44 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great for low-vision or hearing impaired. No frills., January 5, 2009
This review is from: Samsung Knack SCH-U310 Phone, Black (Verizon Wireless) (Wireless Phone)
This phone will never be stolen or used by anyone under 21 (or under 50). It is the most un-kewl device in existence. An iPhone, it is not!
For the vision or hearing impaired or for those who don't need or want the latest gizmo, this phone is for you.
Since the phone does relatively little, there are much less menus. Most of the menu options turn on or off sounds. Example option: Phone will sound out each key you press("four", "six") . Turning on each sound option will make for a very talkative companion.
Pros:
The fonts are large. Very, very large. And you can make the fonts in some of the menus even larger.
No camera. No games. No music. No pictures.
The text is very black and in some areas, the background is bright white making for highly readable ultra-high contrast text. With my 20/20 vision I can literally read the text from across the bedroom. I kid you not.
It does have speed dial but the options to set it is not as described in the manual. I found the speed dial option in a different menu.
The keys light up quite clearly and brightly.
The keys are nicely tactile.
Superb battery conservation. If you don't use the phone much, you probably can go over a week or two before needing a recharge.
The maximum sound is loud -- really loud. A person can hear incoming voices on the other side of the room at the highest setting. You might want to lower the sound for some phone calls.
I use the calendar but it could be improved. I also use the alarm clock, stop watch and calculator. The calendar, alarm clock and calculator have dedicated buttons.
Cons:
Why, oh, why didn't they allow for a blank wallpaper?
This phone is clearly designed for the visually impaired or the no-frills type of person so why wouldn't they have a white, or neutral color, background on the main menu? What were they thinking? There's no way of importing a blank wallpaper since there's no camera and no option to disable the wallpaper.
Small (tiny?) "OK" button.
Small external display. No caller ID on external display. No date on external display.
Also, the font could have been (should have been) larger on the main menu, but no, they had to have a cutesy background.
No Bluetooth. A disadvantage if you want/need a wireless headset.
Some backgrounds have other colors. No option for change. Colors reduce contrast and readability.
The voice recognition is positively awful and slowwwww. It just drives me to tears. My phone from 10+ years ago did a far better job of recognizing names. And you have to see the moronic copyright screen each time. If I wrote that software, I would hide, not show, the copyright screen. It's shameful.
The voice recognition voice prompts is played though the speaker phone which can be rather embarrassing in certain situations. I haven't found an option to disable this "feature". Again, what were they thinking or are they just stupid?
There is no vibrate before ring option. I like to be able to answer the phone before it actually rings so the ring doesn't disturb others. The vibrate feature is rather weak. [Update Feb 28, 09: I found a voice option where a feminine voice softly says 'You have an incoming call' before the phone rings. Many times I'm able to answer the phone before it actually rings. I absolutely love this feature.]
The appointment feature in the calendar is a bit lame. There's no way of alerting you of an upcoming appointment. What I do is set the appointment for several hours in advance and type in the actual time in the text field.
I don't understand why they made the power connection so small and difficult. On the power cord, there's a dark red arrow on a black background. Why not white? And the protective cover is dark red and flimsy. Good luck if you have low vision or poor finger coordination. Another insult to the disabled. On some reviews, the protective door colors are brightened so that they appear to be highly visible. Those reviewers are being deceptive.
In short, this simple phone will meet 80% of the needs of those who are mildly disabled and 95% of those who just want a simple phone. If you have a relative who needs a simple phone or is disabled or a technophobe, you can set this up for them and they'll be happily independent (except for the recharging).
The ring volume is rather low on both of our phones even though the ring volumes are set to the maximum. If the phone is in a pocketbook or a jacket, you might not be able to find your phone when it rings. I find this to be a major detractor. We miss a lot of phone calls because of this. I carry my phone in my pocket. I can never hear my phone ring when I'm in a store. We don't carry phones on a holster and we're not about to start. When other people's cell phone rings, they're so loud I jump. Mine could ring in a theater and I don't think anyone would notice.
