Amazon.com Review
What a mess! And we're not just talking about the wad of bubble gum Sarah manages to stow in her hair one night while sleeping. There's also the matter of the basketball team, where her budding stardom is quickly doused by the realization that no one on her all-boy team realizes she's a girl, including the coach! And then there's the mystery of her new friend Olivia from Trinidad, who turns strangely moody when she's questioned too closely on certain subjects, such as why Sarah and their friend Christina aren't allowed to see Olivia's legs. Christina, meanwhile, is being forced to play the part of a Mexican in the school pageant, even though she comes from El Salvador (her teacher doesn't see the difference). Through it all, Sarah ponders the wisdom offered by her mother about life being like a party with an invitation that says "Come as you are." Is it better to give people the naked truth?
Elisa Carbone brings back the hilarious heroine of Starting School with an Enemy for this rollicking, yet matter-of-factly sensitive story. Ethnically diverse characters populate the pages, with easy-to-swallow messages about honesty, respect, and tolerance for imperfection. (Ages 9 to 12) --Emilie Coulter
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From Publishers Weekly
Fans of Starting School with an Enemy may well be disappointed in this middling sequel. Truth-telling is at the center of Carbone's meandering story, as fifth-grade Sarah and her friends, Christina and new neighbor Olivia, each grapple with a deceit of sorts. Soon after her mother cuts short Sarah's bubble-gum matted hair, the girl attends basketball tryouts, which, unbeknownst to her, is for a boys-only team. Incredibly, she plays on the team without realizing that the coach and her teammates don't know she is a girl. After discovering their misconception, Sarah decides to wait it out, but must come clean with the "naked truth" just before the team sets out on an overnight trip (during which the coach plans to throw the team into the shower). Meanwhile, Olivia, a recent arrival from Trinidad, finally reveals to her new best friends that she wears an artificial leg. With uncharacteristically obvious jokes, the author stretches her truth theme too thin. Despite the convincing dialogue that recommended the first episode starring Sarah, this novel, if truth be told, hits a few too many false notes. Ages 8-12. (Apr.)
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.