Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
There are TWO stories going on here..., August 16, 2009
This novel takes place during the Crusades. At first, there are so many different groups and tribes involved in the story, that one not familiar with the history of the Islamic world or Crusades or Templar Knights will have to do some googling. Once the reader figures out who is who, it is a decent enough story about a young woman named Khalidah. Khalidah was born into a nomad (traveling) Arab tribe and is a devout muslim. While the Franjs are waging war against the Sultan and those of his religion, Khalidah is escaping an unwanted marriage to her cruel cousin by drugging the entire camp and running away with a traveling singer.
The traveling singer, Sulayman, means to take Khalidah back to her long lost mother's people, the mysterious Jinn tribe. Upon arriving in the strange and beautiful land of her mother, Khalidah must make some difficult decisions. Is she ready to lead her people? She is next in line for leadership. And if she does choose to lead the Jinn, will she lead them into war against the Templar Knights? If she leads them to war and aides the Sultan, will she also be leading them to their deaths? Meanwhile, a romance has bloomed with Sulayman. Does she plan to act on her strong romantic feelings towards the traveling singer?
UNFORTUNATELY, Khalidah's story is only half of the novel. What the summary fails to tell potential readers is that there is another story going on as well. Every other chapter is about Khalidah's childhood friend Bilal. Bilal is going back and forth among the Franjs and the Sultan's warriors. It is thru Bilal's eyes that the Crusades and the drama surrounding it is explained. While learning the history tho, readers must also read about Bilal discovering he is gay and in love with the Sultan's son. Those not interested in reading about same sex love affairs may want to skip this novel.
I simply skipped every other chapter to get back to Khalidah's story. It was rather slow tho as most of the novel is about Khalidah traveling to Quaf (land of the Jinn) and having dreams about her mother while the romance blossoms with Sulayman.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Historical Fiction with a Strong Dose of Romance, December 28, 2009
The time of the Crusades seems to be a trend in historical fiction of late. In Sand Daughter, Khalidah, a Bedouin woman, finds herself wishing to escape an arranged marriage with her cousin. She runs away with a traveling singer named Sulayman. Together, they seek out the Jinn, Khalidah's mother's people. Along the way, the inevitable romance blossoms. The second plotline follows Khalidah's friend Bilal, who finds himself a double-agent between two factions. His same-sex romance with the son of a sultan is also explored.
There are many positives to this novel. Sarah Bryant has crafted one of the richest settings I have read in a historical fiction novel. Intrigue abounds, and the novel is filled with tension, as characters are always pressed to make difficult choices, thus exploring their own sets of values in the process. On the downside, the romance element was much too heavy for my liking, though I imagine that is due more to my own reading tastes than the content itself. I also did not enjoy Bilal's storyline as much as I did Khalidah's. It's a definite must-read for those who love historical romance.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Just skip the epilogue, November 30, 2011
There are those who will criticize the gay love affair that occurs in this novel. Well, let them. In terms of actual sexual content this book is rated G - any time anything happens it's just implied. Homosexuality in the medieval muslim world is well-documented so you at least can't attack the novel on those grounds. That aside, this fun, interesting, adventurous, and enjoyably readable little novel is soiled by a 10-page epilogue. I won't post any spoilers, but in the epilogue the author attempts to tie up some loose ends in her two primary characters, and does so in what feels like a very forced and unnecessary hollywood-happy-ending kind of way. In particular, Bilal's bits in the epilogue strain credulity. I strongly suspect that the editors did not like the way the novel ended and insisted that she tack on this unnecessary and discordant ending. So in summary, read this book! It's exciting and interesting and will immerse you in a great story and (for most people) an alien ancient culture. Just PLEASE don't read the epilogue. Or better yet, tear out the last 10 pages and burn them LOL
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|