80 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very Slick with Lots of Potential, October 5, 2008
This review is from: Samsung Instinct SPH-M800 Phone, Black (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
I have used many mobile "smartphones" / "featurephones" in the last year trying to settle on something that meets my needs. The list includes iPhone (1st gen), HTC Mogul, Q9C, Palm Treo 755p, Treo 800w and the Instinct.
My needs and expectations might be different from the reader's, so let me lay them out in advance:
* A decent web browsing experience for regular "desktop" sites.
* Sufficient music capabilities to replace my iPod for most purposes.
* Basic email and calendaring capabilities (Outlook "PUSH" is not one of them).
* An easy-to-use and "fun" interface.
* A reliable phone, with good battery life.
* Navigation, if I can get it.
* MMS capabilities, if I can get it.
Here is where the previous devices have fallen short:
iPhone - Bad AT&T service in my area made it challenging to use as a phone. At the time, EDGE data was too slow to enjoy surfing the web. Pages look great once loaded, but who has 3-4 minutes per page to surf. If I am using WiFi, I might as well have my laptop. No MMS offered. Why?
I know the 3G version improves on this, but AT&T 3G coverage is still not up to par with the EVDO offered by Verizon/Sprint. This is simply the case of a good phone on a bad network.
Mogul - Poor reliability with many bugs that have not been fixed with several firmware update releases. This makes it unsatisfactory to use even for basic voice calls. Who can cope with a phone that reboots during a call? Not a good iPod replacement because you have to use the USB jack or an adapter to hook up a good pair of headphones and bluetooth stereo quality was not good enough to replace wired headphones in my experience. No MMS (can't send pictures of kids to my parents while out-and-about without using email).
Q9C - Almost good enough. Just too darn slow. Too little memory. It does run Windows Mobile 6.1 smartphone with some UI enhancements, and includes a 2.5mm headphone jack for audio. A good choice for anyone willing to live with performance drawbacks. Good voice quality and reasonably reliable for a Microsoft-powered device. My back-up device. No MMS (on Sprint).
Treo 755p - Simply not able to get a decent web browser on the device. It does almost everything else OK, even if the interface is a bit too simplistic. The included Blazer browser has difficulty digesting most modern web sites, runs out of memory and is too slow. Although there are J2ME runtime engines that can be used to run Opera Mini, it frequently crashes the phone.
Treo 800w - Does everything, just not that well. Makes a pig of itself with battery use (see my review elsewhere on Amazon). The phone really falls down as an iPod replacement because it does not have an audio jack, only a microUSB connector. Hard to find good headphones for this jack. Stereo bluetooth on the device with my Moto S9 headphones introduces alot of noise. Still no MMS (on Sprint).
Now we come to the Instinct:
WEB BROWSER:
The browser has been greatly improved by the latest MR-3 firmware update, and Samsung/Sprint does seem inclined to continue to roll out improvements. I think the record sales of the device serves as an incentive to continue offering updates to the software. An MR-4 firmware is slated that is supposed to add keyboard support to J2ME applications that should allow the device to run Opera Mini and many other programs. The browser is not perfect, but it is fast enough to surf the web and get a reasonable approximation of most pages I visit. With the latest update you can take advantage of the entire screen for the browser, hiding all controls. Panning is simple with fingertip swipes. Zoom is still a bit clunky but reasonably fast.
A few "web applications" are present under the web tab that offer an attractive interface to some features you would normally use the browser for such as: weather, news, movie times and sports scores. Much better than using any browser to access this data. I would like to see more of these offered, in fact (how about a YouTube front-end?).
You will also find a version of Microsoft's Live Search to use speech to find local business found with the assistance of the built-in GPS. A very nice touch. Once found, you can call them up or get turn-by-turn directions to get there.
MUSIC
Ahh... finally, a phone with a 3.5mm headphone jack. This allows you to plug in standard iPod-like headphones and enjoy music. Bluetooth playback on the S9 headphones is also very good. The music application is nice, and you can use up to an 8GB SD card to store songs. You can buy music over-the-air from the Sprint Music Store which is integrated into the music application. Still not an iPod touch, but plenty good enough for my uses.
EMAIL AND CALENDAR
The email is simple and easy to use. It offers enough features for a mobile device, although a few options such as a custom signature would be nice. It does not render HTML email, but does help you along by including any web links that might be embedded in an HTML message. For my use, this is a faster alternative than asking the phone to download and render a full HTML version with images for my email on the go.
I would appreciate the capability to view some simple file formats, particularly PDF. I understand this is slated for the MR-4 release and the fact they recognize this need placates me for the time being.
Calendering, on the other hand, is the Achilles Heel for replacing a typical smartphone with this device. There is no provision to sync your calendar with the web or desktop. Accordingly, while there is a calendar app built in, I don't even use it. For the present, I muddle through accessing the mobile version of Google Calendar. Sprint needs to do something to fix this. Maybe a front-end to Google Calendar. If not, it is my hope that a more complete Java stack will open the door for third-party solutions. (See more about Java on the Instinct below).
INTERFACE
The interface is attractive and easy to use. Much better than poking around menus with the tiny stylus on a Windows Mobile device. I know about keyboard shortcuts, but I am more of a point-and-click kind of guy. Just personal preference.
The touch screen is very responsive for a non-capacitive sensor, much better than say the Treo. Not as good as the iPhone, but nothing has a better touch interface than the iPhone.
The Instinct does have "haptic" (vibration) feedback that makes it feel almost as if you are touching physical buttons and makes the phone very satisfying to use.
PHONE, NAV AND MMS
The phone sounds great. Call options are right where they should be, with easy ability to add a conference call or mute the microphone, for example. An in-call menu allows you to access common functions such as the address book or notes while in a call. Photos linked to contacts show up during income/outgoing calls.
