Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An American academic spends an epicurean year in Rome, February 24, 2007
Esthete, epicure, oenophile, academic, and Jewish and gay. Place in the Eternal City for a year and observe the interesting results. This memoir of the sabbatical year of a modest but multifaceted man in Rome is not, one would have to say, an exciting read. For a wild ride, see Felice Picano's Men Who Loved Me. Here is a book for those who appreciate the quieter pleasures: Renaissance sculpture, Roman history, wine, good food, and opera -- at least Mozart's Don Giovanni to which the author refers frequently. As blessedly free of the effete as any book of its type could possibly be, author Barkan describes his eventful Roman year, one with gastronomic and vinous indulgence at its core. We meet his very peculiarly Roman set of new friends, who are of a type that inhabit a very different world and in fact are a very different species than one would encounter in North America. Full of engaging digressions on a myriad of subjects, this book keeps the interest of those with a bent for food and wine, art and music. A glossary for the monolingual would have been nice. A map of Rome with locations noted is unfortunately missing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
WAY Over the Top, December 14, 2009
This review is from: Satyr Square: A Year, a Life in Rome (Paperback)
Argh, how to describe this weirdly-seasoned stew of a book? The author comes across as an over-intellectualized, neurotic, guiltily homosexual, prodigiously conceited, agonizingly self-conscious, precious academic snob--one of those inadvertent self-parodies that abound among the faculties of Ivy League universities.
Rome through his eyes seems to consist entirely of married men who, given their druthers, would really all be gay as daisies. But alas, they've made their choice to marry and all they can do is play frustrating little semi-sexual games with poor Barkan, most of them consisting of elaborate rituals involving food and wine. Are we supposed to feel sorry for the author because he's too neurotic to find himself an openly gay partner and have an affair? But that would be way too simple. Barkan would rather wallow in his self-absorbed and self-created complexities.
The most interesting part of this book consists of Barkan's struggles with the subtleties of the Italian language. But even here, the author's monumental conceit keeps getting in the way; he can't resist bragging to the reader over and over again about his mastery of so many languages and his considerable skills in Italian. He's not over-estimating those skills--his translations of some of the really raunchy "pasquinades" of the Renaissance are extremely clever.
If the book weren't set in Rome, I'd never have been able to finish it. But, in the moments when Barkan drops his obsession with handsome men, expensive wine, and gourmet food, it was fun to see familiar fragments of the Eternal City through (very!) different eyes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
buon vino, buona cucina, buona letteratura, buon sesso, July 8, 2007
This book is so intelligent and yet so pleasurable, or perhaps I should say so pleasurable and so intelligent, it makes me wish Barkin had more lives and had written memoirs about them all. His writing is perfectly pitched. We get not just the funny, rich, sensuous experiences of encounters with strangers and new wines and new language, but also the other things we all live through, crushes, and loneliness, and embarrassment, related with both unusual honesty and unusual humor. I think its a book for anyone, but if you've ever had a glass of wine that was a complete revelation, or listened over and over to Don Giovanni, or wandered through Rome alone, you really must spend some time in Barkan's wonderful company.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|