[Update Jan 24, 2010] I've been informed that a recharging cradle is available which will eliminate the plug-in recharging problem. With Verizon, the default number of rings are 3. You can call Verizon and increase the number of rings up to 8. This CANNOT be done from this phone. Please note that some of the rings are gobbled up before your phone rings so don't expect the phone to actually ring a full 8 times.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Entry Level Texting Phone =), November 5, 2008
This is a great entry level texting phone for all the text message whores out there. Despite all the pictures advertising the phone, it only appears to be big and bulky but it's the complete opposite. The phone is actually very slim & slender. I love that it comes in 3 different colors (Green, Blue, & Rose White) and probably more on the way. I picked up the green one and i love it. I originally purchased the Samsung Epix PDA phone and was so disappointed by the awful operating system and returned it right away. Finally the Samsung Propel hits the stores and it's basically a PDA smart phone without the Window Mobile operating system (Which is awful by the way). I love the Samsung Menu and UI. It's easy to use and just navigating through it is a breeze. You don't even need to look at the manual to operate this thing. The one downside to the Propel is that the screen could be a bit bigger and the colors could be a bit more vibrant. You only get 65K colors as oppose to the usual Samsung high end phones that come with 262K colors. So, that was one of the disappointments with this phone. Samsung knew this phone was strictly for the teens so i can see why the price is so cheap. Considering the friendly price is probably a big reason why you don't get the 262K colors. Another flaw is the Instant Messaging. You do get AIM & Yahoo but the buddylist is not in real time. You will only be able to see a few friends on your buddylist not all. But if you IM them they will respond even though they appear to not be signed in. The best thing about my Sidekick LX is that IM is in real time. I signed on from both devices and had about 50 friends on my buddylist appear on my SK while the Propel only had 3. As i stated before even though only 3 appear you can still IM the ones that don't appear and chat with them. Also AT&T for some reason is so stingy with the accessories. I wish it came with an additional USB charger, free micro SD memory card, or a case. Unfortunately NONE. All you get is the cell & wall charger. Overall i am very pleased with my purchase and recommend anyone looking for a texting phone or any device that might come close to a Sidekick on the AT&T network, this would be the phone 4 u.
Pros:
Sleek sexy design
Comes in multiple colors
Camera/camcorder (Really should be 6.0 megapixel by now)
Built in Messaging Clients (AIM, Yahoo Messenger, Etc)
Access to Emails
Qwerty Keyboard
MP3 Players
Samsung Menu
GPS
Slider Phone
Micro SD (Up to 8GB)
Cons:
Only 65K Colors on screen
Only 1.3 Megapixel Camera/Camcorder (Really should be 6.0 by now)
Battery is really thin so carry an extra charger with you
AT&T is really cheap with the accessories (Only device & charger included)
Wish a USB Charger was included
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Beware the Knack, July 27, 2009
This review is from: Samsung Knack SCH-U310 Phone, Black (Verizon Wireless) (Wireless Phone)
On May 4, 2009, I finally broke down and bought cell phones for all five members of my family, opting for the Samsung Knack because it was a no-frills phone and I didn't want to open Pandora's box with my three teenagers. I went with a one year contract with Verizon just in case the expense of a family share plan was too much. We immediately began having problems with the phones. One phone had to be exchanged within two weeks, and since then we have had to replace three others for a total of four replacement phones in less than three months.
Needless to say, I contacted Verizon about the "lemons" and was told that we were stuck with them. According to our contract agreement, we could only replace phones with the same phones, so now I am getting reconditioned Knack phones, and based upon their track record thus far, I can expect to have 16 replacements before the contract expires.
My two kids who have been the heaviest users have had the most problems and required the replacement phones; however, there is no disclaimer that accompanies the phones indicating they are incapable of heavy use. The actual problems with the phones have run the gamut from not turning on, freezing, scrambling messages/data, menu functions that do not work, etc.
If you are over 50, you might not have any problems with the phones because you are using them on a limited basis. I would not recommend this phone to anyone who uses one throughout the day.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No