The phone also has very good "speech to action" capabilities. You can use this to quickly dial a number or call one from you address book. No voice training is necessary and it is very accurate and usable.
Navigation is simply second-to-none. Tell it where you want to go by talking (through the Live Search discussed above) or type an address, intersection or business name and you are off with turn-by-turn directions and an animated moving map. You can also search for close by businesses and the like (such as the closest gas station or fast-food joint while on the road). Easily meets my navigation needs. Apple should take note and try to put something similar on the iPhone. Google Maps is good, but not like this.
MMS is the cherry on top. You can easily send and receive pictures and short video clips. I use this all the time to send quick snapshots to my wife's phone (a Centro) or my parents. The Treo 755p is the only phone listed above that has this capability. Why such a common innovation is left out of Sprint's smartphone lineup is simply beyond me. There are hacks to do it on Windows Mobile, but it is not the same as having it built into the phone's UI.
MISC
In terms of other attributes, I find the phone has enough battery power for my needs. It is attractive and easy to slip in/out of your pocket. Bluetooth pairing is simple (Widows Mobile -- take note). The speaker is loud enough for ringers. Physical controls are easy to understand. Sprint includes a generous accessory package with the phone: Music syncing application (Windows only), USB cable, wall charger, 2 batteries, a spare battery charger, a handsfree stereo headset, and a 2GB SD card.
The camera is perfectly fine for a phone. Nice pictures and a simple interface. If I want something better I'll use my Nikon dSLR. It records video and the quality is actually surprisingly good for what it is. I always wished Apple would put this on the iPhone, but they just don't want their customers to have it for some reason.
_______________________________________________________________
CAVEATS
*******
Now the downsides, many of which I hope to see remedied:
JAVA
This phone is advertised as being based on an "open" platform in that J2ME applications can be run on the phone, opening the door to many third-party applications. The problem is that Sprint inexplicably does not offer the standard text input libraries developers expect to have present on a J2ME device. This means you can load Opera Mini, but you can't use the on-screen keyboard to enter a URL. Sprint knows this was a gaff, and they assure that a fix is in the works...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Samsung Instinct, September 27, 2008
This review is from: Samsung Instinct SPH-M800 Phone, Black (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
Samsung instinct, September 27, 2008
By Wild Bill "Bill" (CA) - See all my reviews
Pros:
#1. GPS is a cool feature especially if you drive a lot and need directions.
#2. Easy to use with the touch screen
#3. Good looking phone. I really liked the large screen size.
I really wanted to give it a fair shake, that's why I had it for 3 weeks. It was not compatible for my use and here are the problems I had with it.
Cons:
#1. The Samsung Instinct-I owned the phone for 3 weeks. During that time I was calling sprint's technical support almost everyday.
The main problem was voicemail. It had a bug that when my customers, (that's right I use this phone for business.)Called and it would go to voicemail it gave the message "All circuits are busy" Intermittently. The tech support told me that they had a nationwide outage of voicemail but my son has the same service but different phone and his never did this. I kept calling for tech support and week three the last operator told me to replace the phone. Which I did with a Palm Centro.
#2.When you push a button like the web or e-mail many times it would not respond. I would wait a bit then it would work to me. It seems as if it was running slow.
#3.The Battery: There is a reason why they give you 2 batteries. It uses a fully charged battery just using the phone function, voicemail and e-mail in about 2 hours. If you buy this phone get a car charger.
#4. Email: The emails I receive many times have attachments such as word or PDF files. This phone won't open them up!
#5. The web: I could not log on to my bank account because of compatibility so it really was worthless-That's why I bought it, one of the main reasons to check my accounts and to go on my website and check orders. Didn't work. You could only surf. It is soooooo slow!!!
3G or not it is very slow. Dial up is faster. But you can watch videos so I guess it is faster than dial up. Loading pages took a long time.
There were more problems that I had but these are enough major reasons for certain people to not buy it.
I ended up with a Palm Centro. Excellent phone. No trouble with voicemail. Opens and stores PDF files word and excel docs. The web browsing is at least 3 times as fast and it isn't even 3G. I think I will do a review of the Centro when I have had it longer than 3 weeks, Great Phone if you are in business and need it to actually work! Don't buy the Instinct
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The best phone I've had but..., October 24, 2008
This review is from: Samsung Instinct SPH-M800 Phone, Black (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
This is a great phone, but there are a few things that could really turn this phone into an amazing phone.
1. Better music player: The phone comes with a 2gb card which is great for storing music. However I have put on 2gb's worth of music and the phone takes forever to load, probably about 6-8 minutes. I thought this was only going to be the first time it read the music, but that is definitely not the case. Everytime I open the music player it has to go throught this whole process again. I tried taking of a lot of the music and put on about 30 songs to see if it would be faster. Well it was faster, but still not nearly fast enough. It takes about 1-2 minutes to play those songs. I am hoping for a program update to resolve this issue. Until then I am stuck.
2. Viewing of Word, Excel, Powerpoint: This phone is very capable of viewing e-mail and it does a great job of it, even managing 2 e-mail accounts(yahoo mail, and my work e-mail through microsoft exchange server). The only problem is that I have a lot of e-mails that contain attachments of word, excel, and occassionaly powerpoint. There are several other phones, in this class of phones,that have capabilities of doing this and this one should be included. Another thing that I will hope a program update will fix. Until then...
Other than the 2 points above I would say this phone is great! It is by far the best phone I have ever had and everything else that it does is awesome. My favorite feature is the GPS with search. I can pull up the program and say "pizza" and boom within seconds I have 20 pizza places that are close to me to choose from. Even better I can click on the one I want and see the phone number (one click to call), address (one click to start my GPS driving me there), and reviews which I can view and create.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No