definitions of sexuality implemented in the west. As we see in Herdt's ethnography, although the Sambia for a time practice homosexual acts, they would not identify themselves as homosexual. Nonetheless, the Sambia do demonstrate that sexuality varies across time and place, and in this way they give hope to sexual others across the globe who must fight against powerful heteronormative discourses that seek to cast sexual others (in the west, GLBT individuals) as deviant, unnatural, and/or immoral and attempt in some case to persecute them.
Herdt observes that Sambia boys are initiated into manhood by an elaborate series of initiation rites. The secrecy that surrounds these rites is meant to keep the practices, and particularly the one which involves "boy-inseminating", hidden from the Sambia women. Throughout the ethnography, one gets the sense that Sambian men are highly misogynistic. Herdt tells us that the Sambian are constantly at war with their neighbors, and it appears that this misogyny both helps to keep the initiation rites secret and keep the war band of men closely bonded. The practice of boy-inseminating, that which proves the most culturally shocking for the average reader, challenges our understanding of sexuality. All older initiates are to ejaculate after fellatio into the younger boys' mouths, a process that is thought by the Sambia to pass on jerungdu (male strength) to the initiates. The normal practice is for older initiates to engage in this activity with younger ones, and therefore, all Sambian males circulate in and out of these sexual practices. Thus, these periods of homosexuality exist only temporarily, and are not viewed as being part of an adult male's identity. Other rituals include nose bleeding, the ceremony of the flutes, and ritualized beatings, all of which Herdt details at length.
Although women are not part of the secret cult, they nonetheless play a very important role in many of the Sambian men's practices. For example, Jerungdu, as mentioned above, is thought to be in constant decline. Contact with women and ejaculation decrease a man's jerungdu. In this belief, we see how women are cast in conflict with manliness, and this attributes to the misogynist beliefs of the Sambian men. In addition to avoiding women, men of the Sambia consume tree sap in order to replenish their supply of jerungdu. Likewise, the Sambia men are very concerned about the younger men keeping their rituals secret, and it appears as though they are very afraid of the women finding out about their sexual encounters with the boys. This fear of the women in turn spurs many of the rituals and behaviors of the Sambian men. The Sambian men's fear of women suggests that the women are respected in Sambian culture. As a male, Herdt only had access to the male realm (and even then, he speaks about his contested presence in their secret rituals), and thus, we can only indirectly understand the women's world. This dynamic leaves the reader wondering about the women's world and their understanding of them men's realm. Of course, the sex of an ethnographer often places such limitations on the type of study they can produce, and this dynamic gives us an interesting insight to the complex role of insider/outsider the anthropologist must traverse.
The Sambia are neither a static culture nor immune to the impacts of globalization. Herdt notes the changing lifestyles of Sambian individuals as Christianity is brought into their world and individuals begin to desire life in the city as opposed to life in the Sambian village. Luckily for anthropologists and others interested in the social practices of other cultures, Herdt arrived in time to document the now disappearing practices of the Sambia. Like many structuralists, Herdt's ethnography is at times uninterestingly detailed. However, for the intellectually curious, it is a must read.

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Well-researched and insightful, May 6, 2010

By 

A. Dhar (Claremont, CA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New Guinea (Case Studies in Cultural Anthropology) (Paperback)

Herdt truly does understand Sambia culture in a way those who won't experience life with the Sambia for themselves, and it shows. His narrative shows careful research and interaction with the Sambia, and the reader will benefit from his knowledge. I was fascinated by the Sambian culture and practices, and I found the detailed pictures and accounts of Sambian rituals to be helpful in my understanding of Sambia life. It is amazing to consider that Herdt lived so many years among the Sambia and learned so much about both the men and the women's lives, especially since Sambia society is so gender-segregated and interaction between sexes is highly taboo. I was disappointed by the lack of CD that was mentioned several times in the text, yet there was no accompanying CD included in my book. Perhaps a later edition will have some sort of multimedia component as well? It would have greatly added to the reading experience. As others have said, though, the book was somewhat repetitive and the introduction chapters (warlife and setting) were pretty dull, but this book is set up like an ethnography, and therefore the author was not trying to write a bestselling novel, but an accurate and thorough account of life in the Sambia, which I believe he did quite well.
I found that instead of focusing solely on Sambia life in the past and their ritual practices, Herdt does a great job of showing how Sambia life has changed over the past few decades because of missionaries and globalization. Even though some practices seem to be bizarre and cruel to those who aren't in such a society, the loss of such rituals left me disappointed and a bit sad. It's a bit of a shame that the Sambia way of life was uprooted so suddenly by outsiders. Overall, this book was very informative and interesting, though perhaps not written in the most interesting of styles.

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars A Rare Window into a Remote and Vanishing Culture, May 6, 2010

By 

C. Authement - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: The Sambia: Ritual, Sexuality, and Change in Papua New Guinea (Case Studies in Cultural Anthropology) (Paperback)

The Sambia protected the secrecy of their male rituals with an oath, and those who violated it were threatened with death. Gilbert Herdt arrived at a time when the outside world was starting to break down this wall of secrecy that the Sambia so highly valued, and thus he was able to provide this fascinating expose on a culture whose arguably homosexual behaviors sparked controversy and discussion about the issue of the "naturalness" of homosexuality among our species.

The book is a bit eerie to read for this reason, and Herdt describes in first person the outlandish rituals of the Sambia. I found it hard to imagine what my reactions would be in the situations in which he found himself. The cultural collision is so strong that it seems incredibly fitting that our perspective should be limited to one of a spectator. Overall the text as an ethnography is well rounded in that it explores the history of the culture, focusing on why the tribe's ritual's developed, the present situation, including the specific cases of the Sambia that Herdt lived with during his study, and also their future, as globalization began to dramatically alter the boundaries of their society.

As a well-written investigation of a cultural whose unusual habits are really quite interesting, I would definitely recommend this book to potential buyers, although depending on the level of interest, it might be a one-time